Pia was one of the best singers in the competition, she shouldn't have gotten eliminated. I think the judges should have a little more input in the elimination decision. They are after all the ones qualified to know who really can sing, and who needs more work to become a singer. There are many who vote on the basis of who is the cutest, when it should be based on performance. I bet that the larger percentage of viewers that vote are young ladies. Which doesn't make it fair to the young ladies competing in American Idol. That is probably the reason a female hasn't won in years on American Idol. Judges should have a bigger impact on the decisions.
Janet - 13 years ago
Pia is great I knew someone would grab her up fast Its just not right that at singing show can't keep the "STARS" on Are the judges kicking themselves for their "SAVE"
Pia was one of the best singers in the competition, she shouldn't have gotten eliminated. I think the judges should have a little more input in the elimination decision. They are after all the ones qualified to know who really can sing, and who needs more work to become a singer. There are many who vote on the basis of who is the cutest, when it should be based on performance. I bet that the larger percentage of viewers that vote are young ladies. Which doesn't make it fair to the young ladies competing in American Idol. That is probably the reason a female hasn't won in years on American Idol. Judges should have a bigger impact on the decisions.
Pia is great I knew someone would grab her up fast Its just not right that at singing show can't keep the "STARS" on Are the judges kicking themselves for their "SAVE"