Richard Castle is waaaaaaaaay more handsome than Tony DiNozzo!
jeanne - 12 years ago
Castle has the most interesting personality; he has more "family", daughter, Mother, writes books; he has more depth to his charater. He can be serious about life, Tony is just silly most of the time. And Castle is ruggedly handsome.
Cate - 12 years ago
Soooooooooooo glad Tony won. He's hysterically funny and sooooo adorable too.
Love watching NCIS for my men. Big D little i Big N little ozzo OOOOOOOOOOHH!!!
meme - 12 years ago
YES!! YES!! TONY WON!!:)
DIDI - 12 years ago
Yeah, Tony all the way.
And do not watch the other show, it doesn't even air in my country.
But NCIS i watch that show every week,
Tony and NCIS cast are good looking. Gibbs and Tony with there eyes.............. Ahhhhhhh
NCIS Fanataic - 12 years ago
It's a no-brainer. BIG "D" little "i" BIG "N" little "ozzo"!!! Tony all da waay!
clogane8 - 12 years ago
les deux sont bien c'est dur de choisir mais j'ai donner mon vote a Tony
TONTON - 12 years ago
TONY ALL THE WAY HE'S THE BEST
LGSKKB - 12 years ago
Castle is the best!!!
Beks - 12 years ago
Sure, Castle!
BrandyB - 12 years ago
Tony is Top Notch!
Michelle - 12 years ago
Kate calls Castle her partner all the time, therefore he's law enforcement. Sorry I don't watch the other show and who the heck is Gibbs who I keep reading posts about? Regardless, who could beat the character of Richard Castle, with his rugged good looks (thanks, NF) and charm?! I also love his family life and can't wait for Ryan's wedding. Oh captain, you have my vote a million times!
Thom - 12 years ago
I only recently started watching Castle, and Richard makes me smile every episode, as does Tony. I'm a...inspiring writer so I see the greatness in Castle but, I'm also a goof and Tony has that mastered. Not a easy choice so I have to vote for them both, I'd feel like I'd be cheating one of them if I didn't.
P.S: Some of your comments are leading to "changing NCIS cast" and I don't see why any of you would think that, let alone bring it up. That's not what this is for; just a friendly "crush" competition.
heather - 12 years ago
YES!!!
TONY IS BACK IN THE LEAD AS HE SHOULD BE :)
love his smile
Janice - 12 years ago
Tony DiNozzo is so obnoxious he ruins the entire show for me. His writer should be duct taped from head to toe and fired. He's an arragant bag of hot air and an AH.
Castle is the man of my dreams. His writer is excellent. I LOVE Castle!!!!!
Lisa - 12 years ago
I love em both...but Nathan has been my fav for longer. Who didn't like Fire Fly or Serenity?
marian - 12 years ago
tony tony tony!!!!
all the way
Lori Wise - 12 years ago
Still haven't, and never will, gotten over my Mal Reynolds crush. So glad we still get to see him even if it's not on Serenity.
Julie Bellm - 12 years ago
I agree with Gloria.......wish Mark Harmon was a choice as he beats them all hands down.
kudo's to Tony though
Marilyn Whynot - 12 years ago
Tony all the way!!!!!He's just the greatest!!!!All the NCIS team is great. Don't ever change a thing. What about a contest between Abbey and Penelope????Now that would be a hard decision!!!!!
Denise Bell - 12 years ago
Love Tony, he is the hottest younger man on tv. Now for a bit older women, it would be Gibbs. Tony has my vote, lets get him winning again.
Carmen - 12 years ago
They are both divine Nathan cuz hes a bit older and Firefly... and Michael just cuz he gives that look that shows right through to his soul. Its a shame to pick one over the other, I say both will work just fine. thank you
Jennifer - 12 years ago
Not even a competition - Dinozzo, hands-down!!!!
K.H. - 12 years ago
Nathan was hot back in the day of Firefly, but not so much now as Castle. Tony, on the other hand, remains hot. Sorry Captain, my vote goes to DiNozzo.
rd - 12 years ago
DiNozzo all the way...
Sh - 12 years ago
Tony is soooo funy, pluss, that castle dude looks like he just woke up from laying on rocks!! - -
U
dINOZZO - 12 years ago
Tony, hands down!
edison - 12 years ago
tony all the way!!!! dinozzo rocks!!!1
Firefly - 12 years ago
Malcolm Reynolds...
Tori - 12 years ago
Castle all the way! Best TV show and he is just amazing how he's in love with Beckett! I'm definitely a Castle fan - I can identify all the references from the other Castle fans above! Castle is the funniest and most hilarious guy ever! LOVE HIM! *eating a lollipop* "Hmm...Tastes like soap. I LIKE IT!"
Mrs. Castle - 12 years ago
RICHARD CASTLE IS AN AMAZING FRIEND, FATHER, AND LOVERRRR!! SEXY IN EVERY WAY.
jill jones - 12 years ago
Definitely Tony!! He is handsome, funny, and has adorable eyes!! Of course Mark Harmon is definitely eye candy!!
Norma Hoover - 12 years ago
This is a hard one!! But I fell in love with Tony before there even was a Richard Castle, so I gotta be true to my first love. LOL
Inara Serra - 12 years ago
Wash you're my favorite. Voting for Mal as well.
River Tam - 12 years ago
@hiii: Seriously?! You equate the number of viewers to the quality of a show... that makes no sense. Castle rules. So does Captain Mal Reynolds.
Brenda Giddings - 12 years ago
I love Tony i think he is great!!!!!! tony is smart, very cute, and very funny, and really sexy.
Yvonne - 12 years ago
Yes, I voted for Michael Weatherly until he bypass the other dude and it took me about 30 mins..YaY!!!!
albert - 12 years ago
tony! ! ! !
from philippines....
colleen lord - 12 years ago
tony has the sexyest,cheeky and loving smile so go tony (michael)
KC - 12 years ago
um........TONY !!!
Aahzie - 12 years ago
Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony
Melissa - 12 years ago
OMGOODNESS!!! Are you kidding me? DiNozzo ALL THE WAY BABY!!! :)
Hoban "Wash" Washburne - 12 years ago
Captain Mal Reynolds erm... I mean Castle > DiNozzo.
Jennifer Lopez - 12 years ago
Tony way better he funny and cute at the same time and his character to (:
southerngirl - 12 years ago
Nathan is actually about 3 years younger than Michael. Look it up. Both are hot but Nathan wins hands down.
DEE - 12 years ago
I agree Tony is a lot cuter.
How can he be losing:(
Annika - 12 years ago
Why is the old guy winning? Tony is a lot cuter.
Mary - 12 years ago
Castle, without any doubts!
Rachel Berg - 12 years ago
Castle is the best in everything!!!
southerngirl - 12 years ago
Love love Tony and Gibbs but Rick Castle I adore. Nathan all the way!!!
ab - 12 years ago
TONY TONY
He has the cute and sexy look to him
raven - 12 years ago
I guess if you like girly looking men the other guy is "pretty" hot .. but Really.. Nathan All The Way. Especially in the Ruggedly Handsom column.
m - 12 years ago
i love ziva i
m - 12 years ago
i love ziva i
Veronica - 12 years ago
Tony, Tony and Tony again...
CaskettShipper - 12 years ago
@hiiii - check out the poll. I think we have you beat. Alakazam, jackass (if you're a true Castle fan, you'll know what I mean.)
Amy - 12 years ago
Ahh!!!!
NO !! NO!! this cant be Tony lost or is losing.
TeresaM - 12 years ago
Castle makes me long for monday night and when its over tuesday comes along with some more great eye candy..Tony!! my vote has to go to Castle, he is so vulnerable!
Medusa - 12 years ago
Rick Castle for the win. FOREVER!
LORRAINE JHNSON - 12 years ago
TONY ALL THE WAY....HE IS JUST SO CUTE,......
Abby - 12 years ago
ALWAYS CASTLE.
Chris - 12 years ago
Tony all the way.
He has grow so much especially so far in this season
jade - 12 years ago
ich finde tony ist ein arsch aber ein kluger arsch ^^ (und süß)
Liz Berlovan - 12 years ago
Tony Who?Not only is Richard Castle ruggadly handsome he's sweet,funny,charming and has a great personality so Castle it is!
Peter Govan - 12 years ago
only one way to find a winner - FIIIIGHT!!
Bob T. - 12 years ago
Purely on roles Castle Hands Down, Tony is too full of himself.
jen - 12 years ago
No Tony's not in the lead anymore .He needs more votes!!!!!!
Karen - 12 years ago
TONY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! all the way. if you wanna get rid of Tony you'll have to answer to me...................OK!
Marva - 12 years ago
The more refined Castle gets my vote all the way. Rugged, good looking and always has those way out ideas that somehow gets turned around to the right direction of catching the killer. Never miss this show.
Laura - 12 years ago
I LOVE Tony, but ever since I first saw Nathan Fillion on One Life to Live I was desparately in love with him!!!!!This was definitely a difficult choice. on NCIS, I would love to cuddle on a cold wintery night with McGee......
oshe809 - 12 years ago
This was an incredibly hard decision!!! I love both men equally because they have different personalities that work in the settings of the shows!! I voted for both, obviously!!!! Castle is an amazingly hunky man, but DiNozzo is a sexy smart agent who also has a soft side which has been very well shown!!! My love for these two men cannot be split because I love them in different ways.
lin - 12 years ago
if you remember micheal in dark angel you will always vote for him as the most crushable and he is just getting better
Jullie - 12 years ago
TONYYY!! :)
Kate - 12 years ago
While I watch both shows, I must say, I only just like Castle; I adore Tony.
hiiii - 12 years ago
excuse me while I vomit at all these pro-Castle comments.
Castle is the best show? That is YOUR opinion.
NCIS has an average of 20 MILLION viewers each week, and that's JUST in the USA.
Castle has.... an average of 4 million. Aww :)
We'll see who wins.
Arvee - 12 years ago
Tony is out of everyone's league...who would compete?????
Melojane - 12 years ago
My second choice is Tony DiNozzo... next to Gibbs!
VL - 12 years ago
CASTLE no doubt!!!
Me - 12 years ago
Castle was
Kelsie - 12 years ago
We caught up!
SOMEBODY FEED THESE BIRDS!
(The Castle family will get this reference)
NCISoverCastleButCastle(Nathan)overDiNozzo(Michael - 12 years ago
@ CaskettShipper: yup.... we came back.... and yes, we're the best! :-)
Castle was
CaskettShipper - 12 years ago
See? Castle fans are the best - we came back from a loss and took the lead. And we will do it again for Kate Beckett/Stana Katic. Castle is the best cop show on TV, hands down.
dopeysac - 12 years ago
CASTLE!!!!!
Raji - 12 years ago
Castle is a writer; not a law enforcement officer. So Tony has no competition bcuz of dat!
Valine Cain - 12 years ago
It would not have been a contest, if you had included Mark Harmon. The other two
are sexy, but Mark would win hands down.
Kim - 12 years ago
No contest for me. I'm a one writer girl ;) Rick Castle gets my vote! After all, he really IS ruggedly handsome.
Malcolm Reynolds - 12 years ago
Gonna have to say mr fillion. have you seen Dr. Horribles Sing-A-Long blog? or Firefly? amazing. boo tony!
Rosie Shannon - 12 years ago
Tony no DOUBT!!!
Susie - 12 years ago
Castle has my vote all the way to the finals! Luv ya Castle! Muahh!!
Amanda - 12 years ago
@KylieBug- I'm right there with ya! Gotta go with the Capt.!! He's been hot for YEARS before he was on Castle!
Laurabelle - 12 years ago
It is not the good looks that makes Castle so desirable. It is his charm that captures my attention.
KylieBug - 12 years ago
Browncoats I'm thinking we'll rise again. They cant keep the sky from me!!!!!!! I
KylieBug - 12 years ago
Browncoats I'm thinking we'll rise again.
They cant keep the sky from me!!!!!!!
I
it's just a little crush, afteral which would be better to talk to, flirt with or entertaining. Castle!
Mary Beth Ingels - 12 years ago
Oh this is no contest! Tony is the sexiest & sweetest! And Tony has definitly showed that he will go to the ends of the Earth for those that he cares about! Lets remember that Tony is the one that went to the other side of the world to rescue Ziva, he organized the whole rescue mission, even after she treated him badly. He stayed up all night, keeping McGee company, after McGee thought he shot & killed another cop. He turned down the promotion in Rota, Spain, because he was worried about Gibbs. He is handsome, funny, & uses his sillyness to distract his co-workers from the brutal reality of their job. And this season, they are showing a softer, more vulnerable side to Tony, that I just love!
danilla bellamy - 12 years ago
you can't get any better than tony! he's sweet, sensitive, and funny.... no better combination!
Markee - 12 years ago
I prefer to cuddly up to Castle on a cold winter's night! Definitely!!
Richard Castle is waaaaaaaaay more handsome than Tony DiNozzo!
Castle has the most interesting personality; he has more "family", daughter, Mother, writes books; he has more depth to his charater. He can be serious about life, Tony is just silly most of the time. And Castle is ruggedly handsome.
Soooooooooooo glad Tony won. He's hysterically funny and sooooo adorable too.
Love watching NCIS for my men. Big D little i Big N little ozzo OOOOOOOOOOHH!!!
YES!! YES!! TONY WON!!:)
Yeah, Tony all the way.
And do not watch the other show, it doesn't even air in my country.
But NCIS i watch that show every week,
GO NCIS, keep up the good work
tony tony tony
Tony and NCIS cast are good looking. Gibbs and Tony with there eyes.............. Ahhhhhhh
It's a no-brainer. BIG "D" little "i" BIG "N" little "ozzo"!!! Tony all da waay!
les deux sont bien c'est dur de choisir mais j'ai donner mon vote a Tony
TONY ALL THE WAY HE'S THE BEST
Castle is the best!!!
Sure, Castle!
Tony is Top Notch!
Kate calls Castle her partner all the time, therefore he's law enforcement. Sorry I don't watch the other show and who the heck is Gibbs who I keep reading posts about? Regardless, who could beat the character of Richard Castle, with his rugged good looks (thanks, NF) and charm?! I also love his family life and can't wait for Ryan's wedding. Oh captain, you have my vote a million times!
I only recently started watching Castle, and Richard makes me smile every episode, as does Tony. I'm a...inspiring writer so I see the greatness in Castle but, I'm also a goof and Tony has that mastered. Not a easy choice so I have to vote for them both, I'd feel like I'd be cheating one of them if I didn't.
P.S: Some of your comments are leading to "changing NCIS cast" and I don't see why any of you would think that, let alone bring it up. That's not what this is for; just a friendly "crush" competition.
YES!!!
TONY IS BACK IN THE LEAD AS HE SHOULD BE :)
love his smile
Tony DiNozzo is so obnoxious he ruins the entire show for me. His writer should be duct taped from head to toe and fired. He's an arragant bag of hot air and an AH.
Castle is the man of my dreams. His writer is excellent. I LOVE Castle!!!!!
I love em both...but Nathan has been my fav for longer. Who didn't like Fire Fly or Serenity?
tony tony tony!!!!
all the way
Still haven't, and never will, gotten over my Mal Reynolds crush. So glad we still get to see him even if it's not on Serenity.
I agree with Gloria.......wish Mark Harmon was a choice as he beats them all hands down.
kudo's to Tony though
Tony all the way!!!!!He's just the greatest!!!!All the NCIS team is great. Don't ever change a thing. What about a contest between Abbey and Penelope????Now that would be a hard decision!!!!!
Love Tony, he is the hottest younger man on tv. Now for a bit older women, it would be Gibbs. Tony has my vote, lets get him winning again.
They are both divine Nathan cuz hes a bit older and Firefly... and Michael just cuz he gives that look that shows right through to his soul. Its a shame to pick one over the other, I say both will work just fine. thank you
Not even a competition - Dinozzo, hands-down!!!!
Nathan was hot back in the day of Firefly, but not so much now as Castle. Tony, on the other hand, remains hot. Sorry Captain, my vote goes to DiNozzo.
DiNozzo all the way...
Tony is soooo funy, pluss, that castle dude looks like he just woke up from laying on rocks!! - -
U
Tony, hands down!
tony all the way!!!! dinozzo rocks!!!1
Malcolm Reynolds...
Castle all the way! Best TV show and he is just amazing how he's in love with Beckett! I'm definitely a Castle fan - I can identify all the references from the other Castle fans above! Castle is the funniest and most hilarious guy ever! LOVE HIM! *eating a lollipop* "Hmm...Tastes like soap. I LIKE IT!"
RICHARD CASTLE IS AN AMAZING FRIEND, FATHER, AND LOVERRRR!! SEXY IN EVERY WAY.
Definitely Tony!! He is handsome, funny, and has adorable eyes!! Of course Mark Harmon is definitely eye candy!!
This is a hard one!! But I fell in love with Tony before there even was a Richard Castle, so I gotta be true to my first love. LOL
Wash you're my favorite. Voting for Mal as well.
@hiii: Seriously?! You equate the number of viewers to the quality of a show... that makes no sense. Castle rules. So does Captain Mal Reynolds.
I love Tony i think he is great!!!!!! tony is smart, very cute, and very funny, and really sexy.
Yes, I voted for Michael Weatherly until he bypass the other dude and it took me about 30 mins..YaY!!!!
tony! ! ! !
from philippines....
tony has the sexyest,cheeky and loving smile so go tony (michael)
um........TONY !!!
Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony Tony
OMGOODNESS!!! Are you kidding me? DiNozzo ALL THE WAY BABY!!! :)
Captain Mal Reynolds erm... I mean Castle > DiNozzo.
Tony way better he funny and cute at the same time and his character to (:
Nathan is actually about 3 years younger than Michael. Look it up. Both are hot but Nathan wins hands down.
I agree Tony is a lot cuter.
How can he be losing:(
Why is the old guy winning? Tony is a lot cuter.
Castle, without any doubts!
Castle is the best in everything!!!
Love love Tony and Gibbs but Rick Castle I adore. Nathan all the way!!!
TONY TONY
He has the cute and sexy look to him
I guess if you like girly looking men the other guy is "pretty" hot .. but Really.. Nathan All The Way. Especially in the Ruggedly Handsom column.
i love ziva i
i love ziva i
Tony, Tony and Tony again...
@hiiii - check out the poll. I think we have you beat. Alakazam, jackass (if you're a true Castle fan, you'll know what I mean.)
Ahh!!!!
NO !! NO!! this cant be Tony lost or is losing.
Castle makes me long for monday night and when its over tuesday comes along with some more great eye candy..Tony!! my vote has to go to Castle, he is so vulnerable!
Rick Castle for the win. FOREVER!
TONY ALL THE WAY....HE IS JUST SO CUTE,......
ALWAYS CASTLE.
Tony all the way.
