Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo

11 Comments

  • emma - 10 years ago

    Emma should have thought about bring what she was doing before bring Marian to the future she's a good person and all but she didn't think

  • Alison - 10 years ago

    The poll mentions nothing about Emma saving Marian's life. The problem here is not that she saved Marian's life, it's that she brought her to the future! Hook warned her not to do it, Rumplestiltskin warned her not to do it, heck, anybody who has ever seen a time travel movie knows not to do it. Anyway, they very well could have just left her in the forest unconscious. And after she woke up...well, who would believe her if she told people she met two time-travelers from the future?

    Although when you think about it, this is more Hook's fault than Emma's since he's the one who took Marian through the portal. (despite the fact that he'd just got done telling Emma that she shouldn't alter the past because it could have serious consequences, hmm) Sloppy writing at its finest. Regardless of the motive, it was a very thoughtless thing to do on both Emma and Hook's part. I would've expected this from Henry, not his 30-year-old mother.

  • Sophie Jones - 10 years ago

    Why was Emma bringing Marian back a mistake? Regina would have had an innocent women killed. It's not Emma's mistake that Reginas past bit her on the ass. Emma didn't have a clue that Marian had an affiliation to Robin.
    Don't get me wrong i want Robin to end up with Regina (as i think they will) but Emma saving a life wasn't the was a problem. The mistake should've have been "Regina going on a killing spree and then accusing everyone else of not understanding circumstances."

  • Lindsey - 10 years ago

    Emma should have thought about this decision more carefully. Sometimes its okay to let someone die, if they want to die to help someone else. it is very cruel to NOT let a person do what they see as their duty. if they want to help, to sacrifice, to give up something for the greater good, then you should let them, or they'll feel they haven't done their part. I understand that these weren't the exact circumstances in which Marian and Emma were set free, but Marian wanted Emma to go without her, to leave her behind. Emma should have let her.

    Btw, jennifer, hook's redemption, as you call it, was real and he does care for emma. he has been hurt so many times- when Milah dies, when baelfire, his only connection to her left, refuses to befriend him, when emma betrays him on the beanstalk, and when cora dies. so let him have a cance at happiness! also, when they "crashed the ball," they weren't expecting to see the king announce them to the whole crowd.

  • Lindsey - 10 years ago

    Emma should have thought about this decision more carefully. Sometimes its okay to let someone die, if they want to die to help someone else. it is very cruel to NOT let a person do what they see as their duty. if they want to help, to sacrifice, to give up something for the greater good, then you should let them, or they'll feel they haven't done their part. I understand that these weren't the exact circumstances in which Marian and Emma were set free, but Marian wanted Emma to go without her, to leave her behind. Emma should have let her.

    Btw, jennifer, hook's redemption, as you call it, was real and he does care for emma. he has been hurt so many times- when Milah dies, when baelfire, his only connection to her left, refuses to befriend him, when emma betrays him on the beanstalk, and when cora dies. so let him have a cance at happiness! also, when they "crashed the ball," they weren't expecting to see the king announce them to the whole crowd.

  • Jennifer - 10 years ago

    Emma should definitely be on here but not for bringing back Marian. That was reckless but understandable and in character. She should be here for falling for Hook's "redemption", or not having an alias ready when they crashed the ball, or buying into the "You defeated Zelena..." speech, or any other number of dumb things her character has been made to do in the service of Captain Swan.

  • Amy - 10 years ago

    I agree with the other comment ...Emma shouldn't even be on this list, I get some fans are 'conflicted' and wish she'd left an innocent woman to die and it sucks right now for Regina and fans of her and Robin(and I love Regina)...but Emma saved the life of an innocent woman who was imprisoned because she was trying to help Snow White...if it wasn't for people like Marian back in the Enchanted Forest trying to 'help' her mother Emma wouldn't even be here (nor would Henry) ... I'll be honest this plot device was my least favorite part of what I thought was a stellar finale but I can't fault Emma for it, I mean she even took her to the 'future' so not to change the past. True Love on this show was never 'easy' I don't expect Regina's path to it to be all sunshine and roses either.

  • Kate - 10 years ago

    I think it's sad that Emma saving a woman's life is even on here. She is a good person who SAVED A LIFE. and spoilers: it doesn't matter that she is back with her family now so Regina can't be with Robin because do you really think it would have worked out if Robin had found out Regina killed his wife and mother of his son? Of course not. Marian won't be able to escape her fate so Outlaw Queen will still happen but this has fixed something Regina would never have been able to take back. Emma did a good thing and made it so OQ can one day actually happen. But seriously since when is saving a life a bad thing?

  • Julie - 10 years ago

    I think everybody wondered why Slade didn't frisk Felicity on Arrow, but what fun would that have been? He was so distracted, so sure he'd outsmarted Oliver, so sure Felicity wasn't "strong." She nailed it (and him!) and he paid the price for underestimating Oliver and Felicity. It's scenes like those that make Arrow such a great show and Oliver/Felicity such a fantastic pair, partners, and team. Is it any wonder I love them together?

  • Catherine - 10 years ago

    Beckett should have been smarter than this.

  • Naomi - 10 years ago

    I don't think Joan moving out of the brownstone is a dumb move. Her getting her own place is a good thing and a thing she needs to do. She does need to have her own space because Sherlock isn't supposed to be her whole life. And Sherlock does need to learn to live on his own again.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.