I have watched Idol since the beginning and some of the winners I think should have been runner up and the
runner up should have won. This year I think Lee is the best all around singer, Crystal is very good also. I
don't think Mike is good enough to be the winner, he is getting boring. Aaron will someday be a great singer,
he needs to mature more, will say he has earned his spot in this competition, we will see more of him for sure.
Siobhan I think can sing very well, but the screaming is not good, it worked for Adam last year, but he was a
unique entertainer, Siobhan needs more personality. Mike needs to loose his attitude and just be a singer.
It was moving when his wife had the baby, he was more real then, now he is getting annoying. My vote goes
to Casey over Mike. Sorry to see Tim go, he was real.
TooT - 14 years ago
I have nothing against Casey (third on my list) or Tim & Aaron. Michael, has anyone but me noticed that he only sings slow songs, which he is good at, but that's all he's done. And Siobhan can no doubt sing, but I'm tired of her explaining herself after every judging. She just rambles. She's different and that's great, but she is the one who keeps telling us how she is being compared to all these great artist. I think she is getting a bit of an annoying ego, right along with Michael. Since the very first show, way before all the hype I've thought it would come down to Crystal & Lee. Great performances, humble and I love the way they keep it real.
Genilu - 14 years ago
Crystal, top song of the night. Casey and Lee tied for second.
MS. ETS - 14 years ago
cystal was very good, but Mr Lynche was also good. He and crystal have the best vocals, and you have to be a vocalist to understand the quality in ones voice. Now I know it's about who can make the best record sells, but once you take the voice out of the studio u have nothing. Mr Lynche has a soulful voice, he was born to sing. Ms. Crstyal can hold her own. But do we want an American idol final, like we had last year. Boring. The guy that won last year couldn't hold a candle to Adams voice, but he won. And seson 8 final should have been between Adam and Danny, now that would have been a competition.That's what American Idol is, a competition. Two great singer battling it out!!!! But America voted 4 season 8 winner, because he fit into the catergory what American thinks a great American, and that may be true. He maybe a great family american man, but not a great american idol winner. America looked past the vocals of Adam and voted 4 someone else. Adam did not fit the category of a great American. But Adams recordd sells are out selling his opponent, and who won. Shouldn't the winner have the best record sells. Mr. Dewyze is not a great singer at all, and again will make the finals quite boring. it will not be an interesting competion. Lets listen to the vocals really good, before we vote for the wrong person again.
I have watched Idol since the beginning and some of the winners I think should have been runner up and the
runner up should have won. This year I think Lee is the best all around singer, Crystal is very good also. I
don't think Mike is good enough to be the winner, he is getting boring. Aaron will someday be a great singer,
he needs to mature more, will say he has earned his spot in this competition, we will see more of him for sure.
Siobhan I think can sing very well, but the screaming is not good, it worked for Adam last year, but he was a
unique entertainer, Siobhan needs more personality. Mike needs to loose his attitude and just be a singer.
It was moving when his wife had the baby, he was more real then, now he is getting annoying. My vote goes
to Casey over Mike. Sorry to see Tim go, he was real.
I have nothing against Casey (third on my list) or Tim & Aaron. Michael, has anyone but me noticed that he only sings slow songs, which he is good at, but that's all he's done. And Siobhan can no doubt sing, but I'm tired of her explaining herself after every judging. She just rambles. She's different and that's great, but she is the one who keeps telling us how she is being compared to all these great artist. I think she is getting a bit of an annoying ego, right along with Michael. Since the very first show, way before all the hype I've thought it would come down to Crystal & Lee. Great performances, humble and I love the way they keep it real.
Crystal, top song of the night. Casey and Lee tied for second.
cystal was very good, but Mr Lynche was also good. He and crystal have the best vocals, and you have to be a vocalist to understand the quality in ones voice. Now I know it's about who can make the best record sells, but once you take the voice out of the studio u have nothing. Mr Lynche has a soulful voice, he was born to sing. Ms. Crstyal can hold her own. But do we want an American idol final, like we had last year. Boring. The guy that won last year couldn't hold a candle to Adams voice, but he won. And seson 8 final should have been between Adam and Danny, now that would have been a competition.That's what American Idol is, a competition. Two great singer battling it out!!!! But America voted 4 season 8 winner, because he fit into the catergory what American thinks a great American, and that may be true. He maybe a great family american man, but not a great american idol winner. America looked past the vocals of Adam and voted 4 someone else. Adam did not fit the category of a great American. But Adams recordd sells are out selling his opponent, and who won. Shouldn't the winner have the best record sells. Mr. Dewyze is not a great singer at all, and again will make the finals quite boring. it will not be an interesting competion. Lets listen to the vocals really good, before we vote for the wrong person again.
Crystal WAS AMAZING