Kurt Warner no doubt deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. His stats are unbelievable. Remember that he became a starter at the age of 27. Plus, he has a rags to riches background, not to mention his humanitarian efforts, religious convictions, and an exemplary role model.
Warner's SB stats are legendary. Eli was 5-11 on 3rd down and threw 1 TD against the 2nd worst pass D in the NFL this past Sunday...yawn.
Warner has thrown for more SB yards than everyone except Brady. Warner only played in 3 SB. It took Brady 5 to get more yards than Warner. Kurt has more SB yards than Montana and he played in 4.
Furthermore, Justin Tuck deserved the SB MVP in both SB 42 and 46...but he has the wrong last name.
Eli scored 4 more points than Tuck did this past Sunday...yawn.
Jack - 12 years ago
Warner was 1-2 in SB appearances. Eli is 2-0. Eli also has a wife who keeps her mouth shut! Warner and Brady ...not so much.
Rigo - 12 years ago
Eli Manning, hands down! People don't remember you for specefic stats, etc. People remember Super Bowl winners!!! Would you rather have great stats or Super Bowl wins under your belt? Last time I checked, 2 was greater than one.
Sawyer - 12 years ago
Five quarterbacks in NFL history have two Superbowl MVP awards: Bart Starr, Terry Bradshaw, Joe Montana (has three!), Tom Brady, and Eli Manning. Eli is also the only quarterback to beat a two time Superbowl MVP in the big game, and he did it twice. He holds the record for most road playoff wins, has won at Lambeau in the playoffs twice, (against two future hall of famers in Favre and Rodgers) and led the game winning drive of the SB twice. I think Warner and Eli both deserve to be in the hall; but if I had to choose only one it would be Manning.
Jasmine - 12 years ago
Every team play to win the super bowl and Eli did it twice. He's not done yet but Kurt Warner is, So for him to say what he said says more about the type of person he is rather then making Manning look bad. Winning Superbowls is the point of the. game Manning 2/0 Kurt Warner 1/2 that says it all! No one man can always carry a team just ask Brady. Winning is a team effort he is a leader not a one man army! "GO ELI"
Naomi - 12 years ago
Eli's draft day persona is NOT worthy of the Hall of Fame!!!!!
Kurt Warner no doubt deserves to be in the Hall of Fame. His stats are unbelievable. Remember that he became a starter at the age of 27. Plus, he has a rags to riches background, not to mention his humanitarian efforts, religious convictions, and an exemplary role model.
Warner's SB stats are legendary. Eli was 5-11 on 3rd down and threw 1 TD against the 2nd worst pass D in the NFL this past Sunday...yawn.
Warner has thrown for more SB yards than everyone except Brady. Warner only played in 3 SB. It took Brady 5 to get more yards than Warner. Kurt has more SB yards than Montana and he played in 4.
Furthermore, Justin Tuck deserved the SB MVP in both SB 42 and 46...but he has the wrong last name.
Eli scored 4 more points than Tuck did this past Sunday...yawn.
Warner was 1-2 in SB appearances. Eli is 2-0. Eli also has a wife who keeps her mouth shut! Warner and Brady ...not so much.
Eli Manning, hands down! People don't remember you for specefic stats, etc. People remember Super Bowl winners!!! Would you rather have great stats or Super Bowl wins under your belt? Last time I checked, 2 was greater than one.
Five quarterbacks in NFL history have two Superbowl MVP awards: Bart Starr, Terry Bradshaw, Joe Montana (has three!), Tom Brady, and Eli Manning. Eli is also the only quarterback to beat a two time Superbowl MVP in the big game, and he did it twice. He holds the record for most road playoff wins, has won at Lambeau in the playoffs twice, (against two future hall of famers in Favre and Rodgers) and led the game winning drive of the SB twice. I think Warner and Eli both deserve to be in the hall; but if I had to choose only one it would be Manning.
Every team play to win the super bowl and Eli did it twice. He's not done yet but Kurt Warner is, So for him to say what he said says more about the type of person he is rather then making Manning look bad. Winning Superbowls is the point of the. game Manning 2/0 Kurt Warner 1/2 that says it all! No one man can always carry a team just ask Brady. Winning is a team effort he is a leader not a one man army! "GO ELI"
Eli's draft day persona is NOT worthy of the Hall of Fame!!!!!