Would Mo'Nique Have Done A Better Job Playing Cookie Than Taraji P. Henson?

57 Comments

  • Curtis D - 9 years ago

    EVERYTIME I see Taraji as Cookie on Empire, I want to sing R. Kelly's "Cookie" through the show.

  • kt - 9 years ago

    Taraji is such a great actress. I HOPE THAT SHE GET AWARDS for this. Taraji is the heart of The show. Keep up the good work! !!!!!!!

  • evilskinnygirl…lol - 9 years ago

    No offense but Monique as Cookie…it wouldn't work for the total Cookie role. The sassy part yes but the sexy part no way….

  • No Mo'Nique - 9 years ago

    No...Girl BYE. you just said you were blackmailed and now you're being offered roles? Must have been a dream you were having ir the fact that the show is an A1 hit and now you want a piece of the spotlight.

  • pooh - 9 years ago

    hell naw Monique is good but Taraji is killing that part cant see any1 else playing that role like it was made 4 her good choice yall

  • Katie - 9 years ago

    I have seen the majority of the comments have said that Mo Nique would not have made a better Cookie than Taraji P. Henson, and I completely agree. When I heard this on the morning show, I couldn't wait to come home and comment because I think that the part of Cookie Lyons was made for Taraji P. Henson, she plays the role that well! Nothing against Mo Nique, but I honestly believe this show would not be so incredibly huge if Mo Nique had played the role of Cookie, the whole entire show would have been received differently. Taraji P. Henson IS Cookie to me, and I know I wouldn't be glued to this show like I am if Mo Nique played Cookie. Sorry Mo Nique!! But I am so in love with Jamal!! I wish he would come find me!

  • 4real - 9 years ago

    Monique....really????? Precious "yes" but she's no Cookie. Sorry Momo

  • Debra - 9 years ago

    In the format the show is coming from now,no Mo'Nique wouldn't have fit into that format as Cookie but she would have been a great access to the show in a different role. Having those two power houses would have been beyond belief!!

  • khamil - 9 years ago

    I love ❤ Monique to death but that role I can'tsee her in at all

  • Gabrielle B - 9 years ago

    I love Monique but she just would not fit for that role at all. Taraji is just perfect she plays the hell out of that role!

  • Sherry - 9 years ago

    If we believe Mo'Nique, it would have been her playing opposite Wesley Snipes which I can't see at all. It would not have been the same chemistry or appeal as Taraji & Terrence.

  • Linda B - 9 years ago

    Monique, you and Terrance Howard would not fit as a couple. Taraji and Terrance click. Plus there is a difference in playing gangster like and ghetto roles. You have mostly done ghetto type and comedy roles. Neither plays a part in the story line. You are a good actress and comedian (minus the cussing), but airing this issue this way shows you are more fit for the ghetto roles.

  • Tu'i - 9 years ago

    No. The End.

  • T.C. - 9 years ago

    No disrespect intended, but Mo'nique how you figure? Nobody can be Cookie but Taraji...that character is a custom fit for her! And her Terrence automatically vibed together...where do you think you would have fit in at? Your're cool and all, maybe you could have been Porsha her assistant, but Cookie you are not!

  • jackie - 9 years ago

    Was she not just complaining about how Hollywood blackballed her. And now she was all of a sudden offered the roll to be "Cookie"! Ok like does n e body else know a lie when you hear a lie..cause right now I hear a lie.. first nobody wont offer you a part then to I got an offer. . Hhhhhhummmm!

  • Nicki L - 9 years ago

    Empire cast is perfect.... The best woman won Sorry Mo.....

  • Joan Rhodes - 9 years ago

    I love Monique. She has been like my alter ego, her and Patti Labelle but Taraji has a way of making Cookie someone we can relate to in some ways. Not saying Monique couldn't just Taraji fits smoother. Love you Mo

  • Miss V - 9 years ago

    Naw she could be her prison buddy, ride or die friend, or something like that, but COokie is good. ...

  • Miss V - 9 years ago

    Naw she could be her prison buddy, ride or die friend, or something like that, but COokie is good. ...

  • Ms. Big Red Bryant - 9 years ago

    Monique is a good actor but Cookie was meant for Taraji part#2 of Hustle Flow so Empire is the one :-) :-) :-)

  • Lenet H. - 9 years ago

    Monique may have been offered the role as Lucious' assistant but not the role as Cookie, it wouldn't be as believable,the way Cookkie's interaction with Anika,or for that matter Lucious...I think it's great the way it is niw

  • PAMELA - 9 years ago

    IT'S HARD OUT HERE FOR A PIMP SPIN OFF WAS THE ATTENTION GRABBER FOR ME THAT'S ALL THAT IS NKKI BABY.

  • Delisa Kennedy Qualls - 9 years ago

    no no I love Monique..but team Cookie

  • Diane - 9 years ago

    Why would the man ask a woman that is too old to play the part of cookie? Mo'nique would not have been able to pull it off. this roll was made for Taraji she brings it

  • Nene3415 - 9 years ago

    The part of Cookie is made for Taraji!!!! Mo'Nique should go and eat some Cookies

  • Michelle - 9 years ago

    I love Monique and she is very talented. But this role was made for Taraji. No one can master this role like she is doing.

  • Kmf - 9 years ago

    Mo'Nique please have several seats to the left. No way would I have even considered watching this show if Monique was Cookie. Just watch it every Wed like the rest of us. Ugh!!!!

  • Monique - 9 years ago

    Taraji is doing her thang! I can't see anyone else but her! #teamcookie

  • Monique - 9 years ago

    Taraji is doing her thang! I can't see anyone else but her! #teamcookie

  • Rgreen - 9 years ago

    It isn't that I think she would have done a better job, I personally think she would have played the part just as good as Taraji. Both are excellent actress, and I think Mo'nique would have played the hell out of the role as well.

  • J Nes - 9 years ago

    The question is laughable! Taraji was made for this role. It was actually a blessing for Lee Daniels that Fox refused to work with her because the show wouldn't have been have a popular as it is now!

  • pam - 9 years ago

    not downing monique but this part was made for taraji, as far as her being black balled, these women get blinded by love and let their unqualified spouses manage their careers at their own demise, I would be like honey I love you but you effin up my career you are fired.

  • Angela Napier - 9 years ago

    This show was made for taraji and terrance,monique is a good actress but this show is not made for her,they would have to change lucious,the chemistry is not there,everything is perfect the way it is,i feel likeall the other comments,she probably could have played another sassy part on their with that mouth and attitude but definitely not cookie,so cheer up nique and give your girl her props,she earned this.Writer's,thumbs up,you all outdid yourselves on this one. Love it,Love it!!!

  • Collina - 9 years ago

    I don't believe she would have done a BETTER job; but, I don't think the role would have suffered either. Monique is a gifted actress and she would have brought her own spin to Cookie. I do agree that the male lead would have to be different. I don't know if she could have matched the chemistry with Terrence Hiwaed that Taraji has.

  • Juanita - 9 years ago

    No!! Sorry Nique you are a good actress But Taraji is The Only Cookie My opinion I believe the author wrote that part with Taraji in mind again Sorry Nique :) :)

  • Latese Robinson - 9 years ago

    It really does not matter at this point Taraji got the part as Cookie Lyon and it would be foolish to switch up now so with that being said Monique you could have keep all that and just congratulated her. There will be more parts for you and think how many parts you got someone else would have did a better job on...

  • blendia - 9 years ago

    No no no tarji is great at this role.Monique please let this along the show great everyone loves it why freak with it now.

  • Denise - 9 years ago

    Monique is a good actress but this ISNT her role!!!! Even if it were offered to her she wouldn't have done a great good as Taraji! Please leave it alone Monique and move on! God has something bigger and better JUST FOR YOU!!!!! Stop wailing in self pity!!!! It's not cute on you!!!!

  • Kala - 9 years ago

    Monique is a great actress but Taraji rules the show and I don't think that the show would be so high in ratings if Monique played the role of Cookie. It would have been a whole different vibe, hands down.

  • Anne Roberts - 9 years ago

    Taraji is Cookie. I personally do not like Monique or her bad attitude. I can not think of any actress who could have played Cookie better. I love Empire and I love Taraji. I wish it was on for two hours instead of one. Whenever I get together with friends or at the bus stop all the talk is Cookie and Empire. Congratulations Lee, another winner.

  • tk - 9 years ago

    With Gabby on the show...I would've kept thinking about PRECIOUS...that's not something I want out of this show

  • RAN - 9 years ago

    I really do not understand why the media is entertaining this. I love MONIQUE, but as a black woman I feel she is out of line. Taraji has the role,the show is awesome. I love the story and the cast. They did a great job. Stop it Monique! Thou shall not covet!! Congratulate and move on.

  • Mz V - 9 years ago

    You have got to be kidding..who was going to play Lucious??? I know T Howard's BACK thanks the network for more reasons than the obvious!

  • Tina Woods from Memphis - 9 years ago

    They picked the perfect person to play Cookie. The chemistry that Taraji and Terrance have is amazing hands down. Just can't see Monique playing that role and I didn't base my decision on whatever going on with her and Lee Daniels. #teamTaraji!!!!!!!

  • jean Abraham - 9 years ago

    Although Mo'Nique is an outstanding actress and could play a Cookie Lyons,this Cookie Lyons was made for Taraji P hands down spunky,sassy,sexy and a great match for Lucius. She could have played her sassy assistant. Knowing Mo she feels she was too big for the part but this is a good role it would have at least opened the door for her to get more parts. Sometimes we have to humble ourselves. She doesn't just want to be a memory.

  • Bro. Sykes - 9 years ago

    I was already hesitant about watching Empire in the first place, because when I saw Taraji playing another "Baby Boy" role I was just like oh no here we go again. I gave it one episode, and from there I was a Cookie fan. She's so good at it lol. It fits her so well like she's really like that or was once like that in reality. Now had I seen Monique in it... I definitely wouldn't have given it a chance. She's too extra for me. Taraji reeled me in.

  • LaKicia BT - 9 years ago

    Don't get me wrong Monique is a great comedian, actress, and Talk Show Host. but Taraji is playing the hell out of cookie. Taraji and Terrence just have that chemistry and I am LOVING EMPIRE.

  • nikol - 9 years ago

    No regardless Monique would not have made a good choice.They would have had yo rewrite the whole script

  • Nicky P - 9 years ago

    If Monique had been Cookie, then Wesley would be Lucious, since it was Taraji who requested Terence Howard. I just can't picture it with the two of them. Taraji IS Cookie!

  • Wells - 9 years ago

    It really doesn't matter. Because of the actress Taraji it would be difficult to perceive anyone else in the role. Mo'Nique your day will come, until then take a seat and enjoy the show.

  • TK901 - 9 years ago

    Monique should have prove Lee Daniels wrong by getting a great role. No one wants to work with a big mouth know it all. It seems Monique is taking hits at Taraji. Let stick together.

  • Denekia Jackson - 9 years ago

    She could've took Precious part that's it

  • sheila - 9 years ago

    I voted no, I just don't see the sexy that taraji brings I mean she could have nailed the rest and maybe even the sexy with a different guy playing lucious

  • Jae - 9 years ago

    I think that she should have a part on the show but she could never be Cookie!

  • Anna C - 9 years ago

    No I believe Monique is not a good pick for Cookie. Taraji was maked for this role point blank period.

  • cierra - 9 years ago

    Taraji is sassy, classy, and gangster all in one!! Monique may be funny but Taraji was made for the roll!

  • Jasmine w - 9 years ago

    Boo boo kitty vs Monique enough said.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment