ROUND 3: Who's Your Favorite YouTube Makeup Guru?

273 Comments

  • michelle hashimi - 10 years ago

    nicole has to win she is a beautiful person from inside and out she is so nice sweet caring kind amazing funny she has got to win because she also has amazing beauty tutorials skills and beauty tips she is a beauty too.

  • Carlos - 11 years ago

    I hate that I can only vote for one because soooo many of them are my favorite. But my overall fav. has to be Wayne Goss (gossmakeupartist) he's my absolute favorite.

  • Carlos - 11 years ago

    I hate that I can only vote for one because soooo many of them are my favorite. But my overall fav. has to be Wayne Goss (gossmakeupartist) he's my absolute favorite.

  • Holly Alexandra - 11 years ago

    What is going on with this contest!? Did they even have a winner? I'm confused!

  • Piumi - 11 years ago

    My favorites on YouTube are Lisa eldrige,Camila Coelho,pixiwoo,michelle phan and I like Chloe Morello too.

  • Dayana - 11 years ago

    I honestly think Nicole Guerriero has to win. she bring light into my life when i watch her videos. shes so sweet and carrying. and what she did for Talia was so cute. i honestly love her. Even though shes so beautiful shes not acting like shes the top sh*t, she even makes fun of herself. i love you nicole. good luck

  • Ria - 11 years ago

    I also love Nicole, as she's rather funny & true.. But this carli thing is just fake all over!!

    got one message for her, Get over your self!!!!!!

    Really, there are plenty of other girls with blue eyes.. she's a cheater!

  • Cassandra - 11 years ago

    I believe that both girls wear a lot of makeup but have their own way of beauty. BUT I love how Nicole goes about her video's when it comes to makeup. She's funny and brings her personality in every video she does and it's fun to watch. Props on Nicole for keeping it cool and not bashing Carlibel55. But what Carlibel55 did was just a desperate way of trying to be on top! So Nicole keep doing you girl! If you win it's because you truly have talent and if you don't win it's because you didn't cheat and you stayed true to your self and your talent. Wish you luck Girl!

  • melissa - 11 years ago

    I CANT BELIEVE CARLI HASNT BEEN DISQUALIFIED.. IF SHE WINS, THIS WHOLE CONTEST MEANS NOTHING

  • Linda - 11 years ago

    Just read this article about what Carli did to Nicole (YouTube beauty wars). Wow!

    http://www.examiner.com/article/youtube-beauty-wars

  • Glo - 11 years ago

    Why is it that when someone is at the top Americans always want to bring that person back down. Be happy for whoever win you jealous bit***. I'm sorry the other makeup artist don't have the creativity to get extra votes or have makeup to give away to their fans. I am a new Carli and Nicole fan and I don't watch their videos for their personalities I watch them to get makeup tips. You all need to accept people are not perfect, and once you do, you will stop getting disappointed.

  • Sam - 11 years ago

    Honestly I don't think Carlo is bribing I just feel like she is way to into herself and she pretends to be this caring positive humble person but sometime I catch her saying rude things Nicole is funny lol I like her but dulce candy is my favorite shes always been so humble and kind

  • Sam - 11 years ago

    Honestly I don't think Carlo is bribing I just feel like she is way to into herself and she pretends to be this caring positive humble person but sometime I catch her saying rude things Nicole is funny lol I like her but dulce candy is my favorite shes always been so humble and kind

  • yellow - 11 years ago

    Why isnt Michelle phan and promise phan inside??!!!

  • Cat - 11 years ago

    NICOLE GUERRIERO!!!! ♥♥♥ She deserves to Win.
    Carli is WAY into herself, whitout all of that stuf she puts on, she's just average. But, Nicole even without make up and all natural she still is STUNNING!!!!! And her personality makes her even more beautiful, i think Carli is kind of fake and conceited. WAH! NICOLE

  • Geraldine - 11 years ago

    Nicole is the best!❤ Good luck Nicole Guerriero

  • #carliBel55 !!! - 11 years ago

    carliBel55 alllllll the wayyyy

  • amanda - 11 years ago

    tyme shoudn't win. she have an ugly personality

  • Amelia M - 11 years ago

    I still cant believe ZUKREAT is not here anymore. She has more Makeup talent in her little finger than most of these others. It just shows its more of a popularity contest that Makeup artistry! TEAM ZUKREAT all the way!!

  • carina mendoza - 11 years ago

    Carli bybel should not win.. she is a cheater . NICOLE deserves this.

  • SARAH A. - 11 years ago

    NICOLE GUERRIERO ALL DAY EVERY DAY !!! CARLI BYBEL DOES NOT PLAY FAIR , NO OTHER YOUTUBE GURU THREW A $500 GIVEAWAY SO THAT PEOPLE COULD VOTE FOR THEM AND THEN TRIED TO DENY IT WASNT FOR THAT REASON. SHES NOT GOOD AT MAKEUP.. SHES JUST A PRETTY WITH A LISP THAT IS WAY TOO INTO HERSELF. JUST SAYING. I AM NOT HATING, JUST STATING FACTS. NICOLE IS AWESOME AND HAS A PERSONALITY! CARLI TRIES TO HARD TO BE LIKE NICOLE.. WHICH SHOWS WHO SHOULD WIN!!!

  • queen of angel - 11 years ago

    NICOLE GUERRERO♥!!!

  • riley - 11 years ago

    Carlibel55 is a beautiful sweet girl. Her personality shows in her videos and she by no means meant to be a cheater. stop with all the negative comments. i just started watching carli's videos about a month ago and instantly saw how genuine and down to earth she was. who cares if she wears a lot of makeup. she does makeup amazing. why not show off her skills. carli you are beautiful and i love your videos. i hope you win :)

  • Stephanie - 11 years ago

    Go jaclynhill1 you'be made my everyday make up easier! Hope you win!!

  • Say NO to CARLIBEL55 - 11 years ago

    I think Carlibel55 should be disqualified! Enough said. She's shady!

  • erika - 11 years ago

    ITS ALL ABOUT NICOLE GUERRERO♥!!!

  • Lindsay - 11 years ago

    This poll is ridiculous. Nicole Guerriero and Carlibell55? Really? I cant even watch their videos bc they wear more makeup than drag queens. The real makeup artists like Lisa Eldridge and Pixiwoo being overshadowed by these girls is just sad. They're the ones with the true talent.

  • Jbella - 11 years ago

    I don't think anyone should vote for tyme she's so ungrateful and could careless about her fans! Peep her Instagram! She's rude as hell! I say nicole guerrio all day! She's a sweetheart and appreciates her fans unlike tyme who thinks she's queen sh$t when she aint

  • Stacey - 11 years ago

    @ laura... um what was the point of your comment? Your the one that sounds like an idiot cursing for no reason. You can get a life

  • laura - 11 years ago

    Uuhhh hating bitchesss shut the fuck up...if Carli55 wins thats awsome. If nicole wins great too get a damn life people. THE PEOPLE HATING ARE JUST MAD CAUSE Carli winning. SUCK IT UP..AND MATURE..:O

  • Coco - 11 years ago

    What do they win of they win this contest? Is it just the title of being YouTube best beauty guru?

  • Brittany - 11 years ago

    DulceCandy over any of these girls! LOVE HER! So inspirational XO!

  • Crystal Linaa - 11 years ago

    Im so happy DULCE CANDY is making it to the top. She is awesome everyone. Yall should check her out. Also a new fan of Nicole.

  • Terese - 11 years ago

    I also agree with EVERYONE that says nicole should win. Not hating on carli ( even though i DO think she totally bribed people, and maybe she should even be disqualified.) Nicole deserves it, people truly love her she is amazing, so real, and truly inspires people! Love you nicole xox

  • Cerys - 11 years ago

    carli i would love to win your giveaway, your absolutely amazing and ive watched every single one of your videos! thankyou

  • chantell - 11 years ago

    everyone needs to calm down.... calri is only doing a give away because she gained 500,000 followers on youtube so shes doing a giveaway to thank them... shes not doing anything wrong... all the girls that are in this competition are telling their followers to vote for them so its not just calri.... like i said her giveaway is to thank all of her suscribers..

  • Amber Z - 11 years ago

    I just finished all your steps Carli, I would LOVE LOVE LOVE to win som Bellimi Hair Extensions! I do not have twitter thou so sorry. Crossing fingers & toes to win:) good luck!

  • Cassie - 11 years ago

    Everyone just needs to calm down. I have personally been following Carli longer and that's why I voted for her. And Lynda was right, there were no rules. And of course Carli changed her requirement because she doesn't want people to be angry with her. I'm sure you all know she's a liar and a cheater and a horrible friend to Nicole, etc, etc...because you all know her personally, right???

  • Edelin - 11 years ago

    Oh yea thanks for the lollipop(: Nicole also has had a giveaway since this has started and she didnt have voting for her as a requirement. The only reason carli is in the lead is because of the giveaway. Nicole had been number one for all rounds but regardless we know NICOLE IS #1 !!!

  • Tiana - 11 years ago

    What's shocking about what Carli did is that she couldn't just be happy for her "FRIEND" to be in the lead. She couldn't bare that Nicole is more popular & talented make-up wise than she is. It's pathetic and desperate. Even if she does win it will be an empty victory. You conned a friend out of The recognition she deserves - SAVE your 'positive attitude' quotes and what not, they're laughable now. She knows Nicole would have won if she hadn't of bribed her followers. What will she do in the next round? She made a fun contest between friends dirty... SAD!

  • Lynda - 11 years ago

    Very true, Edelin honey. You little genious. My bad - here's a lollipop. Be glad she changed it shortly after then. I'm sure it was not her intention to upset anyone. She's just celebrating the fact she has reached 500k subbies by doing a big giveawayand, as always, people find something to hate on. It's getting so old. It's pathetic. Voting on here being one of the requirements at first, doesn't change the fact people need to get over it already. If Nicole (for example) would have done this, all the Nicole fans would be quiet or defending her right now. All the people, or atleast most, are mad, simply because their favorite is now #2. There's no rules on here about how to get votes, are there? The way she got the extra boost, honestly, is pretty damn smart and you all know it. Time to accept it, too.

  • Edelin - 11 years ago

    Lynda girl shows how much you know about carli's giveaways. Voting for her was part of the giveaway rules until she was getting so much negative feed back she changed it. Know before u open your mouth!

  • Kim P. - 11 years ago

    I think we should take a poll if Carli should be disqualified or not...oh the irony!

  • Saby Rodriguez - 11 years ago

    I love carli, great advice, she knows here stuff and is a beautiful woman. The other contestants are just jealous that shes winning, I swear some people can act more sour than limes. Good look to her she deserves to win, keep up the good work dear.

  • Carrie - 11 years ago

    Carlibel55 is a cheater plain and simple. she has no self confidence to rely on votes the honest way without having to bribe for prizes. She is disgusting.

  • Lynda - 11 years ago

    Giveaway** Not competition.

  • Lynda - 11 years ago

    All this crap about CarliBel cheating is RIDICULOUS. People, you need to get over yourself. Stop being a bunch of drama queens, please - it doesn't look good on any of you. The way I read it, the requirements for entering her competition does NOT include voting on here. There's 6 steps you have to take in order to participate: follow her 1st channel, follow her 2nd channel, follow twitter, follow facebook, follow instagram and open something called ''worldwide''. Voting on here is NOT one of these steps. It is only requested to do so, outside of the giveaway. Get over she fact people like her. Cheers to her for reaching 500k subscribers.

  • Abril - 11 years ago

    I was a fan of Carlibel but now we want to buy them all with the giveaway, that's not fair, she's cheating should disqualify

  • Jaysmomma81 - 11 years ago

    Nicole is the winner regardless shes awesome! True talent and most of all unique, her own sense of style and personality!

  • Stacey - 11 years ago

    LOVE YOU Nicole!! You are such a GENUINE person and so down to earth!
    #creepinitreal we love you! You got this!

  • Andrea - 11 years ago

    Nicole has my vote 110% ... and i have high hopes that she is going to be the winner. Carli may be a little competition but we cannot really blame her. Nicole is beautiful in and out .. outstanding personality, and that is what makes her a winner in my eyes... dont worry nicole. i guarantee you will be the winner of this competition, u deserve it most. ive seen all ur videos. yes im team creep. lol but there is one thing i will never fail to notice. u keep it real. u have not changed throughout the years, the only thing tht did change was ur video qualities. that is all. you have my vote. and for sure i will get all the people i know to vote for u as well. :D i expect to see pictures of u next to ryan seacrest. i am that positive u r going to be the winner ! keep it up girl.

  • Gabriela - 11 years ago

    I sent a message complaint on this website notifying them of Carli's bribery. I also asked them to disqualify her since it's definitely CHEATING and nothing less. Hopefully if enough of us do the same, maybe somebody will listen.

    Her new video doesn't bribe viewers to vote if they want prizes, which SCREAMS of her guilty conscience! This little contest really brought out her true colors!! I loved her and felt bad for people ragging on her before but now I see the real Carli!!

    Vote for anyone but Carli!!

  • loyalty - 11 years ago

    Keep voting girls! We aren't doing too bad for having a cheater on here. #creepnation

  • Lucinda - 11 years ago

    I am shocked of what I am reading about Carli and the other girls. If you think about it, these girls want to win, all of them. Carli is a normal girl who has exceptional talent and she is sharing it to everyone, just like all the other girls. I am taking no ones side here. It is NOT right to embarrass someone on an online site for everyone in this world to read. Shame on every single person who had something bad to say about ANY of these girls. Live your own life and stop worrying about what others are doing... Leave the judging to God one day...

    And from my point of view. All these girls should be winners as they ALL have great talent!

  • jazmin avila - 11 years ago

    ! CARLIBEL55: 32.08% , I DO NOT HAVE TWITTER
    good luck too you carlibel55 i love all your videos and personality hope you win xoxoxoxo

  • nalanie chintamoni - 11 years ago

    GOOD LUCK CARLIBEL!!! I've already been following all of your social networks...I hope you win, you deff deserve to! "JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS to enter Giveaway!! CARLIBEL55:

  • Kay Anne - 11 years ago

    Already subscribed to you on YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and Instagram so I guess I am already entered in your giveaway!! CARLIBEL55: 32.11% , GO CARLI!!!

    My YouTube is Kay Anne just so you know :)

  • Crystal Linaa - 11 years ago

    Go Dulce Candy!,
    Go ITSJUDYTIME
    Go Nicole!
    Iam a new subscriber to Nicole, She's awesome.
    Im not even looking at Caris videos, I've heard to many bad things

  • Bbrunette - 11 years ago

    Carli, why are you so insecure? Do you not trust your subscribers to vote for you without having to bribe them with your pathetic Nume giveaway? I loved watching your videos up until now.. Unsuscribed live. Pretty sad that Nicole was apparently your friend and you couldn't stand her winning this competition.. It says a lot about your personality, you're insecure, greedy, extremely selfish and shameless. yack!

  • Lol - 11 years ago

    Good for you Carli for being in the lead. Embrace it girl, because in around a year or two from now no one will give a fart about you. Let's all cheer Carli on folks, she's an insecure girl and needs all the internet validation she can get - by any means nescessary. Her life is a fabrication of social media and she likes to make herself feel better by having her minions and Jersey trash friends be her personal PR (otherwise bashing other people who fail to kiss her behind). I find it hilarious how the slightest comment deemed negative by this girl gets blocked/deleted/attacked and she does nothing but encourage it. I used to think she was attractive, even pretty, but boy every flaw and ugly trait on her is sure showing now. Ride the money train for as long it lasts sweetheart. Your stop is coming soon.

  • April - 11 years ago

    CARLIBEL55 IS A CHEATER!!!!!!!!

  • Carol - 11 years ago

    Caribel is erasing and blocking any comment saying its not fair she's doing a giveaway to win votes!to bad she cnt erase the ones from here lol
    Anyway, I honestly think Nicole should win!! Come on she was leading round one and two and semi finals , until caribel decides to do the "giveaway", staightout cheating!! She should be disqualified !!!! Team #nicole

  • Kelly - 11 years ago

    Ridiculous...Carli should be disqualified! Make this contest fair and disqualify her!

