Poker face was so much better. I mean come on people.
Do people not understand what real singing is. Really Idina and Lea sang the hell out of that thing.
How can they be losing against a weak mash up that was over produced. wow.
Son of Mumford - 13 years ago
What is the matter with 53% of the people here? Listen to the Glee versions and the original versions -- JayZ stomps the Glee version, but listening to Poker Face done by Glee makes it a real freaking song. It's a dance hall charade in the hands of Gaga, but a thing of beauty when Rachel sings it.
Taylor - 13 years ago
While Poker Face was amazing, it doesn't compare to the actual Lady Gaga song. Plus, I don't really like Shelby, so that might've had something to do with it... their voices are amazing, indeed, but I really truly enjoyed ILNY/NYNY. It was one of the few songs they did in the second half of season two that I enjoyed (minus the Warblers' songs). It was fun and upbeat and truly awesome. And c'mon, they were in New York, how cool is that!?
Shanda - 13 years ago
@ Hanna Agreed. This is crazy. I'm shocked.
Hanna - 13 years ago
This shouldn't even be a competition! Poker Face was one of the best renditions of a Glee song I've ever heard! They killed Lady Gaga at her own song. A true gleek would know this.
Leave a Comment
Create your own.
Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.
Poker face was so much better. I mean come on people.
Do people not understand what real singing is. Really Idina and Lea sang the hell out of that thing.
How can they be losing against a weak mash up that was over produced. wow.
What is the matter with 53% of the people here? Listen to the Glee versions and the original versions -- JayZ stomps the Glee version, but listening to Poker Face done by Glee makes it a real freaking song. It's a dance hall charade in the hands of Gaga, but a thing of beauty when Rachel sings it.
While Poker Face was amazing, it doesn't compare to the actual Lady Gaga song. Plus, I don't really like Shelby, so that might've had something to do with it... their voices are amazing, indeed, but I really truly enjoyed ILNY/NYNY. It was one of the few songs they did in the second half of season two that I enjoyed (minus the Warblers' songs). It was fun and upbeat and truly awesome. And c'mon, they were in New York, how cool is that!?
@ Hanna Agreed. This is crazy. I'm shocked.
This shouldn't even be a competition! Poker Face was one of the best renditions of a Glee song I've ever heard! They killed Lady Gaga at her own song. A true gleek would know this.