11 Comments

• 
  cj - 12 years ago

  ditto on the "where's Padma?" i like Padma way more than Tom.

• 
  bootsycolumbia - 12 years ago

  I had to pick Blake Shelton because he seemed to genuinely care about his contestants. However, any of the judges from The Sing Off would have been a great choice. They all give honest, constructive criticism without being mean or boring. Same goes for Mary Murphy on SYTYCD. Yes, her voice is screechy, but if I ever attempt a paso doble or a rumba, I want Mary to tell me what I'm doing right and wrong. She knows her stuff.

• 
  reb - 12 years ago

  Ben Folds from The Sing Off!!!

• 
  Natalia - 12 years ago

  Just voted for Mary Murphy, from SYTYCD. She's annoying at times, but she's a great judge! By far, better than the rest of the list haha

• 
  Carla - 12 years ago

  Mia Michaels and Lil Cee's would have been my 1st choice for SYTYCD. I also like Bruno on Dancing With The Stars.

• 
  Irene - 12 years ago

  I absolutely love so you think you can dance.However,I can not stand hearing Mary Murphy SCREAMING! Her speaking voice is more then enough!!

• 
  Val - 12 years ago

  Christina! Oh No.. On the Voice she just couldn't shut up. She talked over everyone and was crude at times. She has no class.

• 
  Monique - 12 years ago

  Christina Aguilera should have been on this list..ugh!!

• 
  carrie d - 12 years ago

  Anyone from The Sing-Off..

• 
  Jamal - 12 years ago

  Michael Kors should have been on here for Project Runway instead of Heidi. He had all the great comments.

• 
  Andy - 12 years ago

  Umm, where's Padma?