Did Joshua Ledet deserve to go home on 'American Idol'?

18 Comments

  • CAUTION! - 12 years ago

    JOSHUA LEDET UR AWESOME! I HAVE BEEN WATCHING AMERICAN IDOL SINCE THE FIRST SEASON AND I CANT BELIEVE THIS BULL! I KNEW IT WAS GONNA BE LIKE THIS IN MY HEART! IM A COUNTRY GIRL BUT WHO IN THE HELL WANT TO LISTEN TO PHILLIP HELL NOT ME! I REALLY THINK ITS BECOMING A RACIST THING AND I REALLY REALLY REALLY HATE THINKING LIKE THIS! AMERICAN IDOL I LOVED YOUR SHOW BUT NOW I WILL NO LONGER SUPPORT THIS SHOW! OF COARSE IM JUST ONE PERSON SO IT WOULDNT MATTER HUH! CAN'T WAIT FOR YOUR ALBUM JOSHUA, WE LOVE YOU! GOOD LUCK JESSICA!

  • Gina - 12 years ago

    Josh was awesome until he got too gospelly with the music. He couldn't seem to be able to control that part of him. Although he's a very good singer, with no control, unfortunately he'll only be able to sing gospel music. I thought his song with Fantasia was horrible!! If he can control that part of him, even I will listen to his music.

  • so? - 12 years ago

    It has been outrageous to me to see Josh go . I agree with the holders of the opinion that Am Idol voted the gentleman out. This is all about music not looks . Let's close eyes a lil bit to just enjoy that powerful and expressive voice flowing out of him . Were Am idol just broadcasted without anybody basing on looks, I believe Josh would stay.
    I kinda felt bad because I did not vote, but forget it. It is useless anyway. Josh and Jessica; way to go .....
    Congrats Phillip ...

  • rs - 12 years ago

    i knew either joshou or jessica will be voted off leaving phillip to be safe...and there you go phillip got it...you know why!!!!

  • Diersen - 12 years ago

    joshua is not gay for one thing. the songs that they made him choose made him look gay. i used to hate him, but now he got so much better, and honestly, Jessica should've gone home. if it weren't for the judges, she would of gone home a long time ago

  • CURTISSWATKINS - 12 years ago

    N O JOSHUA LEDET SHOULDN'T HAVE BEEN VOTED OFF, COME ON PEOPLE DO YOU REALLY THINK THAT YOU HAVE SOME POWER? I AM HERE TO INFORM YOU THAT YOU DON'T, THIS SHOW IS ABOUT WHO THEY WANT AS THE NEXT IDOL THE VOTING IS JUST A HOAX TO SEE HOW MANY VIEWERS THAT THEY HAVE WATCHING AMERICAN IDOL, JOSHUA WILL GO ON TO DO GREAT THINGS, YOU PEOPLE WHO ARE OUT THERE CALLING HIM GAY WATCH HIM EXCEL, MY QUESTION IS HOW DO YOU GUYS KNOW THAT JOSHUA IS GAY? OR YOU JUDGING HIM BY HIS LOOKS, I MEAN WHAT? AND SO WHAT IF HE IS GAY? HE WHO IS WITHOUT SIN CAST THE FIRST STONE, HIS FATHER IS A PREACHER A MAN OF GOD AND IF HIS SON IS INDEED GAY AND HE HAS MADE PEACE WITH IT THEN WHO THE HELL ARE WE?

  • talaifua Sauileone - 12 years ago

    Dnt matter no more the whole thing is fix dnt matter who wins anymore my whole family loves Joshua. Not bkause his black or watever its bkause he sings fr his Heart. N he got talent. N its a talent. Fr da man above. Who am I to judge. Only lord knws d ans For. Everything. In god we trust joshua u safe in our hearts GOOD LUCK.

  • Lady Blue - 12 years ago

    Josh Ledet should have never been voted off. He is one of the best American Idol has ever seen.
    It truly was the producers of the show who voted Josh off because America is not ready for a gay
    idol. Let's not forget what the president of the United States recently said. Remember Adam Lambert deserved to win too. How clever Idol was to bring Adam on
    the day they knew they would be voting Josh off, only to remind America why Josh could not
    be the next American Idol either.

  • Mrs. Right - 12 years ago

    Josh is the greatest American Idol ever seen!

  • Jema Seferi - 12 years ago

    Joshua and Jessica deserves to be in the final 2 . They are great singers and flexible in every song they sang.

  • Linde - 12 years ago

    I think at this point it really comes down to "young girl" votes. Do I think Josh was the best? No doubt but i didn't vote (maybe im too lazy) he is the best performer and an Amazing singer!!! Yet the votes are unfair due to who's really voting. The last five kids were amazing singers and we'll be sure to hear more of them in all in the future. Will miss Josh the most!!! Maybe I'll start to vote again.

  • Sarumi Modupe - 12 years ago

    Joshua is the best and he does not deserve to be eliminated.

  • Sam Jackson - 12 years ago

    Should have been Jessica going home....From Louisiana ..now Alabama....Love you Josh...You will make it...watch out Sam Cooke

  • Sweetie - 12 years ago

    Joshua is the best. The producers of American Idol is playing some games here and we all know it.

  • CINDY C. - 12 years ago

    josh is the best singer on american idol besides jessica. it happen again just like deodre the boy can sing anything. i dont think american know what good sanging is, cause they all got it wrong. all i can say is they didnt want josh to win cause i am not going to say it, but you figure it out. Josh i am from Houma la. and i think u are an amazing singer. we all love you in louisiana and no matter what people think, you are my idol and a wonderful singer. Go get your record deal, at least you are going to make those big bucks. Now even though you didnt win, to those who didnt vote for Josh at least he is going to make what you dont have, a lot of money. NOW HOW YOU YOU LIKE JOSH NOW! LOVE YOU JOSH AND I HOPE I CAN MEET YOU ONE DAY IN HOUMA! GOD BLESS YOU AND HAVE A SAFE TRIP BACK TO LOUISIANA.

  • birdie phelps - 12 years ago

    Joshau Ledet had no business being votrd off..I pray that someone pick up this talented young man..he got one the best voices i've hears since i been looking at american Idol.., people need to listen with their hears not judge by the looks ,..this young men can blow i mean blow ..it's a shame that he was voted off..sad to say i had a feeling it would come to that ..but gonna keep my opion to myself ..ya was so wrong to vote him off,...SMDH!!!!

  • Florence Bong - 12 years ago

    Wake Up Americans ! Vote wisely. Joshua Ledet is a living legend. OMG !!!

  • wm - 12 years ago

    i don't think he deserved to go home. he is the best of all those two. i think (my own opinion) phillip and joshua should be the top two...

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment