Can I just try to reignite some Andrew Garcia love here. Now, I can't defend his last two performances. They were, as Simon says, karaoke. His problem is that he is listening to the mentors and judges, which, in my opinion, is the absolute worst thing the contestants can do on the show. Andrew is there because we love his smooth low-key acoustic take on songs. He should be sticking to that. Like he did with Straight Up, Forever, and Sugar We're Going Down. Hopefully most of the voters have long since decided to ignore the inconsistent, rambling, indulgent, contradictory nonsense the judges have been spewing this season. I wish the contestants would too. And Adam Lambert as a mentor did not in any fashion that I saw on the telecast consider that these contestants all have their own style, and should not be critiqued into trying to be more like him. We didn't all love his outlandish performances. A lot of us voted for Kris Allen, remember. I hope Andrew gets a chance to get back to doing what he does best. DON'T LISTEN TO THE JUDGES.
I told Andrew Garcia right from TV, and in my mind about him to stop letting these people mention about him being terrible and awful, mentioning bad things about his Idol competition performance, because he's got talent. I told him also in my mind and from the TV, I am watching not to let these people get you down, including the judges, even though they're doing their jobs, in which I accept, but disappointments on his performances. The judges should have known better to treat him mean. He's done a good job, and I don't blame him, but the judges. He's still in my heart a number of times, a winner. I meant that, too.
sandie - 14 years ago
i like to watch crystal , lee, and casey they are the best the rest can go home sorry about that ,but it is ture and now siobhan she would make a good model not as singer and she dress nice. i think simmon is right about siobhan
KAREN KOPESKY - 14 years ago
Lee is the best Casey is really cool Tim is adorable and Katie should still be there next week...she has come a long way' Andrew and Mike probably not!!! Adam actually did a great job and my granddaughter is flippin...he's coming to Minnesota in June.
Crystal is ridiculous, and she doesn't deserve to win. She's always at the top. Andrew was the best, because he has the style, and sang it in a Latin version of Hound Dog, which he wasn't lazy, but will continue to keep it up. He deserves credit, to make him the winner. Lee is good, and as good, but want to have Andrew catch up with him. Aaron is good, and will be good, but a young guy with a heavy singing voice, who can rock. Siobhan is not good, and neither is Tim, who will leave tomorrow. Mike is good, but not too good, and he should have left last week. Casey, he's always good, but I just wished he'd being stopped being Mr. Perfect. Kate, she's too young for being singing jazzy songs. That's it for the comments on the Idols contestants with the help of former Idol mentor and performer Adam Lambert.
Can I just try to reignite some Andrew Garcia love here. Now, I can't defend his last two performances. They were, as Simon says, karaoke. His problem is that he is listening to the mentors and judges, which, in my opinion, is the absolute worst thing the contestants can do on the show. Andrew is there because we love his smooth low-key acoustic take on songs. He should be sticking to that. Like he did with Straight Up, Forever, and Sugar We're Going Down. Hopefully most of the voters have long since decided to ignore the inconsistent, rambling, indulgent, contradictory nonsense the judges have been spewing this season. I wish the contestants would too. And Adam Lambert as a mentor did not in any fashion that I saw on the telecast consider that these contestants all have their own style, and should not be critiqued into trying to be more like him. We didn't all love his outlandish performances. A lot of us voted for Kris Allen, remember. I hope Andrew gets a chance to get back to doing what he does best. DON'T LISTEN TO THE JUDGES.
I told Andrew Garcia right from TV, and in my mind about him to stop letting these people mention about him being terrible and awful, mentioning bad things about his Idol competition performance, because he's got talent. I told him also in my mind and from the TV, I am watching not to let these people get you down, including the judges, even though they're doing their jobs, in which I accept, but disappointments on his performances. The judges should have known better to treat him mean. He's done a good job, and I don't blame him, but the judges. He's still in my heart a number of times, a winner. I meant that, too.
i like to watch crystal , lee, and casey they are the best the rest can go home sorry about that ,but it is ture and now siobhan she would make a good model not as singer and she dress nice. i think simmon is right about siobhan
Lee is the best Casey is really cool Tim is adorable and Katie should still be there next week...she has come a long way' Andrew and Mike probably not!!! Adam actually did a great job and my granddaughter is flippin...he's coming to Minnesota in June.
Crystal is ridiculous, and she doesn't deserve to win. She's always at the top. Andrew was the best, because he has the style, and sang it in a Latin version of Hound Dog, which he wasn't lazy, but will continue to keep it up. He deserves credit, to make him the winner. Lee is good, and as good, but want to have Andrew catch up with him. Aaron is good, and will be good, but a young guy with a heavy singing voice, who can rock. Siobhan is not good, and neither is Tim, who will leave tomorrow. Mike is good, but not too good, and he should have left last week. Casey, he's always good, but I just wished he'd being stopped being Mr. Perfect. Kate, she's too young for being singing jazzy songs. That's it for the comments on the Idols contestants with the help of former Idol mentor and performer Adam Lambert.
Crystal Bowersox your the best I really hope you win this. you are incredable. Your really special