There was no doubt in my mind that Josh had the most amazing & versatile voice as well as singing style & performance in the X-Factor contest. The sad reality is that the manner by which the winner is chosen in the X-Factor is flawed. The system in which the mentors also judge their contenders' performance is bias e.g., in Simon Cowell's case, he can simply exacerbate his critique & direct it to the others who are not under his mentorship in favor of his very own. Josh should have won for many reasons but strikingly because he sang with passion, with real feelings and made every song his own - the virtue of an artist per se. There is no wonder why more people await Josh Krajick's album more than Melanie Amoro's who can easily win a Karaoke singing contest.
gabby - 12 years ago
I don't understand these shows/competitions. Judges are always saying that they are looking for the whole package. So why is it that the ones that do write their own music, play a multitude of instruments and have amazing voices always seem to loose to the one with only a power house voice. Give Melanie here due , she does have an amazing voice... I was just pondering .
Josh
My family and I are waiting for that album, we all thought YOU should have won. Looking forward to seeing and hearing you on the new season of X Factor.
Paul - 12 years ago
Josh u r the man, always the winner, should b called the Simon Cowel show. With his huge ego how did anyone else fit in the auditorium, let alone on the stage!!!
sharon - 12 years ago
I have ben waiting for Josh to bring out an album.. his voice is amazing, the best I've heard in years and he can move me to tears when he sings.
I also think that Drew Ryniewicz has an amazing voice and a wonderful and unique style. I sure hope that someone will support her to bring out an album too, I predict she will sell millions. She has a sort of folky/country somekindof fabulous style...
paula - 12 years ago
in regards to why josh didn't win - guess what was voting out there? oh, and who's show is it? simons? and he said he made a mistake letting melanie go? seriously? that was all planned. not to take anything away from melanie, but josh was by far the most talented. i can't wait for his cd!
Mark - 12 years ago
No doubt josh was the winner. Talent far surpasses any of the others due to his versatility. He can do it all. Play instruments, sing, write, he's got the goose bump factor. Very upsetting that he didn't win but very glad to hear he will get that money he deserves.
Suze - 12 years ago
Yeah, so what happened America? How could this have happened? Josh should have won hands down! No question about it.
Sylvia - 12 years ago
just wondering - of 77% of us would rather buy Josh's records......why the hell did he not win?
margaret in N.Ireland - 12 years ago
Josh is brilliant, makes the hairs stand on the back of my neck when I listen to him.
KimLnyc - 12 years ago
Based on the statistics here, of the album we would buy ... looks like Josh should have won this contest. He leaves everyone else in the dust!
He is THE BEST singer to come out of these current competitions ... and will replace and surpass Joe Cocker!
Every time I've listened to him ... on TV & YouTube ... he has given me goosebumps!
I can only imagine what it will be like to hear him live!
Deeply in debt I will have to find a way to get a ticket to see him!
Janet Fields - 12 years ago
Josh is the greatest singer to come along in a long time.They should have split the 5 mil.
Elizabeth - 12 years ago
Please please please make an Album, Josh ... I would buy it in a minute! My favorite? Rythem & blues ...
Shelby2012 - 12 years ago
I forgot to insert DWTS not a singing competition, but my favorite Reality Show.
Shelby2012 - 12 years ago
I can hardly wait to buy Josh Krajcic's album!!!! I've never voted before on any singing Reality Show, not even Dancing With The Stars which ismy favorite of all until Josh Krajcic. Hurry Josh, make your CD now :-)
There was no doubt in my mind that Josh had the most amazing & versatile voice as well as singing style & performance in the X-Factor contest. The sad reality is that the manner by which the winner is chosen in the X-Factor is flawed. The system in which the mentors also judge their contenders' performance is bias e.g., in Simon Cowell's case, he can simply exacerbate his critique & direct it to the others who are not under his mentorship in favor of his very own. Josh should have won for many reasons but strikingly because he sang with passion, with real feelings and made every song his own - the virtue of an artist per se. There is no wonder why more people await Josh Krajick's album more than Melanie Amoro's who can easily win a Karaoke singing contest.
I don't understand these shows/competitions. Judges are always saying that they are looking for the whole package. So why is it that the ones that do write their own music, play a multitude of instruments and have amazing voices always seem to loose to the one with only a power house voice. Give Melanie here due , she does have an amazing voice... I was just pondering .
Josh
My family and I are waiting for that album, we all thought YOU should have won. Looking forward to seeing and hearing you on the new season of X Factor.
Josh u r the man, always the winner, should b called the Simon Cowel show. With his huge ego how did anyone else fit in the auditorium, let alone on the stage!!!
I have ben waiting for Josh to bring out an album.. his voice is amazing, the best I've heard in years and he can move me to tears when he sings.
I also think that Drew Ryniewicz has an amazing voice and a wonderful and unique style. I sure hope that someone will support her to bring out an album too, I predict she will sell millions. She has a sort of folky/country somekindof fabulous style...
in regards to why josh didn't win - guess what was voting out there? oh, and who's show is it? simons? and he said he made a mistake letting melanie go? seriously? that was all planned. not to take anything away from melanie, but josh was by far the most talented. i can't wait for his cd!
No doubt josh was the winner. Talent far surpasses any of the others due to his versatility. He can do it all. Play instruments, sing, write, he's got the goose bump factor. Very upsetting that he didn't win but very glad to hear he will get that money he deserves.
Yeah, so what happened America? How could this have happened? Josh should have won hands down! No question about it.
just wondering - of 77% of us would rather buy Josh's records......why the hell did he not win?
Josh is brilliant, makes the hairs stand on the back of my neck when I listen to him.
Based on the statistics here, of the album we would buy ... looks like Josh should have won this contest. He leaves everyone else in the dust!
He is THE BEST singer to come out of these current competitions ... and will replace and surpass Joe Cocker!
Every time I've listened to him ... on TV & YouTube ... he has given me goosebumps!
I can only imagine what it will be like to hear him live!
Deeply in debt I will have to find a way to get a ticket to see him!
Josh is the greatest singer to come along in a long time.They should have split the 5 mil.
Please please please make an Album, Josh ... I would buy it in a minute! My favorite? Rythem & blues ...
I forgot to insert DWTS not a singing competition, but my favorite Reality Show.
I can hardly wait to buy Josh Krajcic's album!!!! I've never voted before on any singing Reality Show, not even Dancing With The Stars which ismy favorite of all until Josh Krajcic. Hurry Josh, make your CD now :-)
Josh is my first choice. But i also like Chris Rene.
Proud OF you Josh...sorry bout
the typo in my previous comment...
Josh Krajcik, of course. Love the KrajcikMagic
Wooster loves you and we're so proud if you!
See (and hear) you soon :)
Josh, hands-down and in a heartbeat!! The Beast Reigns!!!
Josh, hands-down and in a heartbeat!! The Beast Reigns!!!