i picked melanie to win after her first audition, so im sticking with my initial first impressions, i also love josh, but hey ,chris is a superb singer/songwriter who has so much to give. i think the us version this year completely out shone the uk version and im english but the truth needs to be spoken. they all deserve a future in the industry and good luck and god bless them all.
Kate - 12 years ago
Melanie would just be another Mariah Carey and we don't need a clone of her. Josh stands out not only with his voice but he is also a musician, which should be featured more so people can judge for themselves who actually has more talent. And I would advise Melanie to not shout out the stuff she's shouting out, it is a turn off. Josh-----no more dancers, I agree with Simon, it is not who you are.
i picked melanie to win after her first audition, so im sticking with my initial first impressions, i also love josh, but hey ,chris is a superb singer/songwriter who has so much to give. i think the us version this year completely out shone the uk version and im english but the truth needs to be spoken. they all deserve a future in the industry and good luck and god bless them all.
Melanie would just be another Mariah Carey and we don't need a clone of her. Josh stands out not only with his voice but he is also a musician, which should be featured more so people can judge for themselves who actually has more talent. And I would advise Melanie to not shout out the stuff she's shouting out, it is a turn off. Josh-----no more dancers, I agree with Simon, it is not who you are.