alice=ashley greene! and kellan lutz=emmet!!
i strongly disagree if they are replaced,because they already play there * in twilight, new moon and eclipse...
and they are very suitable in their roles!
they are supposed to be paid well even though they are not the main character, but they play an important role in the success of Twilight since the first movie's twilight made.
Chanene - 2 years ago
I would have a problem with recasting either of them simply because we have gotten used to them as emmitt and alice...... when i read the books, they are who i picture.... I really hate it when movie makers change the cast members in sequels....... it completely takes away from the whole experience...... personally i couldnt see anyone else playing alice the way that ashley greene does, yes she may be a novice with the acting....... but i have seen alot worse actors make it to the A list, and Kellan....... as adorable and boy next door as he is...... they would play hell replacing him with anyone that could be anywhere as close as big and cuddly as he is for a vampire........... DO NOT REPLACE THEM
Amanda N - 2 years ago
I have watched both Twilight and New moon and I cant wait to see Eclipse and read all of the books. When you are watching a movie you sort of engross your self with the characters. So I think that it will totally ruin breaking dawn if they replace either actor/actress. Neither one of them is the best actor/actress in these movies and most of the time people are paying attention to Bella, Edward and Jacob but it is the sense of family and both of them have been there from the begining. Both of them need to finish these movies and move on. I will not watch breaking dawn if they replace any actor/actress in these movies. I think it wasnt right that they replaced Rachelle.
Karyn - 2 years ago
I think it would be a disapointment to not have Kellan & Ashley in Breaking Dawn, according to the book Ashley has a very important as a good friend and sister to "Bella" and Kellan's parts seem to be more too. No, I don't think that they should be greedy in the money that they recieve as long as Summit is fair. We are used to seeing certain principle actors in this "SAGA" and to just "recast " as they have done with Rachelle, would be crazy!! They are part of the "Family" and it should stay the same...as long as they want to be there, hopefully Ash & Kellan will make a good decision and work with Summit.
jenna - 2 years ago
omg if they do replace them its stupid theve been in all of the movies and then theyre suddenly there replacing thenm they are really good actors if they wanna get rid of someone they should get rid of robert hes ugly and he cant act
Desi - 2 years ago
The movie in my opionon would be ruined! We are all so used to seeing Ashley as Alice and Kellan as Emmett!!! I love all the acting in the movies. If they were replaced i think lots of us would b P.O.d. Kellan makes an perfect big brother and Ashley makes a perfect sister.
TWILIGHT ROX
charlie - 2 years ago
what the hell!!!!! that cant happen and yes it makes a big difference you cant replace them two, fans would be really pissed off like how can u remove the main characters it make no sence what so ever its retarded i just hope it doesnt happen. as a fan i hope they make the right chose because one wrong mistake you can lose thousands of fan.
Love.Peace.Twilight.
Charlie
Debra Jones - 2 years ago
I thought it was horrible when they replaced Rachelle with the Howard girl. What a slap in the face, expecially since she had no idea she was going to replaced. Talk about Hollywood nepotism. That was so rude. I like the
actors that are in the film now. (excluding the howard girl) Why mess with a good thing.
Sabrina - 2 years ago
Ashley and Kellan may not be the best actors in the world, but everyone is so used to there faces it kinda ruins the scene completly. I love them both to be honest, i wouldnt have picked someone different to play alice, she looks allot like what i imagined she whould when i was reading the book... i dont think they need extra money when they do less acting then Kristen, Taylor, And Rob. but i dont think they should be cut, i hope they can sort this out, i really dont want them to leave!
Merlee - 2 years ago
As many others have said, Ashley actually ruined many scenes for me in New Moon and the only scene Kellan was in, he had one, maybe two lines and the way he delivered them was very static. Their caliber is just not worth what they are asking considering other secondary cast members have settled for less. It would be ludicrous for them, who actually have reduced roles if anything (Alice being gone for a big part of the book and Emmet barely having any speaking lines of consequence) to be paid higher. Like others stated, Summit may well be able to afford what they are asking (or more!) but it doesn't mean they should. Kellan and Ashley should be thankful they can ride the TWI-train as long as they can and get free press and possibly better roles than they could have ever achieved to get only based on their talent...
Stacie - 2 years ago
So sorry, but I disagree with general concensus here. This CAN'T happen!!! I know that Emmett and Alice don't really have a huge part in the books and/or the movies, but Ashely and Kellan are those characters for me at least. And yes, I would boycott Breaking Dawn if they weren't in the movie b/c, well, quite frankly, it's going to be a mess anyway, just like the book was. So, for me, no big deal not to see it if Summit let's them go! I think that Summit is being greedy...they can afford to pay these two whatever they are asking.
whitney - 2 years ago
In general Summit CAN replace Kellan and Ashley.
Will it make a difference? The answer is yes. After being in the other three movies if the roles of Emmett and Alice were to suddenly be replaced, fans would get very upset. By now fans are used to seeing Kellan as Emmett and Ashley as Alice. They associate their faces with that of their fictional characters. It would be disturbing to fans to suddenly see a completely new face as Emmett and Alice.
Should Kellan and Alice ask for more money? Yes and no. The both of them are becoming quite famous now since they now have many different roles in new movies especially Kellan. It only makes sense that as they get more famous the more money they get paid. However at the same time since they haven't become quite that famous they should be expecting lots more money.
So, should Summit pay Kellan and Ashley more? Yes and no. Summit has made a create deal of money from the fans that have gone to seen the Twilight movies not once but twice (some even more than that *know someone who went to the theater five times for each movie and bought the DVDs.*) and bought the DVDs. They can afford to pay Kellan and Ashley more. However, they shouldn't have to pay the full amount of money that Kellan and Ashley demand as they aren't that famous to generate that high a paycheck. What is needed is a compromise with Summit paying Kellan and Ashley more but Kellan and Ashley not asking/getting as much as they are demanding.
annoymous - 2 years ago
People actually feel it will make a difference? They both have minimal parts in Breaking Dawn, Kellan more so than Ashley but still.. I like them as the characters but they are being greedy, they need to get over themselves or they will get the boot! And I say good riddance... they both are sub-par actors in my eyes anyway. I'd still be more mad over Rachelle than if they kicked both Ashely and Kellan!
statcat - 2 years ago
Summit, please allow me to reiterate that some of us wanted Ashley fired anyways.
As for the ones who feel the other way, I'm sure they'll get over it. Clearly the fans didn't boycott NM after Rachelle was replaced.
I think Kellan will get the message if you fire Ashley first.
blue - 2 years ago
summit can replacing this 2 actors. no biggie and no different at all.
emmet only have few lines and alice, well, after new moon, and i am afraid that in eclipse too, ashley acting is bad. really bad. i always cringe every timesaw her scenes. never want to replay her scene at all in my DVD. LOL
emmet and alice is both cullen member family and to be frankly, twilight is far most ashley and kellan best acting to potraits them. if at BD they will replaceable, no one gonna miss them. summit can throws their money for making amazing movie but please, not to paid this D-list actors. please.
AmyLC - 2 years ago
OF COURSE IT WILL MATTER! ASHLEY GREENE IS THE BEST SISTER ANYONE COULD WANT, KELLAN PLAYS THE PERFECT BIG BROTHER!
Juli - 2 years ago
I think it's crap if they get replaced! I hate when movies have sequals and the cast has changed. It is so irritating! Especially bc there are so many parts to this saga, after the third film u are really getting the characters and then by the last film they are different. I think it will change the whole cast dynamic! I believe losing them would suck.
SydneyAlice - 2 years ago
While I love both actors, my feeling is they should be grateful for what this saga has given them, take the offer, and finish the series.
lala - 2 years ago
as long they not replace Rob and kristen, Twilight Saga still on the road!
ca - 2 years ago
Ashley Greene really ruined the scene when she comes back to Forks thinking Bella has drowned. Her acting just ruined the scene. Who cares if she gets recast!!!
Kellan is not irreplacable but has the perfect "big brother giving you a hard time" relationship.
Please replace Ashley. She deserves to get fired anyways.
alice=ashley greene! and kellan lutz=emmet!!
i strongly disagree if they are replaced,because they already play there * in twilight, new moon and eclipse...
and they are very suitable in their roles!
they are supposed to be paid well even though they are not the main character, but they play an important role in the success of Twilight since the first movie's twilight made.
I would have a problem with recasting either of them simply because we have gotten used to them as emmitt and alice...... when i read the books, they are who i picture.... I really hate it when movie makers change the cast members in sequels....... it completely takes away from the whole experience...... personally i couldnt see anyone else playing alice the way that ashley greene does, yes she may be a novice with the acting....... but i have seen alot worse actors make it to the A list, and Kellan....... as adorable and boy next door as he is...... they would play hell replacing him with anyone that could be anywhere as close as big and cuddly as he is for a vampire........... DO NOT REPLACE THEM
I have watched both Twilight and New moon and I cant wait to see Eclipse and read all of the books. When you are watching a movie you sort of engross your self with the characters. So I think that it will totally ruin breaking dawn if they replace either actor/actress. Neither one of them is the best actor/actress in these movies and most of the time people are paying attention to Bella, Edward and Jacob but it is the sense of family and both of them have been there from the begining. Both of them need to finish these movies and move on. I will not watch breaking dawn if they replace any actor/actress in these movies. I think it wasnt right that they replaced Rachelle.
I think it would be a disapointment to not have Kellan & Ashley in Breaking Dawn, according to the book Ashley has a very important as a good friend and sister to "Bella" and Kellan's parts seem to be more too. No, I don't think that they should be greedy in the money that they recieve as long as Summit is fair. We are used to seeing certain principle actors in this "SAGA" and to just "recast " as they have done with Rachelle, would be crazy!! They are part of the "Family" and it should stay the same...as long as they want to be there, hopefully Ash & Kellan will make a good decision and work with Summit.
omg if they do replace them its stupid theve been in all of the movies and then theyre suddenly there replacing thenm they are really good actors if they wanna get rid of someone they should get rid of robert hes ugly and he cant act
The movie in my opionon would be ruined! We are all so used to seeing Ashley as Alice and Kellan as Emmett!!! I love all the acting in the movies. If they were replaced i think lots of us would b P.O.d. Kellan makes an perfect big brother and Ashley makes a perfect sister.
TWILIGHT ROX
what the hell!!!!! that cant happen and yes it makes a big difference you cant replace them two, fans would be really pissed off like how can u remove the main characters it make no sence what so ever its retarded i just hope it doesnt happen. as a fan i hope they make the right chose because one wrong mistake you can lose thousands of fan.
Love.Peace.Twilight.
Charlie
I thought it was horrible when they replaced Rachelle with the Howard girl. What a slap in the face, expecially since she had no idea she was going to replaced. Talk about Hollywood nepotism. That was so rude. I like the
actors that are in the film now. (excluding the howard girl) Why mess with a good thing.
Ashley and Kellan may not be the best actors in the world, but everyone is so used to there faces it kinda ruins the scene completly. I love them both to be honest, i wouldnt have picked someone different to play alice, she looks allot like what i imagined she whould when i was reading the book... i dont think they need extra money when they do less acting then Kristen, Taylor, And Rob. but i dont think they should be cut, i hope they can sort this out, i really dont want them to leave!
As many others have said, Ashley actually ruined many scenes for me in New Moon and the only scene Kellan was in, he had one, maybe two lines and the way he delivered them was very static. Their caliber is just not worth what they are asking considering other secondary cast members have settled for less. It would be ludicrous for them, who actually have reduced roles if anything (Alice being gone for a big part of the book and Emmet barely having any speaking lines of consequence) to be paid higher. Like others stated, Summit may well be able to afford what they are asking (or more!) but it doesn't mean they should. Kellan and Ashley should be thankful they can ride the TWI-train as long as they can and get free press and possibly better roles than they could have ever achieved to get only based on their talent...
So sorry, but I disagree with general concensus here. This CAN'T happen!!! I know that Emmett and Alice don't really have a huge part in the books and/or the movies, but Ashely and Kellan are those characters for me at least. And yes, I would boycott Breaking Dawn if they weren't in the movie b/c, well, quite frankly, it's going to be a mess anyway, just like the book was. So, for me, no big deal not to see it if Summit let's them go! I think that Summit is being greedy...they can afford to pay these two whatever they are asking.
In general Summit CAN replace Kellan and Ashley.
Will it make a difference? The answer is yes. After being in the other three movies if the roles of Emmett and Alice were to suddenly be replaced, fans would get very upset. By now fans are used to seeing Kellan as Emmett and Ashley as Alice. They associate their faces with that of their fictional characters. It would be disturbing to fans to suddenly see a completely new face as Emmett and Alice.
Should Kellan and Alice ask for more money? Yes and no. The both of them are becoming quite famous now since they now have many different roles in new movies especially Kellan. It only makes sense that as they get more famous the more money they get paid. However at the same time since they haven't become quite that famous they should be expecting lots more money.
So, should Summit pay Kellan and Ashley more? Yes and no. Summit has made a create deal of money from the fans that have gone to seen the Twilight movies not once but twice (some even more than that *know someone who went to the theater five times for each movie and bought the DVDs.*) and bought the DVDs. They can afford to pay Kellan and Ashley more. However, they shouldn't have to pay the full amount of money that Kellan and Ashley demand as they aren't that famous to generate that high a paycheck. What is needed is a compromise with Summit paying Kellan and Ashley more but Kellan and Ashley not asking/getting as much as they are demanding.
People actually feel it will make a difference? They both have minimal parts in Breaking Dawn, Kellan more so than Ashley but still.. I like them as the characters but they are being greedy, they need to get over themselves or they will get the boot! And I say good riddance... they both are sub-par actors in my eyes anyway. I'd still be more mad over Rachelle than if they kicked both Ashely and Kellan!
Summit, please allow me to reiterate that some of us wanted Ashley fired anyways.
As for the ones who feel the other way, I'm sure they'll get over it. Clearly the fans didn't boycott NM after Rachelle was replaced.
I think Kellan will get the message if you fire Ashley first.
summit can replacing this 2 actors. no biggie and no different at all.
emmet only have few lines and alice, well, after new moon, and i am afraid that in eclipse too, ashley acting is bad. really bad. i always cringe every timesaw her scenes. never want to replay her scene at all in my DVD. LOL
emmet and alice is both cullen member family and to be frankly, twilight is far most ashley and kellan best acting to potraits them. if at BD they will replaceable, no one gonna miss them. summit can throws their money for making amazing movie but please, not to paid this D-list actors. please.
OF COURSE IT WILL MATTER! ASHLEY GREENE IS THE BEST SISTER ANYONE COULD WANT, KELLAN PLAYS THE PERFECT BIG BROTHER!
I think it's crap if they get replaced! I hate when movies have sequals and the cast has changed. It is so irritating! Especially bc there are so many parts to this saga, after the third film u are really getting the characters and then by the last film they are different. I think it will change the whole cast dynamic! I believe losing them would suck.
While I love both actors, my feeling is they should be grateful for what this saga has given them, take the offer, and finish the series.
as long they not replace Rob and kristen, Twilight Saga still on the road!
Ashley Greene really ruined the scene when she comes back to Forks thinking Bella has drowned. Her acting just ruined the scene. Who cares if she gets recast!!!
Kellan is not irreplacable but has the perfect "big brother giving you a hard time" relationship.
Please replace Ashley. She deserves to get fired anyways.