This poll is ridiculous. Of course Reggie Bush should be able to keep his Heisman Trophy! Sure he's off in the NFL now making millions of dollars but who cares. He was undoubtedly the best player in 2005 and thats what matters. He recieved more first place votes than Vince Young and Matt Leinart COMBINED! How are you going to say he doesn't deserve it? He OBVIOUSLY proved that he deserved that trophy, so why take it away?
Sam - 14 years ago
Yes Reggie was the best college football player in 05, the best player without an ounce of integrity. Even now, what a total lack of character to hide behind his superbowl ring and $$$$. And where's Pete Carrol? Mike Garret should be replaced, but at minimum he faced the music.
Trevor - 14 years ago
Are you kidding me. Yeah we cheered for Reggie when he was playing but I had no idea he was cheating and yes he was cheating. Reggie was having all stress of real life taken care of while everyone else have to deal. That's not fair and called cheating. Bye bye Hesiman
Reggie Bush won the Heisman for what he did on THE FIELD!! He should be able to keep it!
Keishia - 14 years ago
What Reggie did may have been wrong, but it has no bearing on the fact that he was the best college player in 2005. Go Reggie Bush!!!!
TA - 14 years ago
Why can we get to the sports agents who lured Reggie and other great athletes to the money and gifts! It's always the athletes and schools who have to pay the price where the agents get off free to go and screw another great player and school!
Tony Munf - 14 years ago
All you Reggie Bush and Mike Garret haters werent to mad at them when they were winning national titles and Heisman Trophies for the school were you?..Reggie Bush and Mr Garrett put USC football back on the map and made them a name again in college football. Reggie filled that coliseum every saturday and made the school millions of dollars and help sale millions of school merchandise of which he didnt get a single penny of. He was a 19 year old kid who "maybe" made a mistake. You rooted for him then with no problem, so root for him now. He is and allways will be a USC TROJAN!! Fight On Mr Garret and Mr Bush!!!
Reggie Bush is NOT deserving of the Heisman Trophy, any more than Mike Garrett is deserving to stay on as Athletic Director. While I was at USC in the mid-70's, we may have had issues to confront, but nothing as irresponsible as the behavior of these two. The school should not be penalized for the careless behavior of both Bush and Garrett. Pete Rose is not in baseballs Hall of Fame because he is an idiot who thought of himself only. The same can be said of Bush and Garrett. Fight on!
tstewart22 - 14 years ago
Simply put, who was the best football playefr in 2005? Reggie Bush!
This poll is ridiculous. Of course Reggie Bush should be able to keep his Heisman Trophy! Sure he's off in the NFL now making millions of dollars but who cares. He was undoubtedly the best player in 2005 and thats what matters. He recieved more first place votes than Vince Young and Matt Leinart COMBINED! How are you going to say he doesn't deserve it? He OBVIOUSLY proved that he deserved that trophy, so why take it away?
Yes Reggie was the best college football player in 05, the best player without an ounce of integrity. Even now, what a total lack of character to hide behind his superbowl ring and $$$$. And where's Pete Carrol? Mike Garret should be replaced, but at minimum he faced the music.
Are you kidding me. Yeah we cheered for Reggie when he was playing but I had no idea he was cheating and yes he was cheating. Reggie was having all stress of real life taken care of while everyone else have to deal. That's not fair and called cheating. Bye bye Hesiman
Reggie Bush won the Heisman for what he did on THE FIELD!! He should be able to keep it!
What Reggie did may have been wrong, but it has no bearing on the fact that he was the best college player in 2005. Go Reggie Bush!!!!
Why can we get to the sports agents who lured Reggie and other great athletes to the money and gifts! It's always the athletes and schools who have to pay the price where the agents get off free to go and screw another great player and school!
All you Reggie Bush and Mike Garret haters werent to mad at them when they were winning national titles and Heisman Trophies for the school were you?..Reggie Bush and Mr Garrett put USC football back on the map and made them a name again in college football. Reggie filled that coliseum every saturday and made the school millions of dollars and help sale millions of school merchandise of which he didnt get a single penny of. He was a 19 year old kid who "maybe" made a mistake. You rooted for him then with no problem, so root for him now. He is and allways will be a USC TROJAN!! Fight On Mr Garret and Mr Bush!!!
Reggie Bush is NOT deserving of the Heisman Trophy, any more than Mike Garrett is deserving to stay on as Athletic Director. While I was at USC in the mid-70's, we may have had issues to confront, but nothing as irresponsible as the behavior of these two. The school should not be penalized for the careless behavior of both Bush and Garrett. Pete Rose is not in baseballs Hall of Fame because he is an idiot who thought of himself only. The same can be said of Bush and Garrett. Fight on!
Simply put, who was the best football playefr in 2005? Reggie Bush!