I just reread my comment and want to be sure it is clear that I want to get rid of NIKKI. I can tolerate Mariah.
Carol - 11 years ago
I agree with ALL of the above. I have loved American Idol since it began and have been a faithful viewer. However, if they do not remove The annoying, freakish judge mentioned in every comment, I will not be able to watch it for the first time since the show has been on. I am not carried away with Mariah Carey, but I might be able to tolerate her. PLEASE get rid of her before the performances begin.
Jen - 11 years ago
Nikki is ruining my favorite show! If she stays on I will no longer even be able to watch :( She's so self absorbed, unprofessional and irritating!
cookie - 11 years ago
In total I think the show has not measured up. I think the judges are very rude in front of contestants clearly laughing in the contestants faces. That they have made it to the live show is amazing no matter now good or bad they are. When I see the judges laughing out loud in front of those that might not measure up is just in human and insensitive. At least let them leave with pride when you vote NO.....
Mary - 11 years ago
I have watched this show since the very beginning,, and the last couple years the change up of the judges were different but OK...This is you have to take her out PLEASE....Nikki has got to go ,, she it making it all about her,,, judging the judges for saying how they feel about a performance if they don't agree with Nikki baby she has a two year old tantrum and walks out ,....her voice is so #%%$%& irritating she is a attention getting hog those outfits.. are so look at me.... I have pink hair.......look at me my voice is that of a whiny baby..and rolling her eyes all the time I want to scratch them out....please fix this...
Mary - 11 years ago
I have watched this show since the very beginning,, and the last couple years the change up of the judges were different but OK...This is you have to take her out PLEASE....Nikki has got to go ,, she it making it all about her,,, judging the judges for saying how they feel about a performance if they don't agree with Nikki baby she has a two year old tantrum and walks out ,....her voice is so #%%$%& irritating she is a attention getting hog those outfits.. are so look at me.... I have pink hair.......look at me my voice is that of a whiny baby..and rolling her eyes all the time I want to scratch them out....please fix this...
BEVERLY - 11 years ago
I agree with most all of the above comments.....I believe that Nicki is very unprofessional and immature, Can't Stand her voice nor her antics to make sure everyone is paying attention to her, she seems to forget that she is NOT THE ONE IN CHARGE of the show, doesnt show respect to the other judges nor to the contestants...she makes herself look desperate and easy with all her comments and jestures toward the male contestants ...SHE NEEDS TO GO. NOT a SMART move to invite her on this year. Her opinion doesnt count with me........ Other than that...I think Keith Urban , Maria Carey and Randy Jackson are great. Thank you .
Joanne - 11 years ago
You have to get rid of Nicki she is ruining the show. I can't believe they would allow someone like Nicki to be a judge on one of America's most favorite shows. I was also wondering if she is being paid extra to be so rude and nasty so people will tune in just to she how stupid she is? If she doesn't go soon I will have quit watching the show that I have enjoyed for years.
Sheila - 11 years ago
My husband and I, including our whole family, have been American Idol fans from day one. So much exceptional talent has been discovered and you have had some wonderful judges. Nikki is most surely not one of them. If you do not take her off the panel we will defintely stop watching our favorite TV Show. She makes EVERYTHING so unenjoyable, we always mute the sound when she speaks. P-lease!
Pattim - 11 years ago
Way too busy with the judges. It is really hard to watch. I love Randy Jackson and Keith Urban but the girls got to go
KC - 11 years ago
Why does this have to be a show about the judges ? I thought it was a talent show ? It is so bad I cannot imagine it will be on the air much longer . I know it lost me !
Sandy - 11 years ago
I love American Idol and have seen almost all of them and have enjoyed and respected all of the past judges, but I'm sorry to say I'm about 2 shows away from not watching anymore this year. I cannot believe have rude Nicki is. She never shuts up or gives any of the other judges time to critique the contestants. Mariah, Randy and Keith Urban have way more class, and conduct themselves like the professionals they are. I miss the laughs the judges had amongst themselves last year. This year all I can hear is Nickis squeaky voice and nobody seems to be having a good time...including me.
Judy B - 11 years ago
Get rid of Nicki!She add s nothing to the show. It use to be a classy show but has lowered its style. I have watched since the beging and now have mixed feilings about the judges. Yeah for Randy and Mariah! Keith Yes!
Steve - 11 years ago
Get rid of Nicki or myself and everyone else I know will stop watching. Hate to see that happen as we have watched from season 1 on.
lulu - 11 years ago
mariah Carey was fine but then nicki. lol my household is out. bye American idol
Ruth Green - 11 years ago
I am new t watching American Idol the past three seasons, hiwever, with Nikki on there I cannot stand to watch. I have a large family and nne if them will be watching this season because of Nikki. Sad I will miss the new upcoming artists
Claudia - 11 years ago
I did not think they could kill the love the American people had for Idol, but Nicki is hard to listen too, look at and wants every young man to sing to her no matter how good or bad and often asks them to take off their shirts, UGH!!!! She is the worst judge and a limelight HOG!
Iab - 11 years ago
The producers are to be blame. I have lost the mind by hiring Nicki. She is a joke. She has no talent, 'she can't judge and soooo..... irritating and never gave the other judges the chance to speak first. Randy, Keith and Mariah handle themselves so professionally.
Sharon - 11 years ago
I cannot believe American Idol actually hired these two, Nicki and Mariah as the replacement judges this year... where do I start? They lack everything let's start there... I absolutely for the very first time, have to pass this year.. Randy and Keith are great.. Extremely poor choice in the other
two judges... I think they might have just ruined the show... I'm out.. I will watch something else instead....
I just reread my comment and want to be sure it is clear that I want to get rid of NIKKI. I can tolerate Mariah.
I agree with ALL of the above. I have loved American Idol since it began and have been a faithful viewer. However, if they do not remove The annoying, freakish judge mentioned in every comment, I will not be able to watch it for the first time since the show has been on. I am not carried away with Mariah Carey, but I might be able to tolerate her. PLEASE get rid of her before the performances begin.
Nikki is ruining my favorite show! If she stays on I will no longer even be able to watch :( She's so self absorbed, unprofessional and irritating!
In total I think the show has not measured up. I think the judges are very rude in front of contestants clearly laughing in the contestants faces. That they have made it to the live show is amazing no matter now good or bad they are. When I see the judges laughing out loud in front of those that might not measure up is just in human and insensitive. At least let them leave with pride when you vote NO.....
I have watched this show since the very beginning,, and the last couple years the change up of the judges were different but OK...This is you have to take her out PLEASE....Nikki has got to go ,, she it making it all about her,,, judging the judges for saying how they feel about a performance if they don't agree with Nikki baby she has a two year old tantrum and walks out ,....her voice is so #%%$%& irritating she is a attention getting hog those outfits.. are so look at me.... I have pink hair.......look at me my voice is that of a whiny baby..and rolling her eyes all the time I want to scratch them out....please fix this...
I have watched this show since the very beginning,, and the last couple years the change up of the judges were different but OK...This is you have to take her out PLEASE....Nikki has got to go ,, she it making it all about her,,, judging the judges for saying how they feel about a performance if they don't agree with Nikki baby she has a two year old tantrum and walks out ,....her voice is so #%%$%& irritating she is a attention getting hog those outfits.. are so look at me.... I have pink hair.......look at me my voice is that of a whiny baby..and rolling her eyes all the time I want to scratch them out....please fix this...
I agree with most all of the above comments.....I believe that Nicki is very unprofessional and immature, Can't Stand her voice nor her antics to make sure everyone is paying attention to her, she seems to forget that she is NOT THE ONE IN CHARGE of the show, doesnt show respect to the other judges nor to the contestants...she makes herself look desperate and easy with all her comments and jestures toward the male contestants ...SHE NEEDS TO GO. NOT a SMART move to invite her on this year. Her opinion doesnt count with me........ Other than that...I think Keith Urban , Maria Carey and Randy Jackson are great. Thank you .
You have to get rid of Nicki she is ruining the show. I can't believe they would allow someone like Nicki to be a judge on one of America's most favorite shows. I was also wondering if she is being paid extra to be so rude and nasty so people will tune in just to she how stupid she is? If she doesn't go soon I will have quit watching the show that I have enjoyed for years.
My husband and I, including our whole family, have been American Idol fans from day one. So much exceptional talent has been discovered and you have had some wonderful judges. Nikki is most surely not one of them. If you do not take her off the panel we will defintely stop watching our favorite TV Show. She makes EVERYTHING so unenjoyable, we always mute the sound when she speaks. P-lease!
Way too busy with the judges. It is really hard to watch. I love Randy Jackson and Keith Urban but the girls got to go
Why does this have to be a show about the judges ? I thought it was a talent show ? It is so bad I cannot imagine it will be on the air much longer . I know it lost me !
I love American Idol and have seen almost all of them and have enjoyed and respected all of the past judges, but I'm sorry to say I'm about 2 shows away from not watching anymore this year. I cannot believe have rude Nicki is. She never shuts up or gives any of the other judges time to critique the contestants. Mariah, Randy and Keith Urban have way more class, and conduct themselves like the professionals they are. I miss the laughs the judges had amongst themselves last year. This year all I can hear is Nickis squeaky voice and nobody seems to be having a good time...including me.
Get rid of Nicki!She add s nothing to the show. It use to be a classy show but has lowered its style. I have watched since the beging and now have mixed feilings about the judges. Yeah for Randy and Mariah! Keith Yes!
Get rid of Nicki or myself and everyone else I know will stop watching. Hate to see that happen as we have watched from season 1 on.
mariah Carey was fine but then nicki. lol my household is out. bye American idol
I am new t watching American Idol the past three seasons, hiwever, with Nikki on there I cannot stand to watch. I have a large family and nne if them will be watching this season because of Nikki. Sad I will miss the new upcoming artists
I did not think they could kill the love the American people had for Idol, but Nicki is hard to listen too, look at and wants every young man to sing to her no matter how good or bad and often asks them to take off their shirts, UGH!!!! She is the worst judge and a limelight HOG!
The producers are to be blame. I have lost the mind by hiring Nicki. She is a joke. She has no talent, 'she can't judge and soooo..... irritating and never gave the other judges the chance to speak first. Randy, Keith and Mariah handle themselves so professionally.
I cannot believe American Idol actually hired these two, Nicki and Mariah as the replacement judges this year... where do I start? They lack everything let's start there... I absolutely for the very first time, have to pass this year.. Randy and Keith are great.. Extremely poor choice in the other
two judges... I think they might have just ruined the show... I'm out.. I will watch something else instead....