Which was your favorite 'Idol' performance this week?

4 Comments

  • Jess - 13 years ago

    1.I really hope Haley gets into top 3. She deserves it. I think both the girls outsang the guys.
    2. I am with you on the 'judge' Randy and 'judge' Jennifer biased remarks against Haley...am especially flabbergasted with Jen's remark about how 'that's why we can never be easy on you' ??? They are so biased...it makes me miss Simon. I mean seriously....Randy thinks Scotty is like a professional singing Young Blood?? I don't know who's the bigger clown here; the singer or the judge?
    3. Note to Go Go ...u are absolutely right. I wasn't paying Haley much attention until the last 2 episodes when i felt she was unjustly getting hammered.

  • B.Rich - 13 years ago

    Putting all of the Haley garbage treatment last night, who is the solitary idiot who voted for "Young Blood"?

  • Go Go - 13 years ago

    Regardless how well she did on the first song, I think people who would vote for her would actually like her even more after she stood up to those judges because:

    1. The judges this season have been pretty much universally hated. Someone, anyone, to talk back to them is a "HELL YES! FINALLY!" for most viewers.

    2. American Idol is about who gets more votes; not about who you can vote off. No matter how much you hate a contestant, you can't cast negative votes. However, if someone ignites some angry and passion in you, you vote for that someone frantically. I didn't really care much for anyone this season but I hit redial for an hour for her tonight. That's kind of votes she is getting from a lot of people.

  • darclyte - 13 years ago

    Haley's first performance was bad. Just bad. Her voice was grating throughout. It wasn't a good song for her, but Randy came across as "mean" by going on too long. Steven again this week came to Haley's defense (largely ignored last week.) Her second performance was (again) one of the best of the year, but I think perhaps the damage is done with her "talking back" to the judges. Lauren wasn't very good tonight, but she could have burped her way through both songs and been told that "she was back." Scotty was ok, but both he and James have seemed to regress the a bit this week (and James also last week.) But, I did think James was better than Haley on his first song, and was solid on his second. If it was up to me, Lauren would be going home, but I'm afraid it'll be Haley's 5th and final trip into the Bottom.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment