Do you think Nick and Pharrell would be good Idol judges?

11 Comments

  • Kate - 12 years ago

    Nick Jonas would be the perfect fit for an American idol judge :)

  • Isabella - 12 years ago

    I agree go kelly and carrie

  • anonymous - 12 years ago

    Carrie Underwood's sprite, heart and soul would really change the show in a good way!
    Kelly Clarkson would know just what the first judges would want.

    Go Kelly and Carrie!!!!

  • John - 12 years ago

    What happened to Adam Lambert being a judge? He'd be perfect.

  • Asha - 12 years ago

    I wish the other two judges were Carrie underwood and kelly Clarkson, or Reba.-need a country perspective

  • Anonymous - 12 years ago

    Nick Jonas would be PERFECT!!!!

  • Suzanne Wey - 12 years ago

    No that would be a huge mistake. They not ready ti judge others. Need one to know the business and thats can judge different music. I or anyone I know will not tune in if the judges are less than real.

  • Tracie Jordan - 12 years ago

    Ok they need more experience artist that can judge all types of music and older ones people respect. Like Stevie Nicks or someone thats been around long enough to now what to look for. Not someone thats just starting out or a teeny bopper. If they are judges I do believe that will be the end for american idol. I do know it will be for me and all,my friends and people I've talked to.

  • Paul - 12 years ago

    They need to have REAL artists not young kids who dont know yet what they are really doing. The judges for a competition like this need to be to doing to find the best and most autintic talent possible. They need to be able to put personal feelings aside and judge cpompletely unbiased according to real tlalent and not who they personally want to go through according to personal story like has happenned in the past. There have been too many people go too far or win that should not have made it that far. In my opinion, the last person that won that deserved to win because they had a real and true talent was Carrie Underwood. Judges need to be seasoned veterans of the music business and know what it takes to make it in the business. Putiting in younger people will only hurt the competition and the true talent will never make it to the top like they deserve. It also needs to be a person who has truly made it themselves on true talent and longivity and has the real right to tell the contestants what they need to do to improve. I actually dont feel that Mariah is a qualified judge, but that is my opinion. It is sad to see Steven leave cause was a true season veteran. Maybe they need to contact seasoned music directors or producers. They know what it takes to make it and know what true and real talent is.

  • Esther Rathbun - 12 years ago

    I would love to see Adam Lambert as a judge.

  • Brenda - 12 years ago

    They need judges who know the business not kids who havent been around that long. They need that strong opinion to help them.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment