It's hard to say for sure sense I feel it's between Brees and Manning. Would have been a lot clearer choice if Manning had a better organization than the Saint's were at that time . Although I think the answer should be a lot clearer after the upcoming season. With the challenges they face both on and off the field the widow into just how good Brees really is and the Saints as a organization. I'm really thinking both Brees and the Saints will make a strong definitive statement in a positive sense that solidifies any doubt about Brees as one of the best QB's in NFL history, if he hasn't already.