I thought it seemed like an OK idea when he was introduced, but his storyline went on for too long and frankly wasn't as funny as I've come to expect from Tonedeaf...Maybe it was because I just couldn't connect to it like I can to most of the band jokes in your comic, since my doubt doesn't usually personify itself as a giant floating, talking, square.
Sorry if that sounds harsh. I normally LOVE your comic, so "Meh, OK" (how I responded to Bernard) feels worse by comparison.
If you don't mind suggestions...I really loved the Snare/Tenor/Bass line breakdowns. Maybe you'd consider doing other sections of the band/orchestra. (doesn't have to be marching band, even. Viola section, trombone section, pit orchestra, jazz rhythm section all seem to be fair game.)
Nathan Fuller - 12 years ago
I thought it seemed like an OK idea when he was introduced, but his storyline went on for too long and frankly wasn't as funny as I've come to expect from Tonedeaf...Maybe it was because I just couldn't connect to it like I can to most of the band jokes in your comic, since my doubt doesn't usually personify itself as a giant floating, talking, square.
Sorry if that sounds harsh. I normally LOVE your comic, so "Meh, OK" (how I responded to Bernard) feels worse by comparison.
If you don't mind suggestions...I really loved the Snare/Tenor/Bass line breakdowns. Maybe you'd consider doing other sections of the band/orchestra. (doesn't have to be marching band, even. Viola section, trombone section, pit orchestra, jazz rhythm section all seem to be fair game.)
Andrew Green - 12 years ago
I liked him, I just didn't care for the comics with him several times in a row.
I thought it seemed like an OK idea when he was introduced, but his storyline went on for too long and frankly wasn't as funny as I've come to expect from Tonedeaf...Maybe it was because I just couldn't connect to it like I can to most of the band jokes in your comic, since my doubt doesn't usually personify itself as a giant floating, talking, square.
Sorry if that sounds harsh. I normally LOVE your comic, so "Meh, OK" (how I responded to Bernard) feels worse by comparison.
If you don't mind suggestions...I really loved the Snare/Tenor/Bass line breakdowns. Maybe you'd consider doing other sections of the band/orchestra. (doesn't have to be marching band, even. Viola section, trombone section, pit orchestra, jazz rhythm section all seem to be fair game.)
I thought it seemed like an OK idea when he was introduced, but his storyline went on for too long and frankly wasn't as funny as I've come to expect from Tonedeaf...Maybe it was because I just couldn't connect to it like I can to most of the band jokes in your comic, since my doubt doesn't usually personify itself as a giant floating, talking, square.
Sorry if that sounds harsh. I normally LOVE your comic, so "Meh, OK" (how I responded to Bernard) feels worse by comparison.
If you don't mind suggestions...I really loved the Snare/Tenor/Bass line breakdowns. Maybe you'd consider doing other sections of the band/orchestra. (doesn't have to be marching band, even. Viola section, trombone section, pit orchestra, jazz rhythm section all seem to be fair game.)
I liked him, I just didn't care for the comics with him several times in a row.