Did the Appeals Board get the Jack Viney decision right?

9 Comments

  • Alan OMeara - 10 years ago

    Finally, at last, someone in the AFL has some common sense and aren't the
    bunch of idiots we were coming to beleive they were.
    Put real players on the panel and not pansies that are there now.

  • Brandon - 10 years ago

    AFl in a couple of years is going to turn into netball I swear, the players need to toughen up a bit like the generation before them

  • lumpinee - 10 years ago

    its pathetic,its all about The AFL appeasing to the Mums,(how about the players ?)this is how low the afl has sunk in its desire to project to the parents that the afl game is safe n the best option for theyre children,and in taking this path, meddling with it to the point that its an eyesore and unrecoginisable,its become more than unbearable,ppl want valu for money,AFL,yur skating on a very thin ice,if yur business continues to fail to entertain,you will be out of business,as soon as you lose the publics respect,you will lose yur business,make no mistake about that.

  • Chas - 10 years ago

    Guilty,there wasn't any need to hi the opposing teams player at all as both his arms were already pinned by his team-mate rendering him unable to dispose of the ball,look at the photos or video footage PEOPLE!!!!

  • Chas - 10 years ago

    Guilty,there wasn't any need to hi the opposing teams player at all as both his arms were already pinned by his team-mate rendering him unable to dispose of the ball,look at the photos or video footage PEOPLE!!!!

  • Justin - 10 years ago

    Irrespective, the game is now dead!
    Thanks Demetriou..... You killed it!

  • brian - 10 years ago

    So the 3 tribunal experts got it wrong so sack them

  • RICHIE BAKER - 10 years ago

    DOES THIS MEAN THERE HAS TO BE A MEDIA STORM EVERY WEEK TO GET THE TRIBUNAL TO MAKE A COMMON SENSE DECISION???

  • Patch - 10 years ago

    I agree with the decision and what about poor Nat Fyfe?

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment