Rickey.org is the "#1 American Idol fansite" on the Web according to Entertainment Weekly, and the source for "obsessive American Idol coverage" from BuzzFeed. Rickey writes about Reality TV, Lost, Heroes, and pop culture.

Surveydaddy
Check out Surveydaddy, the most easy-to-use survey software around. Start creating beautiful online surveys today.

Create an Online Survey

Should Howard Stern replace Simon Cowell?

Posted 2 years ago.

9 Comments

  • Kasey - 2 years ago

    I vote for Gene Simmons. He would be a valid replacement for Simon, IMHO.

  • bwatt27 - 2 years ago

    Howard Stern wouldn't be in good taste for this show. I'd be willing to bet my college fund that he won't be on the judging panel next season, but as flip-flop as FOX is, who really knows? Personally, I can't stand Stern, and wouldn't be too flattered with him being a judge on the show.

    And Dan, aren't you doing the same thing cheryl did by calling her a 'judgmental piece of shit?' She has the right to her opinion, granted she did take it pretty far with her calling-out on on his low points.

  • Hire Stern! AI NEEDS HIM! - 2 years ago

    Actually, I'd love to see Howard in this role. I a not a Howard Stern fan, but it would be nice to get someone who would tell it like it is....not like Simon....but, who will tell someone who is talentless that they were "okay". Let's face it...mediocre talents like Kris Allen would not be put through and that is needed. BTW, how is Kris' album selling? Rickey hasn't posted an update--which means that it's prob still sinking.

  • Dan - 2 years ago

    All I have to say is SHUT THE FUCK UP cheryl, you judgmental piece of shit!

  • cheryl - 2 years ago

    I am a huge fan of Amer. Idol. I have watched every season. If Howard Stearn becomes a judge, I will never watch again. That is the most disgusting human being I have ever heard or seen. The humiliation he puts on anyone and everyone is horrible, including his wife and family(or should I say ex-wife.) Why anyone would marry such a disgusting pig is beyond me. Nothing was private. Some things need to be. He has no respect for other human beings. None

  • Philip - 2 years ago

    My wheat side is saying "I know good and well this idea is just a pitiful publicity tactic", but my frosted side is saying "oh crap, FOX is serious!".

  • T - 2 years ago

    They are looking for someone as mean as Simon. they do need that with annoying, get-over-your-lame-self Kara the suck-up, boring Randy and nice Ellen. Not sure he is the right fit, but he will get folks to watch. So if that is what they are looking for, ratings--they should hire him. Think of the publicity. I'd bet he would quit after one season though.

  • Sue - 2 years ago

    Howard Stern would be in poor taste. This has to be some sort of publicity stunt or they are really desparte,

  • chuck menthol - 2 years ago

    I don't know if Howard could keep the language pg-13 but if he can, there would be noone more interesting. I mean cmon, Elton John?, why, because of the english accent? Booring. Howards got music experience too.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment