I really didn't like Erin's collection. It just seemed the same look with a different pattern with 1 or 2 different looks. If her designs are the future of fashion I am very worried about it. Personally, I preferred Roberi's look as it was well thought out, went together and I could actually see it looking good in the streets or in a magazine. Plus, it did help that it didn't look like foam
Shelley - 7 years ago
Too many of Erin's designs looked the same, with just different materials. Lucky for her she wasn't rated based on her character.
Donna - 7 years ago
I think Robert had the most fashion forward and sophisticated collection. Was shocked Erin won. Her clothes reminded me of character one would expect on Tellitubbies
Edna Geddes - 7 years ago
What a disappointing choice...Erin...really? Bananas and arts crafts beat out true designers!? Disgusting how the judges folded. Laurance is amazing... Ric had his moments...my favorite was Roberri. He was ripped off in a big way. He was the winner. I feel Erin will fall flat on her face. She's not a nice person and fails as a designer for human women. She should make clothes for Barbie dolls or teddy bears. I'll be honest, I don't think I'll tune in next season. I don't have any respect for those judges any longer. They are sell outs. I'm done...I'm too pissed off to continue.
Adele - 7 years ago
Worst winner ever. Not trying to hate on anyone but last time I checked it was a design challenge and not arts and crafts challenge. If this the way things are going I have to agree with the other intelligent comments about Erin should not have won. This makes me think things are rigged as well. Robert or Laurence should have won by a landslide. Both showed amazingly designed and tailored collections. Unlike the value village, arts and crafts pieces generated by Erin. Watch out world we are going to have a bunch more budding so called designers... They will be from Cub scouts, or perhaps girl guides, because that is what these so called expert judges deem a designer.... Arts and crafts time. Also, she was a terrible person to Cornelius, it felt like highschool. She was part of the pretty club and was just mean to him along with Dexter. I too got to a point where I wish she would stop talking as I don't think she could "like", "ummmm" you know "like" make a full sentence without "like" using the word "ummm" "like". Way to sound like an air head and make those ex Mormons proud. Overall just very disappoint on this season, I think I only feel asleep for 5 of the episodes.
Quinn - 7 years ago
Y'all are so salty. Erin was great and her collection was great too. It was unique and creative and none of you would know high fashion if it slapped you in the face. Look at Gucci look at D&G. They do crazy stuff like that all the time and you with your closet full of aritzia and banana republic think you can tell Zac Posen that "you know best about fashion".
Mame - 7 years ago
OOPs typo...... Meant Project Runway was ONE of my favorite shows............
Mame - 7 years ago
The Show was fixed. The judges clearly favored Roberi. He was their choice. Then suddenly at the end, they were encouraged (forced) to choose someone else. How honorable was that? What was the reason? I don't understand.
The good thing is I will have so much more free time. Project Runway was won of my favorite shows. I will no longer watch it.
I wonder what the sponsors think about the fix???
Cindy - 7 years ago
I used to love project runway. Not so anymore. I am done. Michael Kors needs to come back. Zach Posen picks his winner from day one as it appears Heidi does too. My 8 year old granddaughter said Erin's clothes were stupid. Think I am done watching the show. Too much game playing and favoritism on the part of the judges. Heidi u r not a teenager and siding with so called designers who act that way will not make u going again. Tim Gunn take control of the show
Christine - 7 years ago
Clearly the judges are so terrified of being seen as old and washed up that they chose the most juvenile "just out of school" contestant to somehow signal that they are cutting edge cool. Erin's designs were laughable all season long in their lack of a true silhouette despite her artistic embellishments. Like lipstick on a pig, her baubles did not make her clothes fashion forward. I enjoy seeing provocative fashion in magazines that stretch my imagination but Erin's clothes merely annoy. I turned off the tv in disgust when she was announced the winner. Now I do think the judges are losing their edge.
Shelley Williams - 7 years ago
That was the worst finale I've ever watched I cannot believe Erin won her clothes are horrible. I believeLaurance should have won. Her clothes turned out to be amazing. Erin's clothes have no shape to them
connie - 7 years ago
As the season progressed, I found myself hitting mute every time Erin spoke because she "like" couldn't "like" complete a sentence "like" without a dozen "likes." That and the childish giggling were really annoying. Also, the snarky comments after she won don't speak well of her character. Roberi had the best collection in my opinion.
ria - 7 years ago
Really sad how project runway has turned out to be superficial. gone are the days where designers such mondo were rewarded for their thinking. people like laurence, roberi and rik showed much more design thinking, and execution, talent but sadly the judges go by face value. Erin was their baby doll whom they finally handed the prize unfortunately. it is only a matter of time that project runway is NOT going to be watched for true design, for future of fashion. over the past few seasons, its seems like through the season the judges at most give honest and fashion forward criticism to the designers. but ultimately in the end, it becomes a show that is either trying to play political games by applauding floral head gears tank tops & flowing skirts in the name of fashion, or 'embellishments' akka 'decorations' (in nina garcia's own words) as what is now in fashion. needless to say, if people of their stature and experience think this is fashion and choose to lead it this way, there is very less hope for design and for fashion.
Kate - 7 years ago
Erin is nothing but a childish no talent mean girl. Roberi should have won
Allison - 7 years ago
I really can't believe the judges chose Erin. Her fashions look like over sized doll clothes from a comic strip. I chose Roberi because he rose to the occasion and really put on an awesome show. My first choice would have been Laurence who has impeccable style and tailoring but unfortunately no wow factor in finale.
Susan - 7 years ago
Roberi and Laurence were the best top fashion designers this season. Totally disagree with judges choice of Erin. Plastic baubles are a "unique sensibility"? That the judges didn't see the banana jacket as racist and would not be worn by any person of color, means they are not paying attention. They should apologize to viewers and to the other contestants.
Half the show was a promo for the upcoming kid show. Totally insulting to break up a finale everyone is anxious for. Heidi is all about the money. Many finales have disappointed me. Mondo is very quiet because of his ties. A lot of silence. Erin's intro to her collection was shocking, where'd the valley girl intimations come from? And her reactions were silly and immature. Like her fashions. Laurence and Roberi should have been top two. Show is losing its edge and viewership.
Kenny g - 7 years ago
Project runway has now deteriorated into a ridiculous show. I'm done with it after watching for many seasons. Tim is the only saving grace. Enough of the weirdos, gay drama, black enabling and tackiness. Posen has ruined the show. A crazy weirdo like Erin right out of school with her glue gun nonsense and her sick "friendships" with the blacks is disgusting. She is not anywhere near designer material and should have been eliminated weeks ago. The show has run its course.
Fran - 7 years ago
I do not agree with the judges that Erin should win. I do not think her creations are fashion forward. She's creative, but so are five year olds. I think her final collection lacked cohesion and pizzazz. It was filled with ill-fitting garments with her typical embellishments plastered on them. I think Zac Posen was enamored with her from episode 1 and never took off his rose colored glasses. If he and the other judges would have, they would have seen that Roberi's final collection was far superior to Erin's. I will not be watching this show again because I've lost faith in the taste level of the judges.
Frooz - 7 years ago
Erin is Gretchen #2. Wrong choice of winner!! Very disappointed at the judges.
Dony - 7 years ago
It reminded me of the Mondo Gretchen debacle.
FisA - 7 years ago
Thank goodness the judges have swung their pendulum back to the "fashion is art" side of the spectrum by picking Erin to win. We've been stuck too long in the boring world of "fashion is commercial clothes" ready to sell at your local strip mall. We need inspiration, not marketability in our broader conversation about fashion and PR finally gave it to us!
I enjoyed and respected the runway shows from all of the designers, and would have been happy to see Roberi win as well, but I am impressed that the judges finally have gone with the designer that pushed the boundaries of what's possible in the design of clothing the furthest. Would I buy most of Erin's work? No way. But do I see a designer with a forward thinking vision? Hell yes. I feel we finally have payback for the injustice done to Mondo in season 8.
Cheatah - 7 years ago
I feel like I wasted my time watching this show. I kind of knew they would pick Erin because they seemed so in awe with her ugly splotches of crap pasted on her clothes. She should have left when she made those homeless shorts with throw up sewed on them. They wanted so much for Laurence to change her clothes so they could have a reason to not pick her because everything she made looked awesome except when she tried to please the judges. The show is set up to be a "surprise", "look who we picked" moment but they should probably stick with someone who actually makes clothes, not costumes. Look at Heidi in those silver boots and dress, just no taste. She shouldn't be picking the winner of fashion anything! And the others are there to tag along. It's become the next American idol!
Terry - 7 years ago
Time, not the judges, will prove who the real winner is. With Roberi's expected success in fashion for years to come, we will most likely all ask 'Erin who?'
Eva Cabato - 7 years ago
I was disappointed that the judges chose Erin to win this season's PR. She was not consistent with her work, there were ups & downs. Either of the 3, Roberi- Laurence or Rik should've won. I am not a fashion critic. All of their work seemed so professionally done, except Erin's.
Belilli - 7 years ago
Either the second or third year in a row that the wrong person was chosen.
No would in their right mind would wear last years (larger sized) fashions. That goes for this year as well. Who wants to wear a neoprene tent with all those stupid crafty add-ons.
What are the judges thining?
Lucky if I watch Runway again.
dms - 7 years ago
The majority of the earlier comments reflect my opinion of the results on PR. My personal favorite all season was Laurence. Her designs were stunning. I feel if she had not chosen to make her collection reflective of her life experience, her showing would have blown the rest out of the water. Rob then Rik followed her looks in design innovation and quality. I cannot imagine anyone intentionally wearing Erin's "designs" on any runway unless they were competing for Fashion Police's "misses." Erin's personality and products were of a piece--atrocious and childish. PR judges, were you serious or just self-absorbed like Erin.
Elle - 7 years ago
The banana has been done... Bay Garnet and Chloe made it high fashion years ago. Roberi's collection was fun and unexpected in a wearable, intelligent and beautiful way. I'm disappointed with their choice but to each their own. I hope Roberi and Laurence (both were my season favorites) continue to design and find success. They are true talents with humility and grace.
Elizabeth - 7 years ago
So glad to see so many others feel the way I do! Here I was starting to worry I'd lost it. The other designers were so mature which made her look even more ridiculous. They're trying so hard to praise the unusual they handed the win to someone who didn't deserve it in the least. I'm sick of the idea that only the bizarre qualifies as fashion. Smh. Oh, and I've always hated yellow and now I think I despise it. Bananas have been ruined forever.
Kim - 7 years ago
Erin is kooky and quirky, but that doesn't make for a winning designer. Sadly, her best creations were always the same wide silhouette., and that is what most stumped me about the judges' decision. Her other pieces were always throwaway designs: the chiffon top, oversize pants, whatever. She is a one-trick pony and wull need to grow a lot more to be successful. RoberI should have been the winner, although I was rooting for Laurence all season.
Gael - 7 years ago
Erin's clothing is, for the most part, childish. It always seems as if she is trying so hard to be different that she loses all sense of style, sophistication, and class. Very disappointed in the judges and how they pandered to her sophomoric attitude and arts & craftsy clothing. As much as I've loved Laurence's work during the season, her runway show lacked the unique qualities her other designs had in abundance. Roberi's work exuded his innovation, love and passion, but a lot of the fabrics didn't read well for me. Rik's work was, in my estimation, the most wearble, while still being fashion forward. Rik or Roberi would have been much more suitable to wear the mantle of a Project Runway winner. Sorry, judges, but you chose pretentious clown suits instead of fashion.
Maddie - 7 years ago
ROBERI. his collection was so beautiful and innovative, and the judges didn't have a single negative thing to say about it! Although I WAS confused when the judges said that he'd be "making beautiful dresses with an edge" for his entire future. What?! I don't even understand what that means, especially when the pants he made were cool AF. And you know what? I liked the sneakers. He can do no wrong in my mind, but I would have liked to see them with the rest of the collection. I had a major problem with Erin's separates-- pants especially, and it seemed like the judges did too. WTH?!?? Did Erin's parents bribe the shows producers or something?
Char - 7 years ago
Laurence is hands down an amazing designer and Roberi's final runway show was awesome! Rik did great too. There was a great mix of jeans and leather. BUT Erin should not have won. The quirky and weird mixes did not work with some of her pieces. She's an inconsistent designer. I'm officially done watching the show.
Blaise - 7 years ago
Poor Roberi, his collection was everything he wanted understated, elegant, yet extremely striking and forward thinking. Just beautiful. Yet he lost to that bizarre, hideous, DelPozo mockery. Erin's clothes churned my stomach,
and truly there was nothing of innovation or interest in them. To be truly elegant one must consider less is more.
LRS - 7 years ago
I was such a Laurence fan that I knew I'd be sad if she lost. But I also appreciated the style and spirit of the other designers...except the one who won. I said if Erin wins, this would be my last season watching. As a 15-season fan, I will truly miss the show. Tim, Heidi, Nina...and Swatch! But I can't resolve how the judges selected Erin who did not exude the same depth, style and soul that the others did. And why did no one find the brown human hands holding the bananas to be a bit racially insensitive. I was appalled by that look and totally turned off by her "trying-too-hard-to-be-quirky" aesthetic. No one wants to wear that stuff. I would want to buy Rik or Laurence ASAP. And Roberi totally earned my respect. Erin...bratty...selfish...self indulgent. And possibly racist.
Gloria - 7 years ago
Roberi is the winner, not Erin! I won't watch again either!
Gi - 7 years ago
Erin is NOT the best designer. Roberi is!! I would never buy her design, which is too childish (and the judges agree) and not easy to clean. She should've been a contestant on PR Junior, if at all.
Rebecca Cervantes - 7 years ago
I've clearly been watching Project Runway too long. This season was too much of a disconnect for me. Roberi was clearly the only true designer among the finalists. I'm beginning to think the problem lies with the judges. Rude girl, Erin should have been eliminated early on and Laurence was never able to live up to her own assessment of her talent. I predict Roberi will have a great future as a designer.
Ali - 7 years ago
Roberi got robbed. I don't know if I'll watch next season. Boo.
Jane - 7 years ago
I thought Roberi's was the winning collection, creative and exquisitely beautiful. I appreciate Erin's creativity but find it a bit derivative ( Betsey Johnson without the carttwheel!).
Museera - 7 years ago
I honestly hated Erin ever since the challenge where they got Cornelius eliminated. I have also hated her aesthetic. The keep handing and handing her wins. Also, the judges get mad at the other designers for having the same shoulders or pants twice, when Erin made the same exact coat like every other challenge, and they didn't say anything about it. I feel like she got special treatment that she didn't work for it deservem
Alison - 7 years ago
I'm also tired of the judges handing a win to anyone who does something that's never been done before. Some things haven't been done because they shouldn't be done at all. I bet you have never tried eating fecal matter drenched in cheese and sprinkles while riding a roller coaster ... because no one in their right mind would. It's that simple.
Alison - 7 years ago
I'm completely disgusted that Erin won. I hated her personality and designs all season long so I should have known she would walk away on top. I'm tired of people being weird just to be weird. It's actually the opposite of creative; it's just saying "look at me! Look how different I am!" without actually earning the attention. But to be honest, I didn't like any of the collections the finalists put out. Maybe a couple looks, but I didn't think any of them deserved the win with what they showed. I don't think I'm going to watch another season. My mom said last night "if that's fashion, count me out" and sadly I couldn't agree more.
Diane - 7 years ago
Erin was the most unprofessional designer. Who could stand to be in a meeting with her when every other word out of her mouth was "like". Last night's finale was horrible, between the PRJr clips, another relentless use of the word "like", and her ugly non wearable clothes, I couldn't wait for it to be over. The judges dropped the ball, but I knew they would pick her. What were they thinking? What woman would want to wear an oversized neoprene, baby pink sack with giant sprinkles on it. I guess they are looking for something the general public wouldn't spend their hard earned money on. Very disappointed. Roberi, Ric or Laurence would have been a better choice. They were all great.
Stephanie - 7 years ago
Erin should not have won. Her designs looked cheap and ugly. Even if i was 12 again, i would not be caught dead wearing that. It's not a craft show, its a Project Runway. It's trending now but I doubt anyone will be wearing it next year. This is the second year PR has disappointed me. The other 3 got robbed.
Dee - 7 years ago
ERIN?!? Yuck! She is creative but unbelievably annoying. I hate "up-speak" which turns every statement into a question(?). She's lazy and her greatest accomplishment is getting in the car with her parents when they decided to leave Utah. Who cares! The clothes are slutty versions of toddler clothes. Based on personality alone, before a single item was made I knew the judges would pick her as winner. Roberi and Laurence are passionate dedicated professionals both of whom will be wildly successful and not just the flashy bit of sparkle covered neoprene, splash of yellow and pasty flesh that is ERIN the ex-Mormon's only trick in her bag.
Mary - 7 years ago
I echo the disappointment on the judges awarding Erin the win. She should NOT have won! I turned the TV off as soon as her name was announced.
What in the world were the judges and Hedi thinking???
Roberti or Laurence should have won. Class designers with taste not in their mouth. I doubt if I will watch another season of the show.
JGJ - 7 years ago
When Erin was announced the winner I turned off my TV and left the room. Wrong choice. Her clothes were "clever" but nothing a grown-up would ever wear. Most had no shape and many looked alike, except for the ornamentation. The show isn't called "Project Arts & Crafts", so why would they reward her?! Over the years contestants have been warned not to design costume-y clothing, yet throughout the season Erin's were costume-y. Roberi's collection was extremely creative and made with so much heart. Laurence and Rik's were also interesting and they are both very talented. Although Erin has a point of view, her crafty, glue gun focus should have disqualified her early on. I may not watch another season after this disappointing result.
J'12 - 7 years ago
So...a collection of NEOPRENE won? What a shortcut way to make clothes...no need to sew hems or structure, etc. Was there even any sewing at all in that collection? Ugh.
Laurence was my pick from the start. If she had stuck to her aesthetic - or even sent her own dope wardrobe down the runway! - she could've taken it all. I'm a lIl' sad. I looked at her website and LOVE her stuff.
patti - 7 years ago
i loved laurance and roberi, for me it was batween those two. rick did a great job, but i am very disappointed with erins win. i know this isnt about marketable clothes but erins line was all over the place, they wanted cohesion but voted for her?
i will still watch but am also tired of the unconventional challenges
naomi landau - 7 years ago
absolutely rubbish decision. would rather be boiled in oil than wear Erin's clothes. what were they thinking??
Kerry - 7 years ago
Worse decision ever made on project runway. Erin's collection was childish and silly. My 7 year old granddaughter can paste glitter and pasties on felt but I wouldn't call her a fashion designer. I am so disappointed in the judges decision. I'm glad this season is over. I just hope they do better on the next one.
Iris - 7 years ago
I think every year the judges pick a contestant and stick with them throughout the whole show. Believe me they have chosen some hideous designers. What heidi wants heidi gets. And the others go along with her. Erin was the worst designer on the show who should have gone home a long time ago. The neoprene dress was nothing new, kerry washington wore the same style dress , about four years ago, except it was in a much better fabric. And some of her styles were patterned after others. No i did not like her smug attitude either. Get better judges who judge for the style , not for popularity . This show SUCKS!!! I wished either one of the others won. That they are true designers. ERIN IS A JOKE.
Armando - 7 years ago
I love Erin since challenge one. I enjoyed her collection. But I really think Rob should won.
AB - 7 years ago
What I don't like about Erin is that her designs don't feel thought out. I get the impression she has a moment of inspiration and then must create that thing. There is not moment where she edits or changes. There is a lack of creativity in that she does not adapt from her original conception to create something interesting. There is a level of arrogance that says "why should I change anything? I'm amazing." This was clear in many of her consultations with Tim where she seemed to feel above his advice. She did not grow throughout the season. She was given permission to be weird, went with that, but never grew to make the weird something more than a childish idea. I'm disappointed because I felt like she was on stage with intelligent artists who were thoughtful and experimental and who really did adapt and grow, but she won because she just did whatever she felt like with little cohesion or thought. I think Erin has tremendous potential, but should not have won and was done a disservice by the judges by not being guided in a way that could have helped her become something that really did deserve to win.
Judy Cox - 7 years ago
The judges are so bias! It seems to be fixed for whatever reasons! I never would have thought Erin would have won! Laurence and the other guys were
much better! Maybe if they were blond and blue eyed, they would have had a chance! Especially when you look at the track record of the same old judges! I have watched this show from its beginning trying to give them the benefit of doubt but wow, the proof is in the pudding!
tj - 7 years ago
Can any of you write a complete and accurate sentence? Your comments are childish and immature! You sound like a bunch of whining babies! Omg...I'm not gonna watch the show EVER AGAIN! Boo hoo, this commentary is pathetic and juvenile! Get a grip you amateurs and learn how to write before you criticise anyone about whether they're talented or not! Most of you don't even know the correct names of the contestants you were cheering for this season! You should be embarrassed to put out comments that are so ridiculously childish! Grow up. If you had ever watched this show you would know it's not about selling clothes to some lower class geek's like you but to magazines,etc. Seriously, one of you actually compared herself to the Kardashian clan! Get a grip children!
Hcs - 7 years ago
Ummmm. Reading these comments it's clear you all have summed up how bizare this mess is. I mean it's clear this collection was a stunt. A stunt for toddlers tuning in. Big chubby cute rich toddlers with the guts to throw these huge garments on and leave the house. No god. All those interruptions of project runway juniors. They trying to motivate young viewers with queen green junior Erin snatching the crown while serving when preteen meets pregnant. No god. Roberi got played. Or even the other guy cause while chocolate was my favorite that collection was a snooze. But Erin. And those color castrophe combinations. Lol. Hilarious. I know Zac and Nina probably left and start talking mess about the advertisers as soon as they left the stage. This has to be for the young audience. All of the contestants were nice people but roberi gave you different and right. Not just different. Wow. Get these ratings project runway.
Susan O'Neil - 7 years ago
Laurence by all means then Roberi 2nd, Rik 3rd and Erin last. I don't understand why someone who puts out over-fluffy, unwearable, (most), costumes. There were a few good pieces. But come on, her work was like a Disney Cartoon.
Titi - 7 years ago
I was team Erin the whole season. She had some misses during the season, but overall I loved her vision. Her designs are fun and whimsical. I was excited she won! Laurence was also a favorite of mine, and her designs were very wearable, but it did feel like it's stuff that's already in stores. I think they all did a great job and for the first time, i would've been happy no matter who won, even tho I was rooting for Erin.
Susan O'Neil - 7 years ago
Laurence by all means then Roberi 2nd, Rik 3rd and Erin last. I don't understand why someone who puts out over-fluffy, unwearable, (most), costumes. There were a few good pieces. But come on, her work was like a Disney Cartoon.
Jerome - 7 years ago
May never watch again.... Arts and crats wins. What a joke
Peat - 7 years ago
What's wrong with the judges did we just get punked!!! How could those ugly pieces win or be worn ! Horrible tacky toddler creations I'm very disappointed and not watching anymore along with others # GLUEGUNQWEEN # Halloween costumes rejects
Jacquelyn - 7 years ago
I don't understand the judges decision! Neoprene and craft. The one designer I wanted to see more of was Laurance. The other two were great but not sophisticated and very close to Teen Magazine.
Jacquelyn - 7 years ago
I don't understand the judges decision! Neoprene and craft. The one designer I wanted to see more of was Laurance. The other two were great but not sophisticated and very close to Teen Magazine.
Nicole - 7 years ago
I would have been happy if anyone but Erin would have won this season. I'm so disappointed on the judges decision. Smh
Teresa Fronek - 7 years ago
Look; anyone who has watched Project Runway over the years should know that the judges aren't looking for someone whose designs are "sellable" but new and innovative, inspirational and avant garde! Erin's collection may not meet everyone's taste for wearable clothing but she pushed the boundaries for individuality and uniqueness, which is what the whole idea of Project Runway has ALWAYS focused on throughout the years! There is probably not one thing in ANY of the collections I would just love to run out and buy but I would definitely rather be inspired by something"new" and "unique" than the same ol', same ol' I've seen on the runway before! For that reason I believe the judges made the right decision!
All of those designers are going on to make clothing that will be marketable and will probably find fame and fortune. Nick Vieros,who was featured on the show this season didn't win but he's gone on to make clothing and money and is one of the best designers from past seasons! You need to quit whining and remember what Project Runway is all about! I definitely wouldn't buy the big flowers in my hair from last season either but she stood out and was an individual. THAT is what they look for in a winner so Brava to Erin Robertson for her victory and cheers to all the finalists for a job well done this season!
Dianne Penn - 7 years ago
Neoprene overload. Avoid open flames. Judges showed their Erin favoritism early, she was never told to avoid overuse of neoprene as laurent was told to expand herself. Hobby lobby crafts is not fashon
Mary Jane - 7 years ago
Worst choice ever. Who would wear the crap she put out there. Roberti's collection was 100 times better then those Halloween costumes Erin made all season. I won't waste my time watching this show again.
Deb - 7 years ago
Erin was the judges FAV from day one...even when she was on the bottom. It was obvious that she would win all along. Too bad for the other 3, who didnt have a chance to beat the "kindergarten art project" clothes :-(
gigi - 7 years ago
Poor Roberi was robbed today, how sad!! I can not believe the judges decision. They definitely favored her. This is my last season watching project runway after this fraud. Cant believe i waisted my time watching this for some arts and crafts designer to win over true designers. Had anyother one i would be okay, but her with that collection, please!!!!
gigi - 7 years ago
Poor Roberi was robbed today, how sad!! I can not believe the judges decision. They definitely favored her. This is my last season watching project runway after this fraud. Cant believe i waisted my time watching this for some arts and crafts designer to win over true designers. Had anyother one i would be okay, but her with that collection, please!!!!
Deb - 7 years ago
Erin's designs are not flattering! No woman would be caught in public in that crap. Childish designs, toddler girl colors, cheap looking sequins. I am flabbergasted that she won. The dress that Erin had on was okay, far better than anything that her models had on. Any of the other designers would have been deserving, but not Erin. No way.
Penny - 7 years ago
So disappointed...Erin's collection was childish and unflattering. Arts and crafts but no inspirational designs. No adult would want to be seen in her clothes.
Melissa - 7 years ago
I completely agree. Erin's collection was the worst. I don't know what the judges were thinking. Her clothes won't sell. I loved Laurance all season and thought she should have won.
Patsy - 7 years ago
Erin's designs are childish & immature. Laurence should have won as she makes beautiful clothes which were consistent over the course of the competition. I would have been happy with anyone though, just NOT Erin!!! Yuck! Hated her attitude also. Totally wrong.
Lita - 7 years ago
Where would you sell that crap and who would waste their money buying Erin's designs, they were awful, so disappointed in the judge's choice, she was clearly the poorest designer of all the Finalist. Very Very angry with Project Runway Final Show
diane - 7 years ago
Unbelievable. So wrong. Erin is clever and creative but come on...the winner? The judges said it as much themselves - Roberi's show was outstanding. Then they pick Erin? Makes me not want to watch anymore.
Shawna Norman - 7 years ago
I think Roberi or Rik should of won. Both of their clothes were done nicely. I totally disagree with judges decision.
Janet - 7 years ago
Worst decision possible by the judges. Erin's arts and crafts designs are best suited for a three ring circus. Any if the other three designers would have been a better choice. The chances of me tuming in to watch another season of Project Runway ate slim. Very disappointing outcome. Laughable really.
Shawn - 7 years ago
I loved laurence. She stepped out of her comfort zone. She was true to her theme. I would take the white dress over anything that Erin created. It was sophisticated and told a story. Her tailoring for a woman's body impeccable.
Lorna - 7 years ago
Bad, bad, bad....ridiculous. No one but a twelve year old or a degenerate 30 plus would look twice at E's quirky "designs"...I hate baby pink.....bleck! Robert should have won (love Laurence).
Barb - 7 years ago
Yes I didn't like Erin's designs at all. Crafty & so much puffy flair, who can wear that. I actually liked both Roberi or Rik. Something that I would buy.
Rhonda - 7 years ago
First time in 15 years I immediately turned off the channel in disgust. Erin's design were just gimmicks. Cratfy and creative yes. Odd and different for sure. Talented visionary, gifted designer, not on your life. Terrible choice. What a sham. Different and unique doesn't always mean good. I don't know anyone who would wear her clothing in public, unless they just want to attract attention, like wearing a clown or Big Foot ccostume.
Sarah - 7 years ago
Roberi. His collection is rich and dreamy. Sophisticated yet down to earth, conceptual yet relatable. He understands the female psyche.
Teresa - 7 years ago
Terrible choice! I sat thru all those weeks for this?? Banana couture? ?? Pitiful!!
Trish - 7 years ago
Roberi should have won! I almost cried for him.
Cess - 7 years ago
I think the judges instead of looking for good design are looking for gimmicks such as Erin's. the worst choice of all the seasons. The show should look for new judges.
Anne - 7 years ago
Tim Gunn got it right--Erin is a "Mean Girl". Although, not Mormon or from Utah, could she be any more condescending? Her clothes are childish as is her spirit. Fun is not kooky. Disappointed that she and her silly work won.
carole - 7 years ago
How disappointing was that. Erin should not have won. She was the worst designer. Some of the designs were so childish, over crafty and big (on size fits all). I would NOT wear her clothes. Maybe if I was 12 years old... It is not fair for the other designers who worked so hard all season and presented beautiful collections. During this season, it was so noticeable that Erin was the favorite one. She presented awful designs and yet the judges kept her in the competition. Maybe you should change judges. I do NOT know if I will watch Project Runway again. This is the second year in a row that I am so disappointed. I love your show but it is so frustrating to see, as a viewer, how unfair it is for the others.
Yazmin - 7 years ago
Erin winning this season hurts the credibility of the judges or kardashians or me would wear her designs..plain and simple! Let's hope the ratings of the show don't go down. You guys totally waiste your money with Erin...worst finale ever!
Christy - 7 years ago
Agree with everyone here!! Who wants to wear clothes that look like a 10 yr should be wearing them. These judges honestly want us to know the next best trend and this is not it!!! Not sure if I'll be watching next season. Also, how many times has Heidi been on the worst dressed list??!!loved Laurence and Roberi!! Great futures ahead!!
Lily - 7 years ago
I am so disappointed in this show. Erin should not have won. This is a fashion show, not arts and crafts for children.
