Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo

Cage Match--Villains! -- Who will win: Darth Vader or Murtagh? (Poll Closed)

  •  
     
  •  
     
Total Votes: 1,079
19 Comments

  • Emoraz - 13 years ago

    OMG 12 deathwords darth vader >: u die!!!!!! u r such a
    v v
    (`@`) pig

  • Arya - 13 years ago

    back just one thing
    I

  • Arya - 13 years ago

    Ok now right now if it were me all I would use was one of the 12 words of death. anyone who read the series would agree with me because, one, murtagh has help from the eldarundi, and two, he is one of the best magician in eragons world, in the whole realm of books in my opinion. if it were murtagh AND eragon then sorry darth vader but.... YOU TOAST!!!! Darth vader wouldn't last more than two seconds in that field because it takes like one second to do one word of death so COME ON PEOPLE!!!!! He was already toast when just murtagh was on the scene so GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD BYYYYYYYYE Darth Vader!

    I

  • Ayame - 13 years ago

    Agreed with most everyone that Murtag should have won this battle or it atleast should have had more blood shed. Everyone who has read the Inheritance cycle knows that 1) Thorn may be a confuzed dragon but even Murtag knows better than to let his dragon attack someone who has the ablity to slice through their armor scales just about everything but their heart of hearts. 2) Murtag would have erected wards against fire 3) the other hearts that he (Murtag) poseses hold enough magic to repair Thorn's wounds. 4) all it would take is removing Darth Vader's head to end this whole stupid thing to begin with... AND HIS HEAD ISNT EVEN REALLY ATTACHED!!!

  • megameg - 13 years ago

    this was obviously was written by a baist star wars fan. mertagh would win all the way because he has almost unlimited amount of power from his connection with Galbetorix. i do think it would be harder to kill D.V than most of you give him credit for he dose have the Jedi skill of mind altering (common "these are not the droids you are looking for") so obviously the Jedi have some control over their own mind and the minds of susceptible people around them. i believe this might make it more difficult for mertage to break into his mind make him kill himself. Anyway murtagh would win all the way because he has his faithful dragon beside him.

  • joseph - 13 years ago

    murtagh could have killed darth vader in less than a second, without any effort at all, its not a contest

  • Eugene - 13 years ago

    yeah man darth vader couldn't stand a chance. even if he could summon the dead. i mean is could of used the dragon as a distraction then uttered a death word or 2. burst a artery in the brain kills pple very quickly

  • Aussie - 13 years ago

    Note murtagah could also easily have broken into darths mind and made him kill himself as its not something the jedi learn (mind protection)

  • Aussie - 13 years ago

    Soz previous dude as above words of death or drain energy pluss prettty sure theree would be many spells of concealment + even if darth saw him comin kinda hard 2 run away from a fuckin dragon dude

  • bull - 13 years ago

    the force would have alerted vader to any attack murtagh could have before murtagh could even think about. and a sith lord wouldnt dwell on the dead ppl of the past. sry guys murtagh and eargon togather wounldnt stand a chance against the dark lord of the sith

  • I'm not sayin - 13 years ago

    Anyone who has read the Inheritance Cycle KNOWS that Murtagh will win. DUH!

  • steven - 13 years ago

    hey murtagh may have the added power of the eldinuairy(sorry spelt wrong) so to be honest screw the force and dragons breath fire so darth gets roasted in his own helmet as for the light saber yea not much use buddy if you cant even reach the guy im sorry but you is toast boy!! yow

  • robb - 13 years ago

    Death words, HEART OF HEARTS strength, aided by Galbatorix, elements at his command, possibly making a true name slave of vader in the process. whoever did this pol was obviously a star wars fan and nobody mentioned that although its unpredictable and dangerous Murtagh can access magic without speaking. Darth has NO CHANCE

  • jesse - 13 years ago

    that was an un fair match! lazor sword vs elf steel? the lazar would cut right through it!

  • C3po - 13 years ago

    great story but sorry Darth Vader didn't stand a chance Murtagh didn't even fight and only had to utter a word of death to snap the vein in Darth Vader's neck. It would have been a 2 second encounter without Murtagh ever needing to get off Thorn's back before flying away with Darth Vader dead on the ground below. still the story was good, but wasn't logical there is no hero from any movie or book i've yet read about that can defeat one of the dragonriders from Mr. Paolini's books. Hands up to Eragon

  • Anonymous inheritance cycle fan - 13 years ago

    I agree with all the above people and murtagh would be able to kill vader easily plus he may know how to suck the energy out of other things in this case vader and then destroy the body with it's own energy

  • Dragon's Bane 256 - 13 years ago

    No way man. If Saphira can turn rock into diamond without batting an eyelash, there's NO WAY Thorn would be so easily put aside. NO. WAY. This scenario is only remotely possible if a DRAGON was naive enough to attack from straight above, which they usually aren't. No way, man. Murtagh all the way.

  • Brandon Gallegos - 13 years ago

    I agree that murtagh could have killed vader with a simple spell. a quick word of death and that would have ended the fight. I mean, its not like vader has any wards to protect him from spells. and, murtagh would have healed thorn the instant he had the chance, not rushed vader like an idiot. clearly, who ever made this prediction and story have close to no idea what they're talking about. It's murtagh and thorn all the way baby.

  • Eragon - 14 years ago

    12 words of death? even if vader immediatley started choking him he wouldnt even need to speak the ancient language to use one of the spells. a little less dramatic but thats the world paolini created

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.