6 Comments

• 
  Dimetria - 5 years ago

  This is so hard because I love them both!!!

• 
  Luis - 5 years ago

  I vote for Jim Shaw because they offer fresh seafood at reasonable prices. I wish they open a restaurant Warner Robins-Perry area

• 
  Patricia J.Sapp - 5 years ago

  I love there catfish all you can eat

• 
  Charles C Cooper Jr - 5 years ago

  We love seafood and catfish and Jim Shaw's consistently has the best. Over the years they have kept a friendly and helpful staff. Still maintains a comfortable small town vibe.

• 
  Xander - 5 years ago

  Both of these restaurants deserve to be the “best of the best” in my opinion. I’ve never had a bad experience at either establishment and their food has always been exceptional.

• 
  Marie - 5 years ago

  I voted for The Rookery because they have a good variety of delicious food and also most importantly they have better hours. But I love them both