Steve - 7 years ago
No, I thought Erin did a great job. I would have been happy with Rik winning, Laurence could have won, but she but put on a blah show. I used to get upset with the judges but honestly they are the on the leading edge of fashion.. and they know what looks good. That doesn't mean they pick the prettiest designs.
kitty - 7 years ago
What a dumb decision.
They should change the name of their show to Project Runway Circus. wdf!
kitty - 7 years ago
Pack of shitttttt.. Erins clothes is for the amateur circus. i loved Roberi's fashion, was hoping he would've won from day one. Heidi n them other judges don't know whats in from whats out. All Erin did in the entire runway was glue gun and blend a lot of bright colors n they didn't even match. Need some new judges it there's a next season!!!!!
MIMI - 7 years ago
Erin's was the most tackiest, incohesive collection out of all the designers. Roberi had the most interesting, well put together collection. I could actually see myself wearing some of the pieces at the same time still keeping that runway effect. Roberi had way more WOW pieces that really caught your eye in a postive way while Erin's collection really just left a bad costumey taste in my mouth. I was not impressed by her collection at all. #teamroberi
Pam - 7 years ago
She shouldn't have won. She had an attitude throughout the show. Very disappointed. I would never wear any of her clothes.
ANITA - 7 years ago
erin the glue gun queen so disappointed with the judges
kind of lost my faith with them
so much more talent but to have picked her i just don't understand
Who did Erin sleep with?
I really didn't like Erin's collection. It just seemed the same look with a different pattern with 1 or 2 different looks. If her designs are the future of fashion I am very worried about it. Personally, I preferred Roberi's look as it was well thought out, went together and I could actually see it looking good in the streets or in a magazine. Plus, it did help that it didn't look like foam
Too many of Erin's designs looked the same, with just different materials. Lucky for her she wasn't rated based on her character.
I think Robert had the most fashion forward and sophisticated collection. Was shocked Erin won. Her clothes reminded me of character one would expect on Tellitubbies
What a disappointing choice...Erin...really? Bananas and arts crafts beat out true designers!? Disgusting how the judges folded. Laurance is amazing... Ric had his moments...my favorite was Roberri. He was ripped off in a big way. He was the winner. I feel Erin will fall flat on her face. She's not a nice person and fails as a designer for human women. She should make clothes for Barbie dolls or teddy bears. I'll be honest, I don't think I'll tune in next season. I don't have any respect for those judges any longer. They are sell outs. I'm done...I'm too pissed off to continue.
Worst winner ever. Not trying to hate on anyone but last time I checked it was a design challenge and not arts and crafts challenge. If this the way things are going I have to agree with the other intelligent comments about Erin should not have won. This makes me think things are rigged as well. Robert or Laurence should have won by a landslide. Both showed amazingly designed and tailored collections. Unlike the value village, arts and crafts pieces generated by Erin. Watch out world we are going to have a bunch more budding so called designers... They will be from Cub scouts, or perhaps girl guides, because that is what these so called expert judges deem a designer.... Arts and crafts time. Also, she was a terrible person to Cornelius, it felt like highschool. She was part of the pretty club and was just mean to him along with Dexter. I too got to a point where I wish she would stop talking as I don't think she could "like", "ummmm" you know "like" make a full sentence without "like" using the word "ummm" "like". Way to sound like an air head and make those ex Mormons proud. Overall just very disappoint on this season, I think I only feel asleep for 5 of the episodes.
Y'all are so salty. Erin was great and her collection was great too. It was unique and creative and none of you would know high fashion if it slapped you in the face. Look at Gucci look at D&G. They do crazy stuff like that all the time and you with your closet full of aritzia and banana republic think you can tell Zac Posen that "you know best about fashion".
OOPs typo...... Meant Project Runway was ONE of my favorite shows............
The Show was fixed. The judges clearly favored Roberi. He was their choice. Then suddenly at the end, they were encouraged (forced) to choose someone else. How honorable was that? What was the reason? I don't understand.
The good thing is I will have so much more free time. Project Runway was won of my favorite shows. I will no longer watch it.
I wonder what the sponsors think about the fix???
I used to love project runway. Not so anymore. I am done. Michael Kors needs to come back. Zach Posen picks his winner from day one as it appears Heidi does too. My 8 year old granddaughter said Erin's clothes were stupid. Think I am done watching the show. Too much game playing and favoritism on the part of the judges. Heidi u r not a teenager and siding with so called designers who act that way will not make u going again. Tim Gunn take control of the show
Clearly the judges are so terrified of being seen as old and washed up that they chose the most juvenile "just out of school" contestant to somehow signal that they are cutting edge cool. Erin's designs were laughable all season long in their lack of a true silhouette despite her artistic embellishments. Like lipstick on a pig, her baubles did not make her clothes fashion forward. I enjoy seeing provocative fashion in magazines that stretch my imagination but Erin's clothes merely annoy. I turned off the tv in disgust when she was announced the winner. Now I do think the judges are losing their edge.
That was the worst finale I've ever watched I cannot believe Erin won her clothes are horrible. I believeLaurance should have won. Her clothes turned out to be amazing. Erin's clothes have no shape to them
As the season progressed, I found myself hitting mute every time Erin spoke because she "like" couldn't "like" complete a sentence "like" without a dozen "likes." That and the childish giggling were really annoying. Also, the snarky comments after she won don't speak well of her character. Roberi had the best collection in my opinion.
Really sad how project runway has turned out to be superficial. gone are the days where designers such mondo were rewarded for their thinking. people like laurence, roberi and rik showed much more design thinking, and execution, talent but sadly the judges go by face value. Erin was their baby doll whom they finally handed the prize unfortunately. it is only a matter of time that project runway is NOT going to be watched for true design, for future of fashion. over the past few seasons, its seems like through the season the judges at most give honest and fashion forward criticism to the designers. but ultimately in the end, it becomes a show that is either trying to play political games by applauding floral head gears tank tops & flowing skirts in the name of fashion, or 'embellishments' akka 'decorations' (in nina garcia's own words) as what is now in fashion. needless to say, if people of their stature and experience think this is fashion and choose to lead it this way, there is very less hope for design and for fashion.
Erin is nothing but a childish no talent mean girl. Roberi should have won
I really can't believe the judges chose Erin. Her fashions look like over sized doll clothes from a comic strip. I chose Roberi because he rose to the occasion and really put on an awesome show. My first choice would have been Laurence who has impeccable style and tailoring but unfortunately no wow factor in finale.
Roberi and Laurence were the best top fashion designers this season. Totally disagree with judges choice of Erin. Plastic baubles are a "unique sensibility"? That the judges didn't see the banana jacket as racist and would not be worn by any person of color, means they are not paying attention. They should apologize to viewers and to the other contestants.
Half the show was a promo for the upcoming kid show. Totally insulting to break up a finale everyone is anxious for. Heidi is all about the money. Many finales have disappointed me. Mondo is very quiet because of his ties. A lot of silence. Erin's intro to her collection was shocking, where'd the valley girl intimations come from? And her reactions were silly and immature. Like her fashions. Laurence and Roberi should have been top two. Show is losing its edge and viewership.
Project runway has now deteriorated into a ridiculous show. I'm done with it after watching for many seasons. Tim is the only saving grace. Enough of the weirdos, gay drama, black enabling and tackiness. Posen has ruined the show. A crazy weirdo like Erin right out of school with her glue gun nonsense and her sick "friendships" with the blacks is disgusting. She is not anywhere near designer material and should have been eliminated weeks ago. The show has run its course.
I do not agree with the judges that Erin should win. I do not think her creations are fashion forward. She's creative, but so are five year olds. I think her final collection lacked cohesion and pizzazz. It was filled with ill-fitting garments with her typical embellishments plastered on them. I think Zac Posen was enamored with her from episode 1 and never took off his rose colored glasses. If he and the other judges would have, they would have seen that Roberi's final collection was far superior to Erin's. I will not be watching this show again because I've lost faith in the taste level of the judges.
Erin is Gretchen #2. Wrong choice of winner!! Very disappointed at the judges.
It reminded me of the Mondo Gretchen debacle.
Thank goodness the judges have swung their pendulum back to the "fashion is art" side of the spectrum by picking Erin to win. We've been stuck too long in the boring world of "fashion is commercial clothes" ready to sell at your local strip mall. We need inspiration, not marketability in our broader conversation about fashion and PR finally gave it to us!
I enjoyed and respected the runway shows from all of the designers, and would have been happy to see Roberi win as well, but I am impressed that the judges finally have gone with the designer that pushed the boundaries of what's possible in the design of clothing the furthest. Would I buy most of Erin's work? No way. But do I see a designer with a forward thinking vision? Hell yes. I feel we finally have payback for the injustice done to Mondo in season 8.
I feel like I wasted my time watching this show. I kind of knew they would pick Erin because they seemed so in awe with her ugly splotches of crap pasted on her clothes. She should have left when she made those homeless shorts with throw up sewed on them. They wanted so much for Laurence to change her clothes so they could have a reason to not pick her because everything she made looked awesome except when she tried to please the judges. The show is set up to be a "surprise", "look who we picked" moment but they should probably stick with someone who actually makes clothes, not costumes. Look at Heidi in those silver boots and dress, just no taste. She shouldn't be picking the winner of fashion anything! And the others are there to tag along. It's become the next American idol!
Time, not the judges, will prove who the real winner is. With Roberi's expected success in fashion for years to come, we will most likely all ask 'Erin who?'
I was disappointed that the judges chose Erin to win this season's PR. She was not consistent with her work, there were ups & downs. Either of the 3, Roberi- Laurence or Rik should've won. I am not a fashion critic. All of their work seemed so professionally done, except Erin's.
Either the second or third year in a row that the wrong person was chosen.
No would in their right mind would wear last years (larger sized) fashions. That goes for this year as well. Who wants to wear a neoprene tent with all those stupid crafty add-ons.
What are the judges thining?
Lucky if I watch Runway again.
The majority of the earlier comments reflect my opinion of the results on PR. My personal favorite all season was Laurence. Her designs were stunning. I feel if she had not chosen to make her collection reflective of her life experience, her showing would have blown the rest out of the water. Rob then Rik followed her looks in design innovation and quality. I cannot imagine anyone intentionally wearing Erin's "designs" on any runway unless they were competing for Fashion Police's "misses." Erin's personality and products were of a piece--atrocious and childish. PR judges, were you serious or just self-absorbed like Erin.
The banana has been done... Bay Garnet and Chloe made it high fashion years ago. Roberi's collection was fun and unexpected in a wearable, intelligent and beautiful way. I'm disappointed with their choice but to each their own. I hope Roberi and Laurence (both were my season favorites) continue to design and find success. They are true talents with humility and grace.
So glad to see so many others feel the way I do! Here I was starting to worry I'd lost it. The other designers were so mature which made her look even more ridiculous. They're trying so hard to praise the unusual they handed the win to someone who didn't deserve it in the least. I'm sick of the idea that only the bizarre qualifies as fashion. Smh. Oh, and I've always hated yellow and now I think I despise it. Bananas have been ruined forever.
Erin is kooky and quirky, but that doesn't make for a winning designer. Sadly, her best creations were always the same wide silhouette., and that is what most stumped me about the judges' decision. Her other pieces were always throwaway designs: the chiffon top, oversize pants, whatever. She is a one-trick pony and wull need to grow a lot more to be successful. RoberI should have been the winner, although I was rooting for Laurence all season.
Erin's clothing is, for the most part, childish. It always seems as if she is trying so hard to be different that she loses all sense of style, sophistication, and class. Very disappointed in the judges and how they pandered to her sophomoric attitude and arts & craftsy clothing. As much as I've loved Laurence's work during the season, her runway show lacked the unique qualities her other designs had in abundance. Roberi's work exuded his innovation, love and passion, but a lot of the fabrics didn't read well for me. Rik's work was, in my estimation, the most wearble, while still being fashion forward. Rik or Roberi would have been much more suitable to wear the mantle of a Project Runway winner. Sorry, judges, but you chose pretentious clown suits instead of fashion.
ROBERI. his collection was so beautiful and innovative, and the judges didn't have a single negative thing to say about it! Although I WAS confused when the judges said that he'd be "making beautiful dresses with an edge" for his entire future. What?! I don't even understand what that means, especially when the pants he made were cool AF. And you know what? I liked the sneakers. He can do no wrong in my mind, but I would have liked to see them with the rest of the collection. I had a major problem with Erin's separates-- pants especially, and it seemed like the judges did too. WTH?!?? Did Erin's parents bribe the shows producers or something?
Laurence is hands down an amazing designer and Roberi's final runway show was awesome! Rik did great too. There was a great mix of jeans and leather. BUT Erin should not have won. The quirky and weird mixes did not work with some of her pieces. She's an inconsistent designer. I'm officially done watching the show.
Poor Roberi, his collection was everything he wanted understated, elegant, yet extremely striking and forward thinking. Just beautiful. Yet he lost to that bizarre, hideous, DelPozo mockery. Erin's clothes churned my stomach,
and truly there was nothing of innovation or interest in them. To be truly elegant one must consider less is more.
I was such a Laurence fan that I knew I'd be sad if she lost. But I also appreciated the style and spirit of the other designers...except the one who won. I said if Erin wins, this would be my last season watching. As a 15-season fan, I will truly miss the show. Tim, Heidi, Nina...and Swatch! But I can't resolve how the judges selected Erin who did not exude the same depth, style and soul that the others did. And why did no one find the brown human hands holding the bananas to be a bit racially insensitive. I was appalled by that look and totally turned off by her "trying-too-hard-to-be-quirky" aesthetic. No one wants to wear that stuff. I would want to buy Rik or Laurence ASAP. And Roberi totally earned my respect. Erin...bratty...selfish...self indulgent. And possibly racist.
Roberi is the winner, not Erin! I won't watch again either!
Erin is NOT the best designer. Roberi is!! I would never buy her design, which is too childish (and the judges agree) and not easy to clean. She should've been a contestant on PR Junior, if at all.
I've clearly been watching Project Runway too long. This season was too much of a disconnect for me. Roberi was clearly the only true designer among the finalists. I'm beginning to think the problem lies with the judges. Rude girl, Erin should have been eliminated early on and Laurence was never able to live up to her own assessment of her talent. I predict Roberi will have a great future as a designer.
Roberi got robbed. I don't know if I'll watch next season. Boo.
I thought Roberi's was the winning collection, creative and exquisitely beautiful. I appreciate Erin's creativity but find it a bit derivative ( Betsey Johnson without the carttwheel!).
I honestly hated Erin ever since the challenge where they got Cornelius eliminated. I have also hated her aesthetic. The keep handing and handing her wins. Also, the judges get mad at the other designers for having the same shoulders or pants twice, when Erin made the same exact coat like every other challenge, and they didn't say anything about it. I feel like she got special treatment that she didn't work for it deservem
I'm also tired of the judges handing a win to anyone who does something that's never been done before. Some things haven't been done because they shouldn't be done at all. I bet you have never tried eating fecal matter drenched in cheese and sprinkles while riding a roller coaster ... because no one in their right mind would. It's that simple.
I'm completely disgusted that Erin won. I hated her personality and designs all season long so I should have known she would walk away on top. I'm tired of people being weird just to be weird. It's actually the opposite of creative; it's just saying "look at me! Look how different I am!" without actually earning the attention. But to be honest, I didn't like any of the collections the finalists put out. Maybe a couple looks, but I didn't think any of them deserved the win with what they showed. I don't think I'm going to watch another season. My mom said last night "if that's fashion, count me out" and sadly I couldn't agree more.
Erin was the most unprofessional designer. Who could stand to be in a meeting with her when every other word out of her mouth was "like". Last night's finale was horrible, between the PRJr clips, another relentless use of the word "like", and her ugly non wearable clothes, I couldn't wait for it to be over. The judges dropped the ball, but I knew they would pick her. What were they thinking? What woman would want to wear an oversized neoprene, baby pink sack with giant sprinkles on it. I guess they are looking for something the general public wouldn't spend their hard earned money on. Very disappointed. Roberi, Ric or Laurence would have been a better choice. They were all great.
Erin should not have won. Her designs looked cheap and ugly. Even if i was 12 again, i would not be caught dead wearing that. It's not a craft show, its a Project Runway. It's trending now but I doubt anyone will be wearing it next year. This is the second year PR has disappointed me. The other 3 got robbed.
ERIN?!? Yuck! She is creative but unbelievably annoying. I hate "up-speak" which turns every statement into a question(?). She's lazy and her greatest accomplishment is getting in the car with her parents when they decided to leave Utah. Who cares! The clothes are slutty versions of toddler clothes. Based on personality alone, before a single item was made I knew the judges would pick her as winner. Roberi and Laurence are passionate dedicated professionals both of whom will be wildly successful and not just the flashy bit of sparkle covered neoprene, splash of yellow and pasty flesh that is ERIN the ex-Mormon's only trick in her bag.
I echo the disappointment on the judges awarding Erin the win. She should NOT have won! I turned the TV off as soon as her name was announced.
What in the world were the judges and Hedi thinking???
Roberti or Laurence should have won. Class designers with taste not in their mouth. I doubt if I will watch another season of the show.
When Erin was announced the winner I turned off my TV and left the room. Wrong choice. Her clothes were "clever" but nothing a grown-up would ever wear. Most had no shape and many looked alike, except for the ornamentation. The show isn't called "Project Arts & Crafts", so why would they reward her?! Over the years contestants have been warned not to design costume-y clothing, yet throughout the season Erin's were costume-y. Roberi's collection was extremely creative and made with so much heart. Laurence and Rik's were also interesting and they are both very talented. Although Erin has a point of view, her crafty, glue gun focus should have disqualified her early on. I may not watch another season after this disappointing result.
So...a collection of NEOPRENE won? What a shortcut way to make clothes...no need to sew hems or structure, etc. Was there even any sewing at all in that collection? Ugh.
Laurence was my pick from the start. If she had stuck to her aesthetic - or even sent her own dope wardrobe down the runway! - she could've taken it all. I'm a lIl' sad. I looked at her website and LOVE her stuff.
i loved laurance and roberi, for me it was batween those two. rick did a great job, but i am very disappointed with erins win. i know this isnt about marketable clothes but erins line was all over the place, they wanted cohesion but voted for her?
i will still watch but am also tired of the unconventional challenges
absolutely rubbish decision. would rather be boiled in oil than wear Erin's clothes. what were they thinking??
Worse decision ever made on project runway. Erin's collection was childish and silly. My 7 year old granddaughter can paste glitter and pasties on felt but I wouldn't call her a fashion designer. I am so disappointed in the judges decision. I'm glad this season is over. I just hope they do better on the next one.
I think every year the judges pick a contestant and stick with them throughout the whole show. Believe me they have chosen some hideous designers. What heidi wants heidi gets. And the others go along with her. Erin was the worst designer on the show who should have gone home a long time ago. The neoprene dress was nothing new, kerry washington wore the same style dress , about four years ago, except it was in a much better fabric. And some of her styles were patterned after others. No i did not like her smug attitude either. Get better judges who judge for the style , not for popularity . This show SUCKS!!! I wished either one of the others won. That they are true designers. ERIN IS A JOKE.
I love Erin since challenge one. I enjoyed her collection. But I really think Rob should won.
What I don't like about Erin is that her designs don't feel thought out. I get the impression she has a moment of inspiration and then must create that thing. There is not moment where she edits or changes. There is a lack of creativity in that she does not adapt from her original conception to create something interesting. There is a level of arrogance that says "why should I change anything? I'm amazing." This was clear in many of her consultations with Tim where she seemed to feel above his advice. She did not grow throughout the season. She was given permission to be weird, went with that, but never grew to make the weird something more than a childish idea. I'm disappointed because I felt like she was on stage with intelligent artists who were thoughtful and experimental and who really did adapt and grow, but she won because she just did whatever she felt like with little cohesion or thought. I think Erin has tremendous potential, but should not have won and was done a disservice by the judges by not being guided in a way that could have helped her become something that really did deserve to win.
The judges are so bias! It seems to be fixed for whatever reasons! I never would have thought Erin would have won! Laurence and the other guys were
much better! Maybe if they were blond and blue eyed, they would have had a chance! Especially when you look at the track record of the same old judges! I have watched this show from its beginning trying to give them the benefit of doubt but wow, the proof is in the pudding!
Can any of you write a complete and accurate sentence? Your comments are childish and immature! You sound like a bunch of whining babies! Omg...I'm not gonna watch the show EVER AGAIN! Boo hoo, this commentary is pathetic and juvenile! Get a grip you amateurs and learn how to write before you criticise anyone about whether they're talented or not! Most of you don't even know the correct names of the contestants you were cheering for this season! You should be embarrassed to put out comments that are so ridiculously childish! Grow up. If you had ever watched this show you would know it's not about selling clothes to some lower class geek's like you but to magazines,etc. Seriously, one of you actually compared herself to the Kardashian clan! Get a grip children!
Ummmm. Reading these comments it's clear you all have summed up how bizare this mess is. I mean it's clear this collection was a stunt. A stunt for toddlers tuning in. Big chubby cute rich toddlers with the guts to throw these huge garments on and leave the house. No god. All those interruptions of project runway juniors. They trying to motivate young viewers with queen green junior Erin snatching the crown while serving when preteen meets pregnant. No god. Roberi got played. Or even the other guy cause while chocolate was my favorite that collection was a snooze. But Erin. And those color castrophe combinations. Lol. Hilarious. I know Zac and Nina probably left and start talking mess about the advertisers as soon as they left the stage. This has to be for the young audience. All of the contestants were nice people but roberi gave you different and right. Not just different. Wow. Get these ratings project runway.
Laurence by all means then Roberi 2nd, Rik 3rd and Erin last. I don't understand why someone who puts out over-fluffy, unwearable, (most), costumes. There were a few good pieces. But come on, her work was like a Disney Cartoon.
I was team Erin the whole season. She had some misses during the season, but overall I loved her vision. Her designs are fun and whimsical. I was excited she won! Laurence was also a favorite of mine, and her designs were very wearable, but it did feel like it's stuff that's already in stores. I think they all did a great job and for the first time, i would've been happy no matter who won, even tho I was rooting for Erin.
Laurence by all means then Roberi 2nd, Rik 3rd and Erin last. I don't understand why someone who puts out over-fluffy, unwearable, (most), costumes. There were a few good pieces. But come on, her work was like a Disney Cartoon.
May never watch again.... Arts and crats wins. What a joke
What's wrong with the judges did we just get punked!!! How could those ugly pieces win or be worn ! Horrible tacky toddler creations I'm very disappointed and not watching anymore along with others # GLUEGUNQWEEN # Halloween costumes rejects
I don't understand the judges decision! Neoprene and craft. The one designer I wanted to see more of was Laurance. The other two were great but not sophisticated and very close to Teen Magazine.
I don't understand the judges decision! Neoprene and craft. The one designer I wanted to see more of was Laurance. The other two were great but not sophisticated and very close to Teen Magazine.
I would have been happy if anyone but Erin would have won this season. I'm so disappointed on the judges decision. Smh
Look; anyone who has watched Project Runway over the years should know that the judges aren't looking for someone whose designs are "sellable" but new and innovative, inspirational and avant garde! Erin's collection may not meet everyone's taste for wearable clothing but she pushed the boundaries for individuality and uniqueness, which is what the whole idea of Project Runway has ALWAYS focused on throughout the years! There is probably not one thing in ANY of the collections I would just love to run out and buy but I would definitely rather be inspired by something"new" and "unique" than the same ol', same ol' I've seen on the runway before! For that reason I believe the judges made the right decision!
All of those designers are going on to make clothing that will be marketable and will probably find fame and fortune. Nick Vieros,who was featured on the show this season didn't win but he's gone on to make clothing and money and is one of the best designers from past seasons! You need to quit whining and remember what Project Runway is all about! I definitely wouldn't buy the big flowers in my hair from last season either but she stood out and was an individual. THAT is what they look for in a winner so Brava to Erin Robertson for her victory and cheers to all the finalists for a job well done this season!
Neoprene overload. Avoid open flames. Judges showed their Erin favoritism early, she was never told to avoid overuse of neoprene as laurent was told to expand herself. Hobby lobby crafts is not fashon
Worst choice ever. Who would wear the crap she put out there. Roberti's collection was 100 times better then those Halloween costumes Erin made all season. I won't waste my time watching this show again.
Erin was the judges FAV from day one...even when she was on the bottom. It was obvious that she would win all along. Too bad for the other 3, who didnt have a chance to beat the "kindergarten art project" clothes :-(
Poor Roberi was robbed today, how sad!! I can not believe the judges decision. They definitely favored her. This is my last season watching project runway after this fraud. Cant believe i waisted my time watching this for some arts and crafts designer to win over true designers. Had anyother one i would be okay, but her with that collection, please!!!!
Poor Roberi was robbed today, how sad!! I can not believe the judges decision. They definitely favored her. This is my last season watching project runway after this fraud. Cant believe i waisted my time watching this for some arts and crafts designer to win over true designers. Had anyother one i would be okay, but her with that collection, please!!!!
Erin's designs are not flattering! No woman would be caught in public in that crap. Childish designs, toddler girl colors, cheap looking sequins. I am flabbergasted that she won. The dress that Erin had on was okay, far better than anything that her models had on. Any of the other designers would have been deserving, but not Erin. No way.
So disappointed...Erin's collection was childish and unflattering. Arts and crafts but no inspirational designs. No adult would want to be seen in her clothes.
I completely agree. Erin's collection was the worst. I don't know what the judges were thinking. Her clothes won't sell. I loved Laurance all season and thought she should have won.
Erin's designs are childish & immature. Laurence should have won as she makes beautiful clothes which were consistent over the course of the competition. I would have been happy with anyone though, just NOT Erin!!! Yuck! Hated her attitude also. Totally wrong.
Where would you sell that crap and who would waste their money buying Erin's designs, they were awful, so disappointed in the judge's choice, she was clearly the poorest designer of all the Finalist. Very Very angry with Project Runway Final Show
Unbelievable. So wrong. Erin is clever and creative but come on...the winner? The judges said it as much themselves - Roberi's show was outstanding. Then they pick Erin? Makes me not want to watch anymore.
I think Roberi or Rik should of won. Both of their clothes were done nicely. I totally disagree with judges decision.
Worst decision possible by the judges. Erin's arts and crafts designs are best suited for a three ring circus. Any if the other three designers would have been a better choice. The chances of me tuming in to watch another season of Project Runway ate slim. Very disappointing outcome. Laughable really.
I loved laurence. She stepped out of her comfort zone. She was true to her theme. I would take the white dress over anything that Erin created. It was sophisticated and told a story. Her tailoring for a woman's body impeccable.
Bad, bad, bad....ridiculous. No one but a twelve year old or a degenerate 30 plus would look twice at E's quirky "designs"...I hate baby pink.....bleck! Robert should have won (love Laurence).
Yes I didn't like Erin's designs at all. Crafty & so much puffy flair, who can wear that. I actually liked both Roberi or Rik. Something that I would buy.
First time in 15 years I immediately turned off the channel in disgust. Erin's design were just gimmicks. Cratfy and creative yes. Odd and different for sure. Talented visionary, gifted designer, not on your life. Terrible choice. What a sham. Different and unique doesn't always mean good. I don't know anyone who would wear her clothing in public, unless they just want to attract attention, like wearing a clown or Big Foot ccostume.
Roberi. His collection is rich and dreamy. Sophisticated yet down to earth, conceptual yet relatable. He understands the female psyche.
Terrible choice! I sat thru all those weeks for this?? Banana couture? ?? Pitiful!!
Roberi should have won! I almost cried for him.
I think the judges instead of looking for good design are looking for gimmicks such as Erin's. the worst choice of all the seasons. The show should look for new judges.
Tim Gunn got it right--Erin is a "Mean Girl". Although, not Mormon or from Utah, could she be any more condescending? Her clothes are childish as is her spirit. Fun is not kooky. Disappointed that she and her silly work won.
How disappointing was that. Erin should not have won. She was the worst designer. Some of the designs were so childish, over crafty and big (on size fits all). I would NOT wear her clothes. Maybe if I was 12 years old... It is not fair for the other designers who worked so hard all season and presented beautiful collections. During this season, it was so noticeable that Erin was the favorite one. She presented awful designs and yet the judges kept her in the competition. Maybe you should change judges. I do NOT know if I will watch Project Runway again. This is the second year in a row that I am so disappointed. I love your show but it is so frustrating to see, as a viewer, how unfair it is for the others.
Erin winning this season hurts the credibility of the judges or kardashians or me would wear her designs..plain and simple! Let's hope the ratings of the show don't go down. You guys totally waiste your money with Erin...worst finale ever!
Agree with everyone here!! Who wants to wear clothes that look like a 10 yr should be wearing them. These judges honestly want us to know the next best trend and this is not it!!! Not sure if I'll be watching next season. Also, how many times has Heidi been on the worst dressed list??!!loved Laurence and Roberi!! Great futures ahead!!
I am so disappointed in this show. Erin should not have won. This is a fashion show, not arts and crafts for children.
No, I thought Erin did a great job. I would have been happy with Rik winning, Laurence could have won, but she but put on a blah show. I used to get upset with the judges but honestly they are the on the leading edge of fashion.. and they know what looks good. That doesn't mean they pick the prettiest designs.
What a dumb decision.
They should change the name of their show to Project Runway Circus. wdf!
Pack of shitttttt.. Erins clothes is for the amateur circus. i loved Roberi's fashion, was hoping he would've won from day one. Heidi n them other judges don't know whats in from whats out. All Erin did in the entire runway was glue gun and blend a lot of bright colors n they didn't even match. Need some new judges it there's a next season!!!!!
Erin's was the most tackiest, incohesive collection out of all the designers. Roberi had the most interesting, well put together collection. I could actually see myself wearing some of the pieces at the same time still keeping that runway effect. Roberi had way more WOW pieces that really caught your eye in a postive way while Erin's collection really just left a bad costumey taste in my mouth. I was not impressed by her collection at all. #teamroberi
She shouldn't have won. She had an attitude throughout the show. Very disappointed. I would never wear any of her clothes.
erin the glue gun queen so disappointed with the judges
kind of lost my faith with them
so much more talent but to have picked her i just don't understand