Pia? I dont think so she is a whinner, and no one likes that. I am glad they got ride of her. The most talented is Casey but unfortunatly the little kids who have cell phones are voting for Scott, because he is cute. We will see.
Julie - 13 years ago
Pia is talented, but she is like SO many other stage singers. Can she go up against today's female chart toppers (of which there are many?) With Rihanna, Britney, Katy, Gaga and even J-Lo who is never going to leave dominating the radio, there won't be time to play her. Her style is old school, Celine Dion style performing.
piri - 13 years ago
None of these front-runners will sell many records/cds. They appear to be mirroring previous contestants. They are novel at best but when it comes to serious support after idol, the non-front-runners have more appeal, imagination, uniqueness and a loyal long-term following.
For me it's Haley, Naima, Jacob or Casey; if there were huge protests in the US, possibly even Paul
R.Bella - 13 years ago
Pia is amazing I know she just stands there and sings but once she takes Jennifer's advice to move around a little she will be fine. I think Haley is totally awkward, the way she walked down the stairs as she was singing was so weird she deserves to go or Thia now she is a bore fest!!!!!
ezeddy2 - 13 years ago
I think Thia is the dark horse here. She just keeps growing each week and I think she will be there in the top 4
Jo - 13 years ago
James is not what American will consider an 'idol'! Pia will win if she steps up her songs, and moves some on the stage. Casey doesn't appear to be healthy, I hope his health gets better.
Sarah - 13 years ago
Pia is boring and won't sell CD's, pretty and talented but that is it, same goes for Lauren. I love James and Scotty, both are unique in their sound, same with Paul. What was with Casey being at the bottom? I say the voting is rigged, Thia needs to go and so does Haley, one is too young and the other can't sing. As for a guy winning then what happened last week, a couple of girls should have been there, there was a reason for that - they knew the judges would use their save for him and not for Stefano simple.
Shannon - 13 years ago
Pia is extremely boring, I don't understand how she hasn't been in the bottom yet. In my opinion I think Paul McDonald has the kind of voice that will really make out in the real world, people will pay to hear his voice. As for people like Pia or Jacob go, their voices are something you fall asleep to.
Vada - 13 years ago
James Durbin should win. I thought his Living For The City was brilliant. I don't know what Randy was hearing, but it sounded great over my TV speakers. James is Adam Lambert with a more pleasant vocal tone. He can power the high notes, instead of leaning on falsetto.
monleo - 13 years ago
I voted for PIA of course! Heheh, but then again, i have a few favourites. In terms of vocal power, definitely the ones who stand out are Pia, James and Lauren. So i would certainly not mind if any of them won. Even though Jacob has power, he sounds like a crazy horse everytime he sings...NO.THANKS.
K - 13 years ago
james durbin is the new ARENA ROCK STAR
Ally - 13 years ago
I think that Pia has the best classical/pop voice but Scotty has the best country voice (obviously). Lauren is one of my favorites because she is a cross-over between country and pop. I voted for Pia because even though she sings the exact same kind of music, she pulls it off every time.
Kat - 13 years ago
My Fav is James. But who has the whole package? Who will we hear on the radio for years to come? Who will sell out concerts and sell millions of records? I would have to go with Scotty. Seriously people,Beautiful face and voice,but would you pay money to see Pia stand like a statue for 3 hours and put you to sleep with ballads? yeah, me neither!
kclady - 13 years ago
They got some great talent this year but got to keep up..... so time will tell.
GO PIA - JAMES - SCOTTY!!
Boys Over Girls - 13 years ago
I find it hard to believe that Pia is so popular. She is lovely and can sing, but is sooooo boring. Every week is the same thing. Just can't see it.
Jan - 13 years ago
PIA should win although I don't know whether America will be voting for her. She's the whole package. She's beautiful, talented, her voice is pitch perfect. If Scotty aka Alfred E Newman wins it, then America obviously does not know what singing is all about. Go Pia! Love you! xxx
ebonyandivory - 13 years ago
I voted for Pia in the above poll, but ,on second thought, she isn't the front runner because she's the wrong sex. I know it isn't fair, but the front runner/winner will most likely be a guy because most of the viewers and voters are female. Unless a girl is OUTSTANDING (EXTREMELY TALENTED WITH VOICE AND PERSONALITY) other girls will vote for a good-lookin' guy every time. As far as vocal ability goes, I think the prize should go to Pia, Haley or Scotty. Pia's voice is beautiful and she has a lot of control and versatility. I think the same can be said of Haley and I was shocked to see her in the bottom 3. Her voice has a special sound--different. Her control is unbelievable. Range too. I love Scotty's deep baritone and I'm sure a lot of the other women do too. But I was pleasantly surprised by his version of Motown's "For Once In My Life." I'm just glad I don't have to be the only judge!
Pia? I dont think so she is a whinner, and no one likes that. I am glad they got ride of her. The most talented is Casey but unfortunatly the little kids who have cell phones are voting for Scott, because he is cute. We will see.
Pia is talented, but she is like SO many other stage singers. Can she go up against today's female chart toppers (of which there are many?) With Rihanna, Britney, Katy, Gaga and even J-Lo who is never going to leave dominating the radio, there won't be time to play her. Her style is old school, Celine Dion style performing.
None of these front-runners will sell many records/cds. They appear to be mirroring previous contestants. They are novel at best but when it comes to serious support after idol, the non-front-runners have more appeal, imagination, uniqueness and a loyal long-term following.
For me it's Haley, Naima, Jacob or Casey; if there were huge protests in the US, possibly even Paul
Pia is amazing I know she just stands there and sings but once she takes Jennifer's advice to move around a little she will be fine. I think Haley is totally awkward, the way she walked down the stairs as she was singing was so weird she deserves to go or Thia now she is a bore fest!!!!!
I think Thia is the dark horse here. She just keeps growing each week and I think she will be there in the top 4
James is not what American will consider an 'idol'! Pia will win if she steps up her songs, and moves some on the stage. Casey doesn't appear to be healthy, I hope his health gets better.
Pia is boring and won't sell CD's, pretty and talented but that is it, same goes for Lauren. I love James and Scotty, both are unique in their sound, same with Paul. What was with Casey being at the bottom? I say the voting is rigged, Thia needs to go and so does Haley, one is too young and the other can't sing. As for a guy winning then what happened last week, a couple of girls should have been there, there was a reason for that - they knew the judges would use their save for him and not for Stefano simple.
Pia is extremely boring, I don't understand how she hasn't been in the bottom yet. In my opinion I think Paul McDonald has the kind of voice that will really make out in the real world, people will pay to hear his voice. As for people like Pia or Jacob go, their voices are something you fall asleep to.
James Durbin should win. I thought his Living For The City was brilliant. I don't know what Randy was hearing, but it sounded great over my TV speakers. James is Adam Lambert with a more pleasant vocal tone. He can power the high notes, instead of leaning on falsetto.
I voted for PIA of course! Heheh, but then again, i have a few favourites. In terms of vocal power, definitely the ones who stand out are Pia, James and Lauren. So i would certainly not mind if any of them won. Even though Jacob has power, he sounds like a crazy horse everytime he sings...NO.THANKS.
james durbin is the new ARENA ROCK STAR
I think that Pia has the best classical/pop voice but Scotty has the best country voice (obviously). Lauren is one of my favorites because she is a cross-over between country and pop. I voted for Pia because even though she sings the exact same kind of music, she pulls it off every time.
My Fav is James. But who has the whole package? Who will we hear on the radio for years to come? Who will sell out concerts and sell millions of records? I would have to go with Scotty. Seriously people,Beautiful face and voice,but would you pay money to see Pia stand like a statue for 3 hours and put you to sleep with ballads? yeah, me neither!
They got some great talent this year but got to keep up..... so time will tell.
GO PIA - JAMES - SCOTTY!!
I find it hard to believe that Pia is so popular. She is lovely and can sing, but is sooooo boring. Every week is the same thing. Just can't see it.
PIA should win although I don't know whether America will be voting for her. She's the whole package. She's beautiful, talented, her voice is pitch perfect. If Scotty aka Alfred E Newman wins it, then America obviously does not know what singing is all about. Go Pia! Love you! xxx
I voted for Pia in the above poll, but ,on second thought, she isn't the front runner because she's the wrong sex. I know it isn't fair, but the front runner/winner will most likely be a guy because most of the viewers and voters are female. Unless a girl is OUTSTANDING (EXTREMELY TALENTED WITH VOICE AND PERSONALITY) other girls will vote for a good-lookin' guy every time. As far as vocal ability goes, I think the prize should go to Pia, Haley or Scotty. Pia's voice is beautiful and she has a lot of control and versatility. I think the same can be said of Haley and I was shocked to see her in the bottom 3. Her voice has a special sound--different. Her control is unbelievable. Range too. I love Scotty's deep baritone and I'm sure a lot of the other women do too. But I was pleasantly surprised by his version of Motown's "For Once In My Life." I'm just glad I don't have to be the only judge!