Should children born in the United States be U.S. citizens, whether or not their parents are?

11 Comments

  • BGUNN - 14 years ago

    THE 14 AMENDMENT WAS MEANT TO PROTECT THE BABIES OF SLAVES AND GIVE THEM CITIZENSHIP. It was Not meant to give the illegal invaders the same right AND MUST BE RATIFIED TO STOP THIS HORRIFIC SITUATION. I WILL HOUND ILLEGALS,CALL SEN-CONGRESSMAN,HOUND BUSSINESS OWNERS THAT HIRE AND DO WHATEVER I CAN TO HELP STOP IT..

  • tom lynch - 14 years ago

    get em outa here, we are the only country in the universe that allows children born to illegals who then become citizens, where is the logic? Get the coattail SOB's back to where they came from, or do it the RIGHT way or the HIGHWAY!! We don't need your freeloading any more!!

  • dee mcnamara - 14 years ago

    As a legal immigrant as is the tradition, for more than 200 years, I reSent uneducated,non-engliash speaking elements crawling over our borders and STEALING ANY PART OF THIS COUNTRY,INCLUDING THE MOMENT THEY ILLEGAL CROSS US BORDERS, WELLFARE MONEY OF AMERICANS,HOSPITAL CARE, WHEN AMERICANS MUST PAY FOR THOSE THIEVES, WITH HARD WORK BY LEGAL IMMIGRANTS!STOP THE LOCUST!

    THOSE NATIONAL BORDERS VIOLATING THIEVES,
    MAKING AMERICANS PAY IN HOSPITALS, FOR THEIR BREEDING MACHINES WHEN CRAWLING INTO OUR LEGAL AMERICANS PAID FOR STOLEN HOSPITAL CARE. THAT BROOD OF u.s. NATIONALITY THIEVES IS NOT LEGAL BY ANY SOCIALLY EVOLVED HUMAN STANDARDS!

    ILEGGALS APPEAR TO HAVE LEARNED TO WALK UPRIGHT!THEY HAVE JAILS IN THEIR COUNTRY FOR THIEVES!

    LET THEM MAKE THEIR LEGAL DEMANDS TO THEIR OWN GOVERNMENTS, HOLD THEIR DEMONSTRATION FOR THEIR SOCIAL JUSTICE FOR THEIR OWN GOVERNMENTS. LEGAL HARDOWRKING AMERICANS OWE THOSE THIEVES OF THIS COUNTRY, NOTHING BUT DEPORTATION OF THAT LOCUST!

    PREVENT UNDERMINING OF AMERICA'S SOCIAL FABRIC, DEPORT THE ILLEGAL THIEVES OF THIS COUNTRY. THEY HAVE A COUNTRY OF THEIR OWN, THEY CREATED!!!
    LET THEM KEEP THEIR PRIMITIVE,BESTIAL CULTURE IN THEIR HOMELAMD!

    THOSE LOSERS, WHO DON'T LIKE THIS LEGALLY CREATED COUNTRY GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN, DEMONSTRATE THERE TODAY!
    DON'T BITE THE HAND THAT FEEDS YOU!
    ONLY LOSERS AND PARASITES DO THAT, DESPERATE FOR ATTENTION TO THEIR INSIGNIFICANCE!
    DEE

  • dee mcnamara - 14 years ago

    As a legal immigrant as is the tradition, for more than 200 years, I reSent uneducated,non-engliash speaking elements crawling over our borders and STEALING ANY PART OF THIS COUNTRY,INCLUDING THE MOMENT THEY ILLEGAL CROSS US BORDERS, WELLFARE MONEY OF AMERICANS,HOSPITAL CARE, WHEN AMERICANS MUST PAY FOR THOSE THIEVES, WITH HARD WORK BY LEGAL IMMIGRANTS!STOP THE LOCUST!

    THOSE NATIONAL BORDERS VIOLATING THIEVES,
    MAKING AMERICANS PAY IN HOSPITALS, FOR THEIR BREEDING MACHINES WHEN CRAWLING INTO OUR LEGAL AMERICANS PAID FOR STOLEN HOSPITAL CARE. THAT BROOD OF u.s. NATIONALITY THIEVES IS NOT LEGAL BY ANY SOCIALLY EVOLVED HUMAN STANDARDS!

    ILEGGALS APPEAR TO HAVE LEARNED TO WALK UPRIGHT!THEY HAVE JAILS IN THEIR COUNTRY FOR THIEVES!

    LET THEM MAKE THEIR LEGAL DEMANDS TO THEIR OWN GOVERNMENTS, HOLD THEIR DEMONSTRATION FOR THEIR SOCIAL JUSTICE FOR THEIR OWN GOVERNMENTS. LEGAL HARDOWRKING AMERICANS OWE THOSE THIEVES OF THIS COUNTRY, NOTHING BUT DEPORTATION OF THAT LOCUST!

    PREVENT UNDERMINING OF AMERICA'S SOCIAL FABRIC, DEPORT THE ILLEGAL THIEVES OF THIS COUNTRY. THEY HAVE A COUNTRY OF THEIR OWN, THEY CREATED!!!
    LET THEM KEEP THEIR PRIMITIVE,BESTIAL CULTURE IN THEIR HOMELAMD!

    THOSE LOSERS, WHO DON'T LIKE THIS LEGALLY CREATED COUNTRY GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN, DEMONSTRATE THERE TODAY!
    DON'T BITE THE HAND THAT FEEDS YOU!
    ONLY LOSERS AND PARASITES DO THAT, DESPERATE FOR ATTENTION TO THEIR INSIGNIFICANCE!
    DEE

  • fastfinger - 14 years ago

    Has anyone seen a copy of Obama's birth certificate? He traveled abroad and had to use a foreign passport - why did he not have an American passport? Freedom of information only is FREE when it's for everyone - and Obama is hiding tons - just try to read any of his law school papers, even though he was prominent on law review, nothing is public about his writings - why?

  • Helene - 14 years ago

    To the best of my knowledge, no other country allows for "anchor babies." In fact, my British, now American husband tell me that if you are the child of British parents, born in another country, you are not not automatically a British citizen. You can apply and get your citizenship the legal way.

  • Julie Ceballos - 14 years ago

    As a Native American Indian, I feel that the first time an illegal immigrant had an 'anchor baby' was the first time a pilgrim gave birth on American soil.. If you are on this page and u are white, then guess what, U ARE AN A DESCENDANT OF AN IMMIGRANT AND\OR AN ANCHOR BABY.... SHUT UR MOUTH, CUZ US INDIAN'S WUD REALLY LIKE OUR LANDS BACK.. DEPORT YOURSELVES BACK TO EUROPE!!!!!

  • Sharenlee - 14 years ago

    Well Sylvia - the problem is people like you. You are most likely illegal and don't get the fact the Americans do not want their country to be invaded by illegals. Some politicians think if they get the hispanic vote they will win. This have been proven to be wrong is the recent elections. 90% if Americans support Arizona. Go back to your country and try to make it a better place to live. Our forefathers had nothing, absolutely nothing and built this country from scratch. I suggest you go back home and do the same. Stop trying to live off our backs. We are done with you!

  • RUcerious? - 14 years ago

    @Sylvia,

    Starting at the top, it is ignorant, classless, and disrespectful, to tell someone to shut up. Second you shouldn't be calling someone else ignorant if you cannot spell the work correctly. Third, the beauty of living in America is we don't have to go to "run away" to another country. Fourth, and most important, I am the child of an immigrant family. When my parents came to America they had to learn to speak, and read English, they had to learn good manners and the "American Way' because they no longer lived in Italy or Greece. They did not speak Italian, or Greek, in public places, as it was considered an INSULT to the rest of America to not learn the native language of this country.

    And with regards to "prayer" I suggest you spend more time reading, and understanding the Bible, and the teachings of Jesus Christ before you ask other people to do the same. Christ was very clear about who has the right to judge, and trust me it isn't you.

    If you don't like this country I suggest you go back to where ever you came from. If you, or anyone else, is here illegally you are breaking the law and you should be treated as a criminal. Hopefully all illegals will be offered the opportunity, involuntarily, to return to the homeland, where they can reform their own governments rather than burden our society with their arrognat demands to be considered above the law.

  • jflorida - 14 years ago

    Illegal search and seizure decisions basically ruled that if evidence were obtained by other than legal means then any evidence could not be used against a person - - then how does the illegal act of sneaking into the country bear a legal act of creating a citizen?????????????? It can't it shouldn't it doen't The fourteenth amendment was created in the months following the civil war to protect only freed slaves who were still not considered people or citizens. It was meant to ensure that slave decendents were allowed to become citizens!!!!

  • Sylvia - 14 years ago

    I think they should become citizens and he rule should not change. All the people that said no and have a problem with it just needs to shut up. You are very ingorent i hope and pray you never have to go to another country to live or need to run away there. They are human to it's suppose to be a free country. I am so sick and tired of the immigration law arizona is trying to start i pray it don't come to florida, and if you don't like my comment then you need to prayer.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment