Who do you think is responsible for shooting down Malaysia Airlines flight MH17?

31 Comments

  • Susan - 10 years ago

    Russia denies everything. It havent even gone to Ukraine neither started the war according to Putin. Still it shoot rockets from russian side to ukraine and heavily is arming seperatist. Russia is for sure responsible for this war and for this plane crash.
    Humans havent learned anything from history, that is for sure.

  • LIsa - 10 years ago

    all of you need to use some logic...wake up and realize we do not know the facts.....the facts will never be revealed to us commoners.... and all of our Governments are liars and thieves. I refuse to side with any of them and feel they should all be let go. we need to all come together for world peace... stop the fighting....for what reason do we really fight each other if not to line the pockets of each involved Government. I am angry that so very many innocent lives are lost and yet the ones responsible never accept blame and think more war is the answer. WTH?

  • Barbara Means - 10 years ago

    While it is our naure as humans to want to blame and seek retribution, there is the whole issue that the public, (as usual), does not have the informatioon to draw a factual conclusion. I agree once the evidence documents:
    1. Who truly the weapon?
    2. The destination from which it was fired?
    3. Who fired the weapon?

    We need to think what stance the U.S, "should" take" in light of all the tremendous problems in our owm country. What will be the dominoe effect of our involvement? Will we ultimately end up send armed forces for more of our citizens to die? Will the U.S. declare war and why, if it should happen, must it be the U.S? Is U.S. national security bein threatened at this point?

    I do certainly promote extreme watchfulness, preparedness, but caution, as this could quickly escalate out of poportionand control. Do we, as humn beings, supposedly from a nation that looks out for those caught up in collateral damage, the innocent, want to see that happen, as we have time and again in all of the wars since time began? I realize Obams wants to increase sanctions and I don't know if that action would have any influence. I am not an Obama fan, but perhaps can we spare even a few this time?
    Simply some ideas to consider before we jump the gun.

  • kundan - 10 years ago

    The pro-Russion rebels are now claiming that they have mistakenly shot down the MH17 .This is not an excuse and a case must be registered against the pro-Russion rebels and Russia for assisting them in International court of Justice.Because its the question of loss of 298 innocent lifes .If found guilty the culprits must be punished.

  • Kevin - 10 years ago

    The USA is to blame for the crash because we care what happened to that jet ? Really ?? We are a country that cares about the innocent and innocent children ! Unlike Russia that only cares about themselves . I can't believe Russians and their thinking and it makes me sick . Get out of Ukraine and go home nobody wants u there . The world is getting ready to show russia and that your thinking will not be tolerated . Get ready russia to be alone all by yourselves .......

  • Kevin tito - 10 years ago

    Really ? U are sticking up for Russia ? You guys are causing hell in Ukraine ! It is Ukraines country not Russias . Putin is to blame for all of this and should be charged with a war crime . If Russians don't like the way Ukraine is ran then go back home . It's that easy . I don't see where Putin get his thinking and thinking this is OK . Even if it was ukraine that shot the plane down which it clearly isn't . It would still be russias fault . Russia is the cause of this war and if they weren't there . U wouldn't see the hell that russia has put on Ukraine .Russia need to be punished to highest level . Russians open your eyes . Your beliefs are out of the norm and needs to be stopped !!!!

  • Srinivas - 10 years ago

    Does this has anything to do with BRICS formation almost mini IMF which can change the future course of Economic inequalities or is it the HIV research scientists (Joep Lange) or is it a warning to Russia from US threatening to play underdog. why would any militia shot down a passenger plane with out any demands and that too with ground to air strike missile technology at their disposal wont they be able to identify what type of plane is it. Questions apart Feeling sorry for the lost lifes. May their souls RIP

  • Czechoslovakia - 10 years ago

    Actually they want to hit Air India flight, which was 90 sec away, but by mistake hit Malaysian Air line.
    After Stalin, Only Putin can keep the legacy of brave Russians who defeated the Germans Nazi in world war 2. Now its US inn world war 3. India love you Russia...we will allocate extra 2% of our defense budget to buy expensive weapons, which we don't need, from you.

  • kiszombi - 10 years ago

    i cant believe that some here even mention the US as a suspect...
    clearly brainwashed against all american politics. but we all know that if the US gets involved, they are blamed. Also if they don't get involved, they get blamed. so make up your mind already!

  • Pat - 10 years ago

    Why will russia shoot Malaysian airline. They have nothing to gain from it. So now use logic and understand who must have done this

  • Dilip - 10 years ago

    Russia is playing an inhuman game. Putin plays nearly like a dictator.his international fall is imminent. Euro Zone and NATO, difficult for Russia to counter. Obama will have the last laugh.

  • Tango Bravo - 10 years ago

    @Tom: your comment is pure hogwash. The BUK missiles can reach altitudes of 25,000 meters. Why don't you do a bit of research before posting unsubstantiated facts?

    Initially, it was also reported that the rebels found the black boxes. When they realized that they might be held accountable, they no longer had the black boxes. They're now destroying any evidence they can that may link them to the downing of this aircraft.

    Want more proof? Look at the KAL Flight 700 in 1983. Russian fighter jet downed the aircraft. The plane and the black boxes ended up in the sea. The Russians scrambled to get to the black boxes before the US and the international community could reach the plane. Lo and behold, black boxes stolen! More Russian coverup. Need more?

  • cherry - 10 years ago

    What's the use of voting?? Al so called supreme countries might b knowing who did this !! Even anyone in the Malaysian government or the government itself might be knowing who did this!! We are been fooled !! When plane goes missing without any evidence of where it gone they simply closed the case saying its crashed into Indian ocean... Nobody questioned! one month the news went viral and then nodoy knows how it got suppressed!! Now a second incident happening the same way even we going to react and the same way government n media s going to handle this case!! We cannot do anything, because we are just common people who run to earn for food n family!!! No one is superior in gods creation even the activists , surely things will come out one day and you have to answer!! So , I conclude by saying , as a human being let's pray for the families of ppl who lost their life and calmly watch the change over!! [ IM ASHAMED THAT EVEN I CANT DO ANYTHING RATHER COMMENTING ON SUCH NEWS]

  • prem - 10 years ago

    I think USA is now over reacting in the matter of plane attack

  • tom - 10 years ago

    Ukraine do have BUK and they build BUK not just Russians,
    This is something politically well planned to destroy the fame of Russia.

    there is a rumour about pro-russian rebels braging .. that is fake. they are not stupid. Antonov-26 Cargo can not fly at that altitude of 10k meters. maximum is 7.5k meters, whoever commanding BUK will know it.

    I think the suspect is USA n West. USA is showing beyond care seems weird to me.
    Pro-Russians are framed.

  • Pradeep Pimple - 10 years ago

    Russia's reaction is as expected.There is no incidence in history that guilty has accepted his guilt. And you can't expect it now. Russia and China should beat in mind that in this era, it is a self damaging act to try to claim other country's land.Gone are those days.

  • Dave - 10 years ago

    Clearly the only people with the ability to build, supply and operate the missile launchers were the Russians. As Ramesh stated, the only one who can be responsible for this despicable act is Russia, and you don't provide that option.

  • Rku - 10 years ago

    this seems to be dirty american politics. The US wants to dominate this world. Russia is the only country who can challenge the US. their sanctions on russia doesn't seem to be effective. So they must have planned this well with Ukraine to undermine Russia and win world support. This missile must have been fired by Ukraine under the supervision of CIA.

  • vins - 10 years ago

    in the news it is being said that aids researchers were travelling and there were very close to finding a cure against aids. so probably they found a cure and its all a huge controversy and the plan was shot down cz the companies already making a medicines and providing expensive treatment for aids patients didnt want a cure as this would effect their buisness.. think about it.

  • jellybaby - 10 years ago

    When final evidence is revealed then throw the stones. I voted I do not know for that reason. Until I find out I do not judge. My heart goes out to those that have lost their lives and am sorry for that fact.

  • prithi - 10 years ago

    russian millitary based in east ukraine on the disguise of separatists is responsible for the tragedy.They had been blowing around 20 helicopters, transport planes and fighter jets in east ukraine.Finally , they did with malaysian plane thinking russian. now world must punish russia and putin .EU N US should crush rebels together with ukraine and then seal border so that no more russian terrorist repeat this crime

  • Mawusi - 10 years ago

    Ukrain has the same has the sane weapons in its arsenal.
    Just look observe the body language of the Ukrainean Prime
    minister on TV.And you still blame Putin,Oh No!Russia is not a factor
    in this tragedy.What is the genesis of this Ukrainean crises?Was not
    forceful removal from office of an elected president with the conivance
    of the EU and the Obama regime?
    Those who live in glass houses should not throw Stones.

  • mahadev b m - 10 years ago

    Apparently, it is a misadventure by pro-Russion rebels, with the assistance from Russia. Presumely, rebels mistook the plane as Ukraine's cargo or defence .

  • Prash - 10 years ago

    Imo it was America which used ukraine an militia to bomb tHiS plane containing AIDS researchers, numbering over a 100. ITS too much of a Coincidence to be missed. Plus the way Obama IS trying to blame it on Putin and Russian, ITS clear they are hiding something. America is the shittiest nation on the face of tHiS earth

  • Orthodox slavic cross - 10 years ago

    I agree with Obama

  • Obama_blakey - 10 years ago

    Why isnt USA an option ?

  • Spetnaz - 10 years ago

    You dont simple enter a warzone with a civilian airliner.

  • ishkey - 10 years ago

    I thing it was mis understanding with piolat and ground troops convarzation blackbox will. Clear all mistree of accidant.

  • reghu varma p.k. - 10 years ago

    From the available data it seems that Russia has to be held responsible.

  • Mannangatti Bali - 10 years ago

    I agree with Ramesh

  • Ramesh - 10 years ago

    Why isn't Russia one of the options?

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment