Most jarring moment:

• Sam rolling his eyes and sighing when Dean started talking about Hell AGAIN.

• Dean's 'I liked torturing' speech -- he didn't seem all that upset about it.

• All the heavy-handed 'we've been through tragedy' hints before we found out about Andy

• The Carters at the end: 'We're the opposite of ok but...we're together.' That's one to grow on!

• What are you complaining about? I liked the ep!