Black IPA (BIPA) because that is how it is how it smells, tastes and is brewed.
Great poll by the way!!
Cheers!
h4ck54w - 13 years ago
I'd be interested to see how the votes lay out geographically. I bet there aren't many Non-CDA votes in Washington and Oregon. Or Pro-CDA votes in, say Colorado.
You know, regional pride and all that.
Location: Olympia
Vote: CDA
h4ck54w - 13 years ago
@Dunn
I did, probably a bad example.
Or a very good example, depending on how you look at it.
dunn - 13 years ago
and H4ck54w, IPA's weren't made IN India, they were made FOR India.
But I'm sure you knew that... ;-)
dunn - 13 years ago
BIPA because THAT's what it is!
It's an IPA, that looks Black! Doesn't matter that the word Pale is in there, that part of the description has been abandoned long ago. Most IPA's aren't pale either.
H4ck54w - 13 years ago
@Dan
Your logic also says IPAs should only be used for beers actually produced in India...
and Pils/Pilsners from Pilsen, Scotch Ales from Scotland, Irish reds from Ireland, ect
Which we all know isn't the case.
Dan Olson - 13 years ago
Cascadian Dark Ale should only be used for beers actually produced in Cascadia.
It would be like calling Sparkling wine from Australia Champagne.
Yeah, most of the CDA proponents I've seen are from the great republic of Cascadia.
San Diego - BIPA
:-D
Black IPA (BIPA) because that is how it is how it smells, tastes and is brewed.
Great poll by the way!!
Cheers!
I'd be interested to see how the votes lay out geographically. I bet there aren't many Non-CDA votes in Washington and Oregon. Or Pro-CDA votes in, say Colorado.
You know, regional pride and all that.
Location: Olympia
Vote: CDA
@Dunn
I did, probably a bad example.
Or a very good example, depending on how you look at it.
and H4ck54w, IPA's weren't made IN India, they were made FOR India.
But I'm sure you knew that... ;-)
BIPA because THAT's what it is!
It's an IPA, that looks Black! Doesn't matter that the word Pale is in there, that part of the description has been abandoned long ago. Most IPA's aren't pale either.
@Dan
Your logic also says IPAs should only be used for beers actually produced in India...
and Pils/Pilsners from Pilsen, Scotch Ales from Scotland, Irish reds from Ireland, ect
Which we all know isn't the case.
Cascadian Dark Ale should only be used for beers actually produced in Cascadia.
It would be like calling Sparkling wine from Australia Champagne.