I gotta go with Eli...just on the Superbowl wins alone.
I think everyone would like to see Eli and Peyton play in a Superbowl against each other, but Peyton's neck problems may play into that..
But, my vote goes to Eli...
Mark - 12 years ago
It not about MVP- no one cares- Teams are formed to win Super Bowls- therefore Eli is the man.
Rick - 12 years ago
I can't possibly vote here. How can they be compared?
MM - 12 years ago
Cooper is the best Manning athlete.
Johnny M - 12 years ago
Bill I think you have Peyton confused with Tony Romo for bad post season play.
Eli and Peyton are both great QBs... but there is no doubt that Peyton has the better mechanics, signal calling, and overall arm strength and accuracy.
But Eli does have two rings lol
Lusee - 12 years ago
Both are great! Colts with Manning win; without Manning 2-14. Shows Peyton is the team. If Eli could not play for a year, would Giants go 2-14? Doubt it.
Carol McClellan - 12 years ago
Eli also is better at getting come from behind victories than Peyton.
Drew - 12 years ago
It's easy to overlook Peyton after Eli has just won another Superbowl and Peyton is sidelined from neck surgery, but Peyton has done it with much more imbalanced teams. He's done it all. If the Colts had the Giants defense which won them those two Superbowls, how many rings does Peyton have now? In any event, two of the all-time greats.
rae - 12 years ago
they're both great! period.
IC - 12 years ago
Peyton is a great superstar and play caller. Only once did he have the great team around him to win it all. Eli is the better team player and he is tough; he doesn't crack under pressure. I think it is partly due to having 2 older brothers that probably beat on him all the time because he had to play up to compete at their level.
Zman - 12 years ago
Eli performs in the clutch and that is what matters most. Peyton is great in his own right but when it comes to winning I think Eli is the "Bigger Brother".
The Giants have a TEAM and that is how you win Super Bowls. They all played slightly better than they really are and did it game after game after game. Nobody is really a Super Star like Peyton but as a team with Eli as their leader there is nobody better in the league.
GO GIANTS!!!!!!!!!!
Josh - 12 years ago
No reason to compare them. Two great quarterbacks, two superbowl champions and two people who seem to be genuinely nice. I think Eli is the greatest quarterback the NY Giants have ever had.
fred - 12 years ago
no way, suka...
u is da sore loser
eli is better than peyton cause peyton is a lil bich fuk
Bill - 12 years ago
Why u say that?! Peyton's career postseason record is horrendous!! There is something to say about that. He is great about putting up numbers in regular season but who cares. . . Peyton has choked time and again. .
mike - 12 years ago
really? as a Giants fan I love Eli, wouldn't trade him for the world, but he's not better than Peyton.
I gotta go with Eli...just on the Superbowl wins alone.
I think everyone would like to see Eli and Peyton play in a Superbowl against each other, but Peyton's neck problems may play into that..
But, my vote goes to Eli...
It not about MVP- no one cares- Teams are formed to win Super Bowls- therefore Eli is the man.
I can't possibly vote here. How can they be compared?
Cooper is the best Manning athlete.
Bill I think you have Peyton confused with Tony Romo for bad post season play.
Eli and Peyton are both great QBs... but there is no doubt that Peyton has the better mechanics, signal calling, and overall arm strength and accuracy.
But Eli does have two rings lol
Both are great! Colts with Manning win; without Manning 2-14. Shows Peyton is the team. If Eli could not play for a year, would Giants go 2-14? Doubt it.
Eli also is better at getting come from behind victories than Peyton.
It's easy to overlook Peyton after Eli has just won another Superbowl and Peyton is sidelined from neck surgery, but Peyton has done it with much more imbalanced teams. He's done it all. If the Colts had the Giants defense which won them those two Superbowls, how many rings does Peyton have now? In any event, two of the all-time greats.
they're both great! period.
Peyton is a great superstar and play caller. Only once did he have the great team around him to win it all. Eli is the better team player and he is tough; he doesn't crack under pressure. I think it is partly due to having 2 older brothers that probably beat on him all the time because he had to play up to compete at their level.
Eli performs in the clutch and that is what matters most. Peyton is great in his own right but when it comes to winning I think Eli is the "Bigger Brother".
The Giants have a TEAM and that is how you win Super Bowls. They all played slightly better than they really are and did it game after game after game. Nobody is really a Super Star like Peyton but as a team with Eli as their leader there is nobody better in the league.
GO GIANTS!!!!!!!!!!
No reason to compare them. Two great quarterbacks, two superbowl champions and two people who seem to be genuinely nice. I think Eli is the greatest quarterback the NY Giants have ever had.
no way, suka...
u is da sore loser
eli is better than peyton cause peyton is a lil bich fuk
Why u say that?! Peyton's career postseason record is horrendous!! There is something to say about that. He is great about putting up numbers in regular season but who cares. . . Peyton has choked time and again. .
really? as a Giants fan I love Eli, wouldn't trade him for the world, but he's not better than Peyton.