He has grow so much especially so far in this season
ich finde tony ist ein arsch aber ein kluger arsch ^^ (und süß)
Tony Who?Not only is Richard Castle ruggadly handsome he's sweet,funny,charming and has a great personality so Castle it is!
only one way to find a winner - FIIIIGHT!!
Purely on roles Castle Hands Down, Tony is too full of himself.
No Tony's not in the lead anymore .He needs more votes!!!!!!
TONY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! all the way. if you wanna get rid of Tony you'll have to answer to me...................OK!
The more refined Castle gets my vote all the way. Rugged, good looking and always has those way out ideas that somehow gets turned around to the right direction of catching the killer. Never miss this show.
I LOVE Tony, but ever since I first saw Nathan Fillion on One Life to Live I was desparately in love with him!!!!!This was definitely a difficult choice. on NCIS, I would love to cuddle on a cold wintery night with McGee......
This was an incredibly hard decision!!! I love both men equally because they have different personalities that work in the settings of the shows!! I voted for both, obviously!!!! Castle is an amazingly hunky man, but DiNozzo is a sexy smart agent who also has a soft side which has been very well shown!!! My love for these two men cannot be split because I love them in different ways.
if you remember micheal in dark angel you will always vote for him as the most crushable and he is just getting better
TONYYY!! :)
While I watch both shows, I must say, I only just like Castle; I adore Tony.
excuse me while I vomit at all these pro-Castle comments.
Castle is the best show? That is YOUR opinion.
NCIS has an average of 20 MILLION viewers each week, and that's JUST in the USA.
Castle has.... an average of 4 million. Aww :)
We'll see who wins.
Tony is out of everyone's league...who would compete?????
My second choice is Tony DiNozzo... next to Gibbs!
CASTLE no doubt!!!
Castle was
We caught up!
SOMEBODY FEED THESE BIRDS!
(The Castle family will get this reference)
@ CaskettShipper: yup.... we came back.... and yes, we're the best! :-)
Castle was
See? Castle fans are the best - we came back from a loss and took the lead. And we will do it again for Kate Beckett/Stana Katic. Castle is the best cop show on TV, hands down.
CASTLE!!!!!
Castle is a writer; not a law enforcement officer. So Tony has no competition bcuz of dat!
It would not have been a contest, if you had included Mark Harmon. The other two
are sexy, but Mark would win hands down.
No contest for me. I'm a one writer girl ;) Rick Castle gets my vote! After all, he really IS ruggedly handsome.
Gonna have to say mr fillion. have you seen Dr. Horribles Sing-A-Long blog? or Firefly? amazing. boo tony!
Tony no DOUBT!!!
Castle has my vote all the way to the finals! Luv ya Castle! Muahh!!
@KylieBug- I'm right there with ya! Gotta go with the Capt.!! He's been hot for YEARS before he was on Castle!
It is not the good looks that makes Castle so desirable. It is his charm that captures my attention.
Browncoats I'm thinking we'll rise again. They cant keep the sky from me!!!!!!! I
Browncoats I'm thinking we'll rise again.
They cant keep the sky from me!!!!!!!
I
I love both of them.. THIS IS SO HARD.
I pick Castle... :/
it's just a little crush, afteral which would be better to talk to, flirt with or entertaining. Castle!
Oh this is no contest! Tony is the sexiest & sweetest! And Tony has definitly showed that he will go to the ends of the Earth for those that he cares about! Lets remember that Tony is the one that went to the other side of the world to rescue Ziva, he organized the whole rescue mission, even after she treated him badly. He stayed up all night, keeping McGee company, after McGee thought he shot & killed another cop. He turned down the promotion in Rota, Spain, because he was worried about Gibbs. He is handsome, funny, & uses his sillyness to distract his co-workers from the brutal reality of their job. And this season, they are showing a softer, more vulnerable side to Tony, that I just love!
you can't get any better than tony! he's sweet, sensitive, and funny.... no better combination!
I prefer to cuddly up to Castle on a cold winter's night! Definitely!!