Which was your favorite 'Idol' performance tonight?

3 Comments

  • Melanie - 13 years ago

    I loved Haley's facial expressions while getting the first "critique" (using that term loosely). If looks could kill J-lo would be lying in a shallow grave behind the judges table tonight. F**k you eyes if I ever saw them! Go Haley!

  • Christy - 13 years ago

    SUCK IT JIMMY!!!

  • Sarah Farley - 13 years ago

    Grassy knoll anyone??...There clearly is a conspiracy among the producers of the show to downgrade Haley's success. The two best performances of the season--Moanin' and House of the Risin' Sun---were by Haley. Sure, there have been other great performances--I personally loved "I Put a Spell on You", but Haley, more than ANYONE else, knows how to sell a song. I just don't understand what the producers have against her--she is beautiful, has a great figure, wonderful stage presence and perfect pitch. She does what they tell her to do, and then gets criticized for it. It is infuriating and even more so, knowing the producers and judges don't have to answer for this patent unfairness.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment