Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo

ROUND 3: Who Is Your Favorite 'American Idol' Winner of All Time? (Poll Closed)

  •  
     
  •  
     
  •  
     
  •  
     
  •  
     
  •  
     
19 Comments

  • Shari - 11 years ago

    I am always amazed that the radio is not playing David or Kris's singles. It is one of the reasons more people aren't hearing their music. I wish we could go back to the days when people could request on the radio instead of having so called "experts" giving DJ;s a playlist that repeats the same song over and over again until you are sick of it. I remember when they were allowed to play cuts deeper in a cd that had not been released as a single and requests from listeners. It made radio much more fun to listen to. I like all three of these Idols and buy all three of their music. I don't know why Kelly is played on the radio more than the other two. Why wasn't Lie by David Cook released as a single and played on the radio after Carrie Underwood had him sing it on her show? Bad marketing . Maybe the only reason Kelly isn't winning is that she has "made it" and people want to draw more attention two two really great singers who aren't getting the recognition they deserve.

  • Bubby Boots - 11 years ago

    Yeah we know it's for fun but we like winning for a change. Personally I hate these stupid polls because I feel Idol gets their jollies off. Maybe they twiddle their thumbs the whole day. But I get sick and tired of them doing "selective" promotion. So because of that, it's up to the fans to do their own promoting because I believe that whoever is in charge of Idol publicity and promotion would like everyone to believe that only certain of their "chosen ones" have fans, when in reality, the ones they promote the least, also are not only doing well, but are very well liked.

  • Fan - 11 years ago

    You guys are taking this too seriously. It's just for fun. My favorite is Taylor BTW. :)

  • YeahRight - 11 years ago

    It is possible to vote multiple times per round on this poll. It's not super easy, but it can be done. I just tested it. For every vote I cast for each of the contestants their % went up .01%. Except for Kris Allen. I voted a total of 6 times for him and the net result is his % went down .01%. Would the person or persons running this poll care to explain that?

  • p2fan - 11 years ago

    screw this rigged poll people obviously still bitter about his win, get a life

  • Bev - 11 years ago

    Ken, when one votes over and over and over....it's called spamming. You cannot vote as much as you like unless you know how to spam.

  • Alex sosa - 11 years ago

    Philip Philip is the best singer in the world

  • rod777 - 11 years ago

    you can not vote as many times as u want, in fact, even when i vote twice, the % decrease, i dont know why, but thats what happen when i vote 4 Phillip.

  • Ken - 11 years ago

    Bev. I dont know what you mean by spamming, but you can vote over and over until you want to stop. That's what I was referring to.

  • Abby - 11 years ago

    Kris Allen definitely! He's an incredible songwriter and singer!

  • Cassidy - 11 years ago

    Kris Allen is my favorite on this list. Taylor Hicks is my second, but I have to give all my votes to Kris. So in answer to "who the heck is voting for Taylor Hicks", I guess his fans. Just because someone is NOT promoted by TBTB or because they're not discussed in every tabloid or appear on every award show, does not mean they don't have fans.

    However, if people want to believe that, far be it for me to burst their bubbles.

  • GT - 11 years ago

    Kris Allen is a fantastic singer and songwriter. His tour shows are the best and inspirational. Luv seeing him at live shows.

  • p - 11 years ago

    who the hell is voting for taylor hicks lol? no offense, didnt know he had a huge fanbase

  • Bev - 11 years ago

    Ken...Even if I want to spam, this poll won't allow you to, so your theory is not correct this time. Of course there may be some fans who know how to spam because that's what they always do, but I haven't. And I also disagree that it has nothing to do with sales because some CDs were not promoted as much as others and some singles were never sent for adds like others too.

    But what I find ironic is that if YOUR favorite was winning...and by YOUR I don't mean you, in particular, Ken, I mean WHOEVER'S, then that person would think it was a legitimate and accurate poll.

    So if you think Kelly should win, then vote for her. If you think it should be David, then vote for him. Kris' people should vote for Kris. Taylor's fans for him, etc. And let the best man or woman win. So far it seems to be neck and neck between Kris and David. So maybe, just maybe they ARE both well liked.

  • Kitz - 11 years ago

    I agree with Ken. This poll is for Entertainment only. Wont make any difference who wins. Chill out and have fun! My favorite is David Cook btw.

  • Ken - 11 years ago

    One thing people have to realize is that a lot of these polls where you can vote as many times as you want, doesn't show who the most popular is. It shows what fans have the most time to click all day so relax. The numbers (i.e. album sales, hit songs, followers etc) show who the most popular is.

  • SG - 11 years ago

    Kris Allen forever. Best American Idol winner ever graced the Idol stage.

  • anonymous - 11 years ago

    Well the thing about that is it has to be YOUR favorite idol and Kelly is not mine. David Cook is. Whether or not she was the first. Don't see the logic lol

  • .-. - 11 years ago

    Why is Kris & David winning? Kelly deserves to win. She's the original Idol plus the most talented.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.