What should a reviewer do in a case like this?
Nothing. Reviews are confidential.
Contact the journal that published the paper privately about these concerns.
Write a letter to the editor for publication.
Nothing, since the authors did not make any actual error.
Vote
View Results
See this poll on:
https://poll.fm/7479318/embed
Leave a Comment
Your Name
Please enter your name.
Email Address
Please enter your email address.
Your Website (optional)
Your Comment
Please enter a comment.
0
/4000 chars
Submit Comment
Leave a Comment