Both similar players, with Harley obviously having an extra flag under his belt. The fact is Nick will go on to play more games and be involved in more finals series than Harley.
That the poor excuse for a human that is Scarlett had the temerity to say that none of their team respected Maxwell is an oxymoron. They obviously thought about him and he got on their nerves enough for him to bring up his name in a cowards way through his book. I would take Maxwell, if only because Tom Harley wears very ordinary looking cardigans in his Swisse commercials
Shayne Cole - 10 years ago
Tom Harley was a really overrated footballer so my vote goes to Nick Maxwell all the way
Nick - 10 years ago
They're both ordinary players who played in good sides. I think Harley is way more overrated then Maxy
Luke - 10 years ago
This poll clearly show's that Harley is much better than Maxwell. Respect is a two way street, and the fact the Maxwell never showed much respect to other clubs/players, is what will make him live in Harley's shadow forever. Harley was a gentleman of the game, and thus well respected across the league. Whilst not doubting Maxwell's abilities as a player or captain, it seems that his lack of ability to be a respectful gentleman of the game, has cost in more ways than just this poll.
Brian - 10 years ago
Both very good captain's and leaders at their respective clubs. Being a Cats supporter my vote is with Tom Harley. Great speaker and role modelled the expected behaviour on and off the field.
Both similar players, with Harley obviously having an extra flag under his belt. The fact is Nick will go on to play more games and be involved in more finals series than Harley.
That the poor excuse for a human that is Scarlett had the temerity to say that none of their team respected Maxwell is an oxymoron. They obviously thought about him and he got on their nerves enough for him to bring up his name in a cowards way through his book. I would take Maxwell, if only because Tom Harley wears very ordinary looking cardigans in his Swisse commercials
Tom Harley was a really overrated footballer so my vote goes to Nick Maxwell all the way
They're both ordinary players who played in good sides. I think Harley is way more overrated then Maxy
This poll clearly show's that Harley is much better than Maxwell. Respect is a two way street, and the fact the Maxwell never showed much respect to other clubs/players, is what will make him live in Harley's shadow forever. Harley was a gentleman of the game, and thus well respected across the league. Whilst not doubting Maxwell's abilities as a player or captain, it seems that his lack of ability to be a respectful gentleman of the game, has cost in more ways than just this poll.
Both very good captain's and leaders at their respective clubs. Being a Cats supporter my vote is with Tom Harley. Great speaker and role modelled the expected behaviour on and off the field.