  • Laura K - 11 years ago

    Carli is nothing but a cheater. Nicole deserves it.

  • Eunice - 11 years ago

    I know probably carli or Nicole will win. But everybody should check out JaclynHill1 on YouTube, she is a makeup artist and she is super talented! I guarantee you will become obsessed with her. :)

  • Michelle - 11 years ago

    I loved Cali until I realized she was a cheater. Quite sad that she couldn't rely on her talent alone and had to cheat to win. NICOLE ALL THE WAY! Way more REAL!

  • Sam D - 11 years ago

    Seriously I want Nicole to be on top. She's very true to herself and her fans. Love her and will always love her. I'll keep voting for her until she's on top again.

  • Anniek - 11 years ago

    I like nicole so much so I voted for her from the beginning and she was also number 1 every round so it's obvious that carlibell bought her votes by doing the give away. Anyway for me nicole is #1 even she will win or not. But after this I de-subscribed carlibell.

  • Crystal Linaa - 11 years ago

    everyone who is voting for Cari really wants to win lol.
    VOTE FOR DULCE, Im checking out other gurus and Nicole and Andrea are awesome and they have new subscribers ;) Also Ive been watching ITSJUDYTIME for a while now Shes great!

  • Ange - 11 years ago

    Well the cheater is still in the lead, at least this is just the semi-finals....wonder if she'll come up with another bribe for the finals? Hmmm

  • Kimberly - 11 years ago

    Jeeeaaloooussss, because Carli is going to wiinnn!! Jaaaa

  • Marcella - 11 years ago

    Carliface! I love your channel, voted for you and followed all the steps. However i don't have twitter. Know that you are truly inspiring to us gals!

  • Joana - 11 years ago

    Just followed all the steps for the giveaway! Carlibel55: 32.53% I don't have a Facebook!

  • Maria - 11 years ago

    I cannot believe carli is manipulating people to vote for her . I love Nicole ! She doesn't manipulate anyone she already knows she's a winner , love u Nicole !

  • Teanna Chesterfield - 11 years ago

    Yayyyyyy Carlie at 32%!!!! I love everyone but I really hope Carlie wins!!! ❤❤❤ she's so inspiring, uplifting and beautiful inside and out!!! ❤❤❤ you deserve this Carlie!
    ❤Teanna❤
    (Your biggest fan!!!!!)

  • Megan - 11 years ago

    Y'all are haters seriously! Carli deserves to win! She's gorg and even better shares her beauty secrets with us! I wouldn't know half the stuff Ido if it wasn't fr her!!!

  • laura - 11 years ago

    FACT***

  • laura - 11 years ago

    It DOESN'T MATTER whether the give away was planned weeks in advanced, that's irrelevant, IT'S THE FAT CARLIBEL55's requirement to enter said giveaway is to vote (MANIPULATE) the poll in order to be eligible. Perhaps she just should have had the giveaway without a voting requirement!

  • Kelsey - 11 years ago

    For everyone who is saying she posted the giveaway video for this, your WAY wrong. She posted it because she got 500K subbies! So what if part of it is to vote for her? Every contest she has you have to follow her or vote for her. This is really no different. And half these people who are saying she should be disqualified dont even watch her videos. I have been watching Carli since the beginning and she is such an angel! If you think she did this on purpose try watching her videos. And honestly I think she could care less about the haters out there! GO CARLI ❤

  • mari - 11 years ago

    just followed all the steps for giveaway! carlibel 33% i do have twitter facebook and instagram

  • Desiree - 11 years ago

    Shaaanxo all the way!

  • Lynn - 11 years ago

    VOTE FOR NICOLE GUERRIERO! SHE IS AMAZING AND TALENTED AND SO REAL!!!!

  • Jess - 11 years ago

    Just followed all the steps for the give away! Carlibell55:32% !! I don't have any social networks, or I would've been following you along time ago! Xo

  • Monique - 11 years ago

    It's funny how Carlibel55 keeps repeating that her giveaway has been planned for weeks and that's it's for 500k, she could of came up with 10000 different ways of entering her giveaway, but she comes up with one and it's to come and vote for her on this contest, she's just making up excuses to not look bad. Her giveaway obviously worked cause she was second this entire time & the minute her video went up, she was first... Every second she has people posting on that video that they just came to vote for her on here so they're now entered, and they write down what % she's now at... Is that the idea of this contest? I thought the entire idea was to find out which beauty guru is the most liked, not which one can come up with the best way of cheating !

  • angela lira - 11 years ago

    JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS TO ENTER GIVEAWAY!! CARLIBEL55: 31.96% **dont have any social media ~~ GOOD LUCK

  • Emma Jansson - 11 years ago

    CARLIBEL! JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS to enter Giveaway!! , I DO NOT HAVE TWITTER, MUCH LOVE FROM SWEDEN! XOXO

  • Samantha - 11 years ago

    JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS TO ENTER GIVEAWAY!! CARLIBEL: 32.12%, I do not have twitter. Xoxo :)

  • Steph - 11 years ago

    Nicole Guierriero needs to win this! She's the most amazing beauty guru and REAL person! She doesn't need bribes and giveaways to win votes...you know who should be disqualified from this contest! Nicole all the way!!!!!!!!

  • Charissa - 11 years ago

    I wish everyone would calm down about Carli. She had this giveaway in the works for weeks, way before this contest. PLUS she cant really tell if you voted or not to be picked as a winner. So chill! She simply asked for y'all to vote. She just hit 500K subscribers on youtube which is way more than Nicole. I love Nicole as well but Carli was the first Makeup Guru I followed and ill always pick her. And again, Nicole & Carli are friends and they have no beef to one another, its all Nicole's fans...

  • Anna - 11 years ago

    VOTE FOR SHAAANXO SHE DOSENT CHEAT LIKE SOME PEOPLE (CarliBel55) go shaaanxo xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx shaaanxo xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • angela lira - 11 years ago

    JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS TO ENTER GIVEAWAY!! CARLIBEL55: 31.96% **dont have any social media ~~ GOOD LUCK

  • Carmen - 11 years ago

    I can't believe CarliBel55 has to block people (including me), just for voicing their opinion on her giveaway video. Even if Nicole doesn't win, she will always be my favorite. she doesn't need BRIBES for her vote.

  • Nancy - 11 years ago

    JUST FOLLOWED ALL THE STEPS to enter Giveaway! CARLIBEL55: 32% I DO NOT HAVE TWITTER NOR FACEBOOK. Good Luck!

  • Sylvie - 11 years ago

    Carlibel55 needs to be disqualified from this contest or not it just promotes bribing-cheating.

  • Kelly - 11 years ago

    Jrzgirlz is my favorite youtube beauty guru - She's up and coming and my fav!!! http://youtube.com/jrzgirlz

  • Victoria Villarreal - 11 years ago

    Carlibel55 is the perfect person to win this. She shows a lot of great makeup tutorials, great tips and more. Please for Vote Carlibell55! #1

  • Victoria Villarreal - 11 years ago

    Carlibel55 is the perfect person to win this. She shows a lot of great makeup tutorials, great tips and more. Please for Vote Carlibell55! #1

  • Myrna Russell - 11 years ago

    I will take no bribe! Nicole from the start! CREEPFORLIFE, TAKENOBRIBE, TEAMNICOLE! Carli should be disqualified, bribery shouldn't be a part of beauty wars! Sad, sad, sad...I used to really like her, but this made her so ugly to me. As Nicole's friend, some good clean competition should be just that.

  • erika - 11 years ago

    Nicole has been winning all these rounds without having to do a giveaway nor had to be frequently asking for votes carli is a great artist but her character just made her ugly. #TEAMNICOLE
    #1SINCETHEBEGINNING
    #VOTENICOLE

  • Leylyn jacquez - 11 years ago

    Just followed the steps for the give away!
    Carlibel55: 32% I don't have a twitter
    You're beautiful and I hope you win because your an amazing makeup artist Goodluck !!!!

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment