Who is your favourite new Idol judge?

3 Comments

  • elle - 11 years ago

    I love watching Mariah on the panel. As for the Nicki-Mariah feud, well I don't know if it's for reals, with all the Nicki-roll-eyes as MC speaks.
    But I hope this season's Idol got to find a Kelly or Carrie, with talent and charisma.

  • Kelly - 11 years ago

    As for why none of the judges should make 12, 18 or even 6 million dollars is with all of the tragedies that have been happening world wide, even in America; how can they justify earning that kind of money when people in their own back yards are struggling and going hungry.

  • Kelly - 11 years ago

    First off, Randy Jackson should be making more than any of the new judges-he has been there the longest, and knows what does and doesn't work. Miss Carey does not deserve 18 million (no one does), she is boring, she is too motherly, and her advise isn't even there. Miss Minaj and her upper and lower implants, plus her plethora of hideous wigs does not make her worth 12 million (again, no one does); but she is at least a better and stronger judge than Ms.Carey.

    Now for Keith Urban, I think it is sick that hebis making much less than the two divas (Cary and Minaj). For starters, he is talented, he has been around a long time, he knows music inside and out; and he is no flash in the pan like Carey and soon to be Minaj. He has had a lng term career in cross over pop/country....but he is a better judge than either of two divas. They are boring.

    I miss Steven Tyler and JLo, but mostly I miss Simon. I think this will have to be the last season unless they can get some great talent going, or, better yet, get rid of Ms. Carey and bring back Simon, he is better of on Idol than his failing xfactor.

    My two cents.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment