EPISODE BATTLE Part 3: Season two 1-13. Which is your Favorite?

59 Comments

  • Stillz - 10 years ago

    ....more.

  • Stillz - 10 years ago

    How the everloving fuck does MMDW rise even _slightly_ above "Secret of My Excess"? My appreciation for the fandom just died a little.

  • Quiet Desperation - 10 years ago

    All my love for Hearth's Warming Eve. Private Pansy, Chancellor Puddinghead, Princess Platinum and so on. DIRT!

  • DS - 10 years ago

    Luna Eclipsed is a seriously overrated episode. Pinkie was absolutely unbearable the whole time and the moral was essentially the same as Bridle Gossip's, when it could've been teaching Pinkie how not to be a horrible pony.

  • Zebugamer45 - 10 years ago

    @DannyKay4561 You know, I think a lot of people voted for Lunar eclipse juste because they liked it and not only because Luna ^^ And personnaly, friendship is witchcraft made me like it even more !! :p

  • Adie - 10 years ago

    Sisterhooves Social, it have more meaning to me. I've always felt crazy characters are pointless when it doesn't fit, it did for Pinkie Pie as she's already crazy (positivity just went negativity) but for Twilight is ruins her character and like this she's not the pony I love. Twilight is my favorite, but I'm probably the only Twilight fan who hates Lesson Zero. I loved Sisterhooves Sosial because the relationship improvement between Rarity and Sweetie Belle taught me to pay more attention and spend more time with MY little sister. That and how the role of Applejack was portrayed, certainly a pony who needs more love and went from third to second favorite the last two seasons. I love all the ponies though and all episodes too except Lesson Zero and Daring Don't.

  • Badly Drawn Turtle - 10 years ago

    I am disappointed at the showing of... pretty much every episode in the poll. I mean, come on, Lesson Zero and Luna Eclipsed have a combined 57% of the vote? Is this fandom really that single-minded that over one fourth of people went "Must vote for Luna" and another one fourth went "Must vote for crazy"?

    I chose baby Cakes, but that's irrelevant to my point. Show more independent thought, people!

  • Rockpath5 - 10 years ago

    Oh great Audunis, please bestow upon us your knowledge of which opinions are shit.

  • Audunis - 10 years ago

    Oh look, people are finally recognizing that the fandom has shit opinions

  • Where Is Your Celestia Now - 10 years ago

    There is no deserve, it's a personal preference poll. It's like freaking out if more people like red because blue is your favorite color.

  • pones - 10 years ago

    Luna is worst pony. :)

  • ShadowRose - 10 years ago

    *sigh*....Really? Luna Eclipsed is going to win? It was cute, but not nearly as cute as Sisterhooves Social. It was fun, but not as much as Sweet and Elite. Doesn't deserve to win.

  • Senior Stevensonville - 10 years ago

    I voted Lesson Zero. Not crazy about Twilight's crazy face, but it was still a very amusing episode which made the show less formulaic. Stressed out Twilight is the best Twilight!

    Luna Eclipsed is really charming, but I didn't vote for it because it suffers from a pretty big plot hole. In episode 1 season 1, no-one knew who Nightmare Moon was, yet in this episode, there's a holiday about her?

  • Rainbow Cash - 10 years ago

    Oh, it's just so much fun to read all those 'fuck you Lunafags!'-comments. Guys, you must realize one thing: Princess Luna is our beloved princess, that's why we would always vote for her rather than for the episode-shmapisode. LONG LIVE LUNA! YOUR FAITHFUL SUBJECTS LOVE YOU!

  • Skywrite - 10 years ago

    I'm gonna call it right now, "Luna Eclipse" will win because Luna.

  • Elise - 10 years ago

    Actually I love Return of Harmony, but only that. It's just that both parts are up and I love them equally, they're two-parters and should be counted as one episode.

  • Elise - 10 years ago

    Season 2 is the only season I actually despise. How am I going to vote on something I hate everything in?

  • DannyKay4561 - 10 years ago

    @Zebugamer45 yeah you're right the episode Lunar Eclipse is a pretty funny episode and I like it because of that.What I don't like,wait no,what I HATE about Lunar Eclipse or just Luna in general is the idiots that vote for her every single motherfucking time she's an option on a poll.The fandom needs more people like you and less people worshipping a cartoon character.I'm not even joking on the last part,I seen people say "HAIL LUNA".What a bunch of moronic assholes

  • LiboR - 10 years ago

    Seriously guys? I understand you like Luna. It's good character, but in 'Luna Eclipsed' she acted like a baby.
    She went to crowd and she thought, she was totally welcomed. She could expect she wasn't. Then she did almost everything to get to the point, she wanted be. This trying totally killed her character, because she's acting doesn't think and she's acting like a baby or maniac.
    That CANTERLOT ROYAL VOICE thing. You can't be serious about that. When someone's talking to crowd, he/she always has to be loud. I don't se reason to see something more... oh wait, I see. Luna.
    'The fun has been doubled'? This is: mathematically incorrect, because that spider-throwing thing she did first time, so she couldn't double it by first good throw.
    But of course, it's favourite character and in this situation you can always switch these proofs and say that this was totally normal. And when favourite character says some catchphrase (doesn't matter how nonsensible it is) it's always great catchphrase. :/

  • Zebugamer45 - 10 years ago

    @DannyKay4561 I personnaly voted for Lesson Zero, sinice it's one of my all time favorite episodes, but I hesitated with Lunar eclipsed, and not because there's Luna in it, I just loved it, it was very funny, and had lots of great moments! :D

  • Luna Is Life - 10 years ago

    Nothing can withstand Luna.

  • blazingwhirlwind - 10 years ago

    I liked Baby Cakes for the message it gave: Taking RESPONSIBILITY.

    I see a lot of people today who shirk any responsibility, usually blaming others for their mistakes and/or failures. When Twilight tells Pinkie that not everyone can handle the responsibility, she's right, but Pinkie becomes determined to show her and everyone else that there is more to her than just a Party Girl.

    Most of it comes from needing to grow up and accept those responsibilities that come with adulthood, though many never want to grow up and accept this. I was raised by my parents to accept this and accept that my mistakes and failures were my own. I made the choice to do what I did and I had to accept the consequences of those decisions. Just as Pinkie accepts that it's up to her if she succeeds or fails, because she begged the Cakes to let her do it. In the end she nearly fails, but her example of determination to succeed and possibly their feeling of responsibility for making things so difficult for Pinkie (remember what you all did to the substitute teacher) that they finally work with her and not against her. She's reluctant to babysit again, but with the kids saying her name in their sleep, it shows her that they respect her, and she is willing to do it again.

  • Bue - 10 years ago

    ....aaaaand it's a draw... And an exact one at that.

  • Blargh - 10 years ago

    Voted for Return of Harmony Part 2(why can't they merge both answers into one?).
    Discord's Epicness is no match for that overrated Luna.

  • tasty taylor - 10 years ago

    Please don't vote for an episode just because it has your favorite character starring it. *cough* *cough* LUNA

  • Rockpath5 - 10 years ago

    Looks like we are getting a statistical draw.

  • Dashie24 - 10 years ago

    I chose May the Best Pet Win, but I almost chose Mysterious Mare-Do-Well. Dashie is my favorite and I really enjoyed those episodes, and they're not as bad as people say they are. Remember, this poll is "What is your FAVORITE episode?" not "What is the best episode?" Favorite episode and best episode can mean 2 different things to most people. One person's "worst" or "bad" episode is another person's favorite episode, and vice versa. So, no one is "stupid" or "dumb" or "odd" for picking the "worst" or "bad" episode(s) as their favorite. It's all a matter of opinion, after all.

  • anon - 10 years ago

    @DannyKaye4561: You are absolutely 100% right.

  • DannyKay4561 - 10 years ago

    Oh and by the way.I don't hate all Luna fans.I just hate those idiots who do nothing but vote for Luna in every single motherfucking poll that has Luna as an option

  • DannyKay4561 - 10 years ago

    Once again anything that has Luna in it is voted the most.Seriously guys,this needs to stop.I really don't know why people like Luna so much I mean she doesn't get a lot of screentime,she's in the background most of the time and she doesn't even have a backstory! other than "I didn't got attention and I turned into NMM".You guys are like Pewdiepie fans and that's not a good thing because I'm starting to hate Luna right now and for all of you who are most likely to rage at this comment,then let me say this,open your fucking eyes! I'm just gonna say it because there's no turning back now.FUCK LUNA!

  • Timberrwolf - 10 years ago

    Family appreciation day is my favorite because It is the first episode my adopted family kind is featured.

  • Twylite-Sparkle - 10 years ago

    Looks like a close one between Lesson Zero & Luna Eclipsed...they are my favorites & it's hard to decide...I go with Lesson Zero because crazy Twilight & one of the first DVDs that I bought when they were packaged with the Brushies.

  • lordelliott - 10 years ago

    So many of these were SO good. I couldn't decide so I just voted Luna. :P

  • Orfearus - 10 years ago

    Man, I loved these episodes. Brings back old memories.

    @EQD, any chance that 2-part episodes could just be one option on the poll?

  • pon - 10 years ago

    Lesson Zero was the only episode where I even remotely enjoyed Twilight.

  • Anonymous - 10 years ago

    Lesson Zero and Baby Cakes are the best two of the lot. Baby Cakes should be much closer to the front, but I'm glad Lesson Zero is where it is.

  • Space Tissues - 10 years ago

    With the exception of Mysterious Mare Do Well, this is probably the strongest 13 episode block in the series. There are easily 7 of the best 15 episodes in this block alone.

  • TidestManager1 - 10 years ago

    Ah dang I hope the woona lovers come through on this one, Luna Eclipsed was an awesome episode and it's so close too (70 votes!)

  • E-K-9 - 10 years ago

    I loathe season 2 so I have no idea what to vote. I'll skip these poll.

  • What? - 10 years ago

    Lesson Zero? But that stunk, it was like a poor fanfiction...

  • Cosmic-Dash - 10 years ago

    I love it when Luna Fans vote for the Luna episode just because Luna is in it. Oh wait, no I don't! I'm not talking about all Luna Fans, but I feel like anything with Luna in it is voted more, just because she's in it. I feel like it needs to stop. She has almost no dialogue, and has barely any backstory other than 'I loved my sister but then I got mad because I got no attention. I tried to kill my sister and I got banished to a place for what I did.' It seems like we came up with so much fake backstory that we take it as true. Correct me if I'm wrong, but Luna never STATED that she felt lonely on the moon. Maybe there were space ponies or something that she talked to. 'Cause ya'know... magic! I'm not a Luna hater, I just think Luna Love is pretty ridiculous.

  • Anonymous - 10 years ago

    And one last thing: bronies FUCK you and FUCK your stupid goddess that isn't a goddess. I know the majority of you hate all the episodes after Return of Harmony because after that Lauren Faust didn't work anymore on the show. You're nothing but a bunch of idiots.

  • Anonymous - 10 years ago

    Do you really have to be so annoying in every poll? We get it you hate Twilight so shut up.

  • Litigious - 10 years ago

    For me, Lesson Zero, Luna Eclipsed, and Sweet and Elite were all equally good. I chose Lesson Zero, because Sweet seems to have no chance at winning, and I am not a Luna fanatic, I just liked her in Luna Eclipsed. I'm amazed at the comments hating Lesson Zero, because crazy twilight is what I loved. When she stopped being as crazy and more serious starting with Too Many Pinkie Pies, I lost interest.

  • Hat - 10 years ago

    O, most wonderful of nights!
    (Voted Secret of my Excess)

  • Ringcaat - 10 years ago

    Lesson Zero was a grating episode and it's baffling to me that so many people enjoyed seeing Twilight's character getting smashed to bits. The Return of Harmony part 1, Luna Eclipsed and Hearth's Warming Eve are all top tier episodes, the show at its best, so there's no reason for Lesson Zero to win. Except maybe Smarty Pants. But he's not enough!

  • silvadel - 10 years ago

    This is the first one that is going to be close. Still wondering about the people who think Mare Do Well is the best episode -- I didn't think it was a BAD episode like most people seem to but best is a stretch and a half a stretch. I voted Lesson Zero... This was the real birth of Trollestia with the ticking of the sun.

  • M7ASPilot - 10 years ago

    So many of my favorites are on this list. So hard to choose. >_

  • Kicks_McGee - 10 years ago

    Sisterhooves Social is the correct answer. But of course it doesn't stand a chance against OMG Lesson Zero and Luna. *sigh* So... I'll just vote for Mysterious Mare Do-Well. :]

  • Mojo - 10 years ago

    Hmm how is Best Pet Win doing so well, beside the song which is one of the best muscial sequences in the show that was a pretty average episode, certainly not as good as Sweet and Elite or Secret of My Excess.

  • Rush2201 - 10 years ago

    I'm honestly surprised Mare Do Well isn't dead last. People dislike Granny Smith that much?

  • Rockpath5 - 10 years ago

    Twilight has made the official comics worse too actually...

    Most of my top Season 2 episodes were in the second half, but I do like Hearth's Warming Eve. I just wish the Heart Carol were a longer song.

  • Smiles - 10 years ago

    Sisterhooves Social and Secret of My Excess. :)

  • Rockpath5 - 10 years ago

    I knew Lesson Zero and Luna Eclipsed would be at the top...
    Luna Eclipsed is okay, but I loathe Lesson Zero. It took a character I liked, and turned her into an obnoxious character that I can't stand. Since Lesson Zero, Twilight has made every episode she has been in worse by her mere presence.

  • chaucer345 - 10 years ago

    But... But... There are too many good ones here! Lesson Zero and Luna Eclipsed deserve the top spot, but Granny Smith and the type of pony everypony should know and gneeee!

  • Wertcvsts - 10 years ago

    Luna ep was freken Awesome

  • Grokenstein - 10 years ago

    Bottom of the poll be damned, I voted "Family Appreciation Day" without hesitation. It's an average episode right up to the point Granny Smith begins her sepia-toned flashback, and then it very quietly sneaks up and becomes epic.

  • ShadowRose - 10 years ago

    Really? Luna Eclipsed is near the top? Why? Because Luna. Why no love for Sweet and Elite or Sisterhooves Social? I must support Lesson Zero, all the way! ^.^

  • don - 10 years ago

    Zero for Twilights visit to the funny farm side of Ponyville GO SMARTY PANTS GO !.
    Excess for the Sparity.......Go! Go! Spikezilla!
    & Luna eclipsed for Luna and her ROYAL CANTERLOT VOICE !

    Sweet & Elite for SunButt getting her hoofs kissed

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment