Jennifer Haymore's, A Hint of Wicked, was nominated in our Worst category. Does the heroine's twisted position and unfortunate flower placement seal its fate?

• No, the flower and heroine look awkward but it doesn't deserve to make the final 10 Worst covers.

• No, because beauty is in the eye of the beholder and I think it's a beautiful cover! Just look at the lush colors.

• Yes, because there is no excuse for poor execution. It belongs in the Worst final 10 for 2009.