Kate's got class; Kim needs to return to the trailor park.
Jean - 12 years ago
Lovely Kate, Elegant and with lots of class. Love her clothes and her ability to show inner beauty as well as outer.
Well as for Kim she represents what the ill reputed women have always represented. Ill repute.
So typical of the USA women trashy.
deb - 12 years ago
both dresses are nice...i liked kims dress, for me, that one looks more comfortable, could be a little longer, if i had a say how it would look for me...
Pat - 12 years ago
Kate looks like a lady which never goes out of style even for the young ones. Unfortunately, many females today think they need to show much more than they should, and therefore, come across looking cheap. Kim looks like she could shed a few pounds.
CA - 12 years ago
They both look very nice, Kim wore this dress a year ago. At the time it look great. I think the voting is being based on how people feel about Kim today! Kate has a total different style then Kim and the dress works for the both of them....
KG - 12 years ago
Hard to compare the two. Really depends on the occassion. Kim is much more trendy, while Kate is simple and classy.
Britchick - 12 years ago
There are so many comments that are spot on and thankfully only a few that are obviously written by tasteless people themselves like Kim.The question of who wore it better is so ridiculous it doesn't deserve an answer,it's also insulting.Good grief are you kidding me.If these were two unknown people it would still be obvious who looks better.One looks classy and one looks like trashy.
drake - 12 years ago
OMG..really? People mag come on. There is not a comparison.
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge! You should not have put Kim next to her. People mag should be ashamed.
Lupita - 12 years ago
If you notice the design tails on the hips really helped define Kate's petite frame while Kim having large hips looked suffocated in the dress. Kate looks much classier than Kim, and what can one expect from the Diva of Reality?
Joni - 12 years ago
I think Kate looks fabulous in this dress, she has style and she is classic lady
Paula - 12 years ago
Be.... Not at all jealous I am 49 years old I never said she was not beautiful because she is beautiful. I just think she should dress her age.
T! - 12 years ago
Kate has and always will be a lady! She is classy, clever and fills her roles and responsibilities beautifully and with grace!
Kim..... The less said the better! It's genetic :(
Ana - 12 years ago
Kate looks like a lady......Kim looks like a cheap hooker trying to dress nice! Hands down Kate wins!
Be - 12 years ago
Paula's comments wreaks of jealousy...she probably wished that she looked as good as Kate!
Carol Griffin - 12 years ago
Really, get real! Granted both dress are red and pleated, the same dress? not hardly.
Paula - 12 years ago
As Kate looks nice in her dress the style is too old for her. While Kate dresses proper and elegantly, can she not wear clothes that are more age appropriate and still look proper and elegant? She is 30 years old not 50 years old . Even Princess Diana started to dress her age after awhile and she was very proper, elegant and beautiful and held her title well.
kat - 12 years ago
The dress doesn't even fit over Kim's hips. This is a no brainer.
jan - 12 years ago
Kate looks elegant and classy. Kim will modify any dress to show off what she thinks are her assets to get attention.
Stella - 12 years ago
Catherine looks stunning and elegant. Kim looks normal like something I would see any ordinary American wearing. Personally, because Kim made a sex video, even with the press her and her family receive, I still believe it kind of tarnished any classy image of her. Kim Kardashian is a sexpot basically no matter what press she receives. Catherine is college educated, Kim is not. Catherine is royalty, Kim is not.
Ethelyn - 12 years ago
If Kim wasn't in the news every day, then maybe . . . Kate all the way.
Anya - 12 years ago
Everyone in America seems to think that dresses that look like they are 3 sizes too small are fashionable. Maybe it's just a cultural thing......we ain't got none. the Duchess beats the bimbo by a mile.
bmp - 12 years ago
as usual kim looks what she is...a whore and nothing more
Topaze - 12 years ago
Kim's fit is too tight and makes her hip & mi-section look huge, her shoesnecklace are not very attractive with the dress. It's like she's trying too many looks at one time!
Jill - 12 years ago
I like Kate's version much better. The fit is nicer and is age-appropriate. Just because one is young doesn't mean all their "bits" need to be exposed. Kim's dress looks a bit tight in the midsection, anyway. And this has nothing to do with my opinion of either of them, because they are both successful women that have accomplished much in their young lives!
Corey Williams - 12 years ago
Even Kim's legs are Fat. Kate can wear a garbage bag and make it look classy.
Trashstash - 12 years ago
Kim whorified it.
M - 12 years ago
I agree with Danielle. I think most people are voting based on the person, not on who wore it best. There is no doubt that Kim wore it best. Kate makes it look too old for her age.
T2 - 12 years ago
Kate = class. Kim = crass.
Rebecca - 12 years ago
Ugh...please never compare beautiful and classy Kate Middleton to Kim Kardashion...really PEOPLE???
CAMMY - 12 years ago
Danielle Fashion is everything about a person. Fashion shows how a person feels or cares about him/herself image. plus Kate pic looks way better then the troll Kim.
Gaby - 12 years ago
I love and Kim and Kate's style's,this time in my opinion Kim wear it better :)
Danielle - 12 years ago
This is not about the person they are. It is about their fashion ELLIE!!!
ELLIE - 12 years ago
HOW IN GODS NAME CAN YOU EVEN COMPARE KAT TO KIMMY? THERE IS NONE. KATE IS THER WINNER ALL THE WAY. KATE IS DOWN TO EARTH AND KIM IS ONE BIG PHONY!
Kate's got class; Kim needs to return to the trailor park.
Lovely Kate, Elegant and with lots of class. Love her clothes and her ability to show inner beauty as well as outer.
Well as for Kim she represents what the ill reputed women have always represented. Ill repute.
So typical of the USA women trashy.
both dresses are nice...i liked kims dress, for me, that one looks more comfortable, could be a little longer, if i had a say how it would look for me...
Kate looks like a lady which never goes out of style even for the young ones. Unfortunately, many females today think they need to show much more than they should, and therefore, come across looking cheap. Kim looks like she could shed a few pounds.
They both look very nice, Kim wore this dress a year ago. At the time it look great. I think the voting is being based on how people feel about Kim today! Kate has a total different style then Kim and the dress works for the both of them....
Hard to compare the two. Really depends on the occassion. Kim is much more trendy, while Kate is simple and classy.
There are so many comments that are spot on and thankfully only a few that are obviously written by tasteless people themselves like Kim.The question of who wore it better is so ridiculous it doesn't deserve an answer,it's also insulting.Good grief are you kidding me.If these were two unknown people it would still be obvious who looks better.One looks classy and one looks like trashy.
OMG..really? People mag come on. There is not a comparison.
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge! You should not have put Kim next to her. People mag should be ashamed.
If you notice the design tails on the hips really helped define Kate's petite frame while Kim having large hips looked suffocated in the dress. Kate looks much classier than Kim, and what can one expect from the Diva of Reality?
I think Kate looks fabulous in this dress, she has style and she is classic lady
Be.... Not at all jealous I am 49 years old I never said she was not beautiful because she is beautiful. I just think she should dress her age.
Kate has and always will be a lady! She is classy, clever and fills her roles and responsibilities beautifully and with grace!
Kim..... The less said the better! It's genetic :(
Kate looks like a lady......Kim looks like a cheap hooker trying to dress nice! Hands down Kate wins!
Paula's comments wreaks of jealousy...she probably wished that she looked as good as Kate!
Really, get real! Granted both dress are red and pleated, the same dress? not hardly.
As Kate looks nice in her dress the style is too old for her. While Kate dresses proper and elegantly, can she not wear clothes that are more age appropriate and still look proper and elegant? She is 30 years old not 50 years old . Even Princess Diana started to dress her age after awhile and she was very proper, elegant and beautiful and held her title well.
The dress doesn't even fit over Kim's hips. This is a no brainer.
Kate looks elegant and classy. Kim will modify any dress to show off what she thinks are her assets to get attention.
Catherine looks stunning and elegant. Kim looks normal like something I would see any ordinary American wearing. Personally, because Kim made a sex video, even with the press her and her family receive, I still believe it kind of tarnished any classy image of her. Kim Kardashian is a sexpot basically no matter what press she receives. Catherine is college educated, Kim is not. Catherine is royalty, Kim is not.
If Kim wasn't in the news every day, then maybe . . . Kate all the way.
Everyone in America seems to think that dresses that look like they are 3 sizes too small are fashionable. Maybe it's just a cultural thing......we ain't got none. the Duchess beats the bimbo by a mile.
as usual kim looks what she is...a whore and nothing more
Kim's fit is too tight and makes her hip & mi-section look huge, her shoesnecklace are not very attractive with the dress. It's like she's trying too many looks at one time!
I like Kate's version much better. The fit is nicer and is age-appropriate. Just because one is young doesn't mean all their "bits" need to be exposed. Kim's dress looks a bit tight in the midsection, anyway. And this has nothing to do with my opinion of either of them, because they are both successful women that have accomplished much in their young lives!
Even Kim's legs are Fat. Kate can wear a garbage bag and make it look classy.
Kim whorified it.
I agree with Danielle. I think most people are voting based on the person, not on who wore it best. There is no doubt that Kim wore it best. Kate makes it look too old for her age.
Kate = class. Kim = crass.
Ugh...please never compare beautiful and classy Kate Middleton to Kim Kardashion...really PEOPLE???
Danielle Fashion is everything about a person. Fashion shows how a person feels or cares about him/herself image. plus Kate pic looks way better then the troll Kim.
I love and Kim and Kate's style's,this time in my opinion Kim wear it better :)
This is not about the person they are. It is about their fashion ELLIE!!!
HOW IN GODS NAME CAN YOU EVEN COMPARE KAT TO KIMMY? THERE IS NONE. KATE IS THER WINNER ALL THE WAY. KATE IS DOWN TO EARTH AND KIM IS ONE BIG PHONY!