umm... i saw the movie twice && both times it ended with Edward.. but now i wanna see the one that ends with Bella.. : )
Twilight Lover(L) - 14 years ago
I only saw 2 times but im planning on going 100 more the first time i saw it it ended with edward and the second time with bella, it really bothers me that the girls who havent even read the book go to the cinema and scream every 2 seconds and then in the end shout at the movie for not showing bella's answer IF YOU WANT TO KNOW IT READ THE BOOK!
by the way i loooooved the movie it was great TEAM EDWARD!!!!
Cat - 14 years ago
the first time i saw the film it ended with bella looking shocked but i'm going to see it again in two days, i will look and see if it ends different...
Does anyone wonder what ending will be on the DVD when it comes out? or will there still be alternate endings ??? (keeps you thinking doesnt it).
LRS - 14 years ago
In response to the comment that "marry me" wasn't in the book New Moon, you need to revisit the book! Edward DOES ask her in New Moon and then he asks her fagain formally with a ring in Eclipse. He does it when they are discussing when and who will change her into a vampire. He puts it as a conditon to her getting him to do it rather than Alice or Carlise. I promise!
kim - 14 years ago
first time it was edward and the second time it was bella, it just took a little longer than the first time , liked it better with edward ending
belgium december 1
Paula - 14 years ago
I saw it 4 times ... in 3 different theaters, and it always ended the same for me ... Bella surprised.
Shalynne - 15 years ago
Ok people, do you even realize that that ending wasn't even pertaining to the book? The only reason that they put that in was so that the fans that just watch the movies and don't read the books will definitely want to come back and see Eclipse so it will get high ratings because of the cliff hanger. If you read the books you would've noticed that there was actually a very important scene in ECLIPSE where he says that, it is very frustrating to me. Especially when the little 1st grade girls sitting behind me and have seen the movie like 3 times before are telling their friend the entire movie as it happens, and they didn't even read the books. They don't even have a clue. One of their comments actually right at the end of the movie was that one time when they saw the movie, they started yelling at the screen when it ended like that. I think that if they honestly shouldn't be allowed to watch the moveis in the first place. especially when they can't even read the books for one and probably wouldn't if they could and if their parents have read the books they probably wouldn't let them read them at this point anyway. Lol it feels good to rant meaninglessly.
lynn flowers - 15 years ago
i have only seen it once but plan on going again but i saw bella looking surprised when he ask her then it went off but it does make u wonder why that happened and if it really has two different endings then when it comes out on dvd what will happen with the ending unless it gives u two endings to watch like they did with bourne identity u got two different endings to watch oh well it was still awesome i luv edward cullen go team edward!!!
Tawnee - 15 years ago
well, maybe the theater cut it off at different times so, it looks like 2 different endings,,maybe?
CULLEN LOVER(L):) - 15 years ago
I saw it twice as well, and the first tome, november 20th, it ened with bellas suprised face!
And the second time nov. 24th it just ened with dward!!
And they were in 2 diffrent theaters!!
Hmm...weird i never thought of that! :S
But i prolly didnt cause i cried like a baby threw the movie... both times!! ;)
I LOVE ALICE & JASPER & CARLISLE & ESME & BELLA & EDWARD & ROSEALIE & EMMET & JACOB & EMILLY & SAM & THE REST OF THE WOLF PACK & LIKE VERYONE ELSE!! (LL) ;)
HOPE THEY MAKE BREAKIGN DAWN!!! (yn) (yn) :) :)
**Since NEW MOON has been it its made almost hlaf a BILLION dolllars!! (LL):)
Shea - 15 years ago
I think both times I saw it in the theatre (Greater