Which Guy Should Join Mariah on 'American Idol'?

4 Comments

  • Shana - 12 years ago

    I think that Pharrell would be the perfect judge for American Idol. He's a great producer and has worked with the best of the best artist in the world. He has so much knowledge of the industry and would be an awesome contribution to the show. Adam Lambert is not qualified to judge anyone if he doesn't have the stats to prove he is a super star, he's an American Idol failure, If I had to pick a past contestant it would be Kelly Clarkson. Whoever thought about Charlie Sheen is stupid!! Why would you chance such an important thing as someone's career in the hands of a Cocaine head. I know Brad Paisley is good too, but I'm not that familiar. Nick Jonas is just a teen heart throb, he's definitely not qualified.

  • Marie - 12 years ago

    I think Adam Lambert would definitely make a great Idol judge. He is honest, articulate and funny. Most of all he experienced Idol first hand which puts him ahead of the game.......and yes the man can sing!!!!!

  • kim - 12 years ago

    Adam would be perfect for the judging position on Idol - smart, articulate, great sense of humor never mind the guy can sang! He would add a much needed edge to the show. And damn, he's gorgeous.

  • Jenna - 12 years ago

    The only one on this list that is qualified and has enough experience would be Brad Paisley. Adam Lambert is just plain repulsive not to mention his career is tanking with very poor sales of his CDs. No one likes his music. Nick Jonas has no qualifications at all. Charlie Sheen is a joke, and I'm not familiar with Pharrell.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment