Romo's numbers are there,& he has the talent to win the big ones.You gotta remember that Eli had a incredible D last year,in my opinion,that's what won the games. If Romo was on the Giants right now,they'd have a lot more than two rings. Romo doesn't get the credit he deserves because he doesn't have the D NY. has,but I think the cowboys will get their just reward this season
Terry - 12 years ago
I can't say that Eli is better than Romo, I have seen Eli choke games as well. As for the 2 rings,he's also 2 lucky plays away from not having any rings either.
Steve - 12 years ago
Its all about winning, McNabb holds all the Eagles records as QB, but being down 6 points with two minutes left, he is the last person you would want in the huddle. Until Romo wins something, he is going to be viewed the same. My view is he has the talent to be the best, but lacks in commitment to the team and the game.
Gino - 12 years ago
I have been a Cowboys fan for over 40 years and I would trade Romo in a minute....Sucks in big games. Eli unfortunately is a winner Hurts to say it but its the truth!
Oz - 12 years ago
Toomer the FOOL!!!!!!!!!!
John T - 12 years ago
I've been a Giants fan for 60 years and an Amani Toomer fan since the day the Giants drated him. But he's asleep at the switch on this one. He researched the statistics? There's only one that matters and it's 2 to 0 Eli.
Mark aranita - 12 years ago
If romo had that front four of the giants easily better than eli.romo had what 2.2sec do that eli
jonathan ruelas - 12 years ago
Actually the Giants D is the real 2x superbowl winner. Eli sucks BIG ones, and Rhomo sucks even BIGGER ones!!!!!
Rick Hundley - 12 years ago
This is the most rediculous thing coming out in a long time. I am a diehard cowboys fan but when you think how Eli has won in such a short time with a team that shouldnt have won, no way can Romo be better than Eli. I do not like Eli but right now Romo aint good enough to tie Eli's shoes. Romo when the team went 13-3 should have done it but didnt. Great QB's in the past have not won super bowls but none of them were the DALLAS COWBOYS whom you expect to contend every year. Fran T and Dan M were great QB's but Eli has won when it counted most and thats a true champion and Tony has had to much choke time. Win the big one and then come back with a stupid article like this.
King Supa - 12 years ago
Romo is a superb athlete and a top 5 talent but his like of consistency has others doubting the skills they see. If you compare numbers Romo's are far better and top 5 period when he wins a ring then he will silence the critics so be ready to put him in the race for MVP and Super Bowl champion #1 Cowboy fan
Pedro - 12 years ago
Amani is an articulate ex player who is opinionated and who likes to be a contrarian just to get attention. He's the same guy that basically said that Jerry Rice got into the Hall of Fame because he benefitted from a system that threw the ball a lot, unlike his career with the Giants, who ran it a lot.
Jer - 12 years ago
Hey Ed, maybe "EliSuxCox" IS actually Tony Romo..... ????? hmmmm
ed - 12 years ago
Who are you people who make comments like, "Can't spell feline without eli?" Better clean your inflatable woman. She's getting sticky.
Jer - 12 years ago
between these two no question Eli, he has two rings. But Big Ben is better
Romo's numbers are there,& he has the talent to win the big ones.You gotta remember that Eli had a incredible D last year,in my opinion,that's what won the games. If Romo was on the Giants right now,they'd have a lot more than two rings. Romo doesn't get the credit he deserves because he doesn't have the D NY. has,but I think the cowboys will get their just reward this season
I can't say that Eli is better than Romo, I have seen Eli choke games as well. As for the 2 rings,he's also 2 lucky plays away from not having any rings either.
Its all about winning, McNabb holds all the Eagles records as QB, but being down 6 points with two minutes left, he is the last person you would want in the huddle. Until Romo wins something, he is going to be viewed the same. My view is he has the talent to be the best, but lacks in commitment to the team and the game.
I have been a Cowboys fan for over 40 years and I would trade Romo in a minute....Sucks in big games. Eli unfortunately is a winner Hurts to say it but its the truth!
Toomer the FOOL!!!!!!!!!!
I've been a Giants fan for 60 years and an Amani Toomer fan since the day the Giants drated him. But he's asleep at the switch on this one. He researched the statistics? There's only one that matters and it's 2 to 0 Eli.
If romo had that front four of the giants easily better than eli.romo had what 2.2sec do that eli
Actually the Giants D is the real 2x superbowl winner. Eli sucks BIG ones, and Rhomo sucks even BIGGER ones!!!!!
This is the most rediculous thing coming out in a long time. I am a diehard cowboys fan but when you think how Eli has won in such a short time with a team that shouldnt have won, no way can Romo be better than Eli. I do not like Eli but right now Romo aint good enough to tie Eli's shoes. Romo when the team went 13-3 should have done it but didnt. Great QB's in the past have not won super bowls but none of them were the DALLAS COWBOYS whom you expect to contend every year. Fran T and Dan M were great QB's but Eli has won when it counted most and thats a true champion and Tony has had to much choke time. Win the big one and then come back with a stupid article like this.
Romo is a superb athlete and a top 5 talent but his like of consistency has others doubting the skills they see. If you compare numbers Romo's are far better and top 5 period when he wins a ring then he will silence the critics so be ready to put him in the race for MVP and Super Bowl champion #1 Cowboy fan
Amani is an articulate ex player who is opinionated and who likes to be a contrarian just to get attention. He's the same guy that basically said that Jerry Rice got into the Hall of Fame because he benefitted from a system that threw the ball a lot, unlike his career with the Giants, who ran it a lot.
Hey Ed, maybe "EliSuxCox" IS actually Tony Romo..... ????? hmmmm
Who are you people who make comments like, "Can't spell feline without eli?" Better clean your inflatable woman. She's getting sticky.
between these two no question Eli, he has two rings. But Big Ben is better
Fuck shELI.
Can't spell feline without ELI.
get real! Eli has 2 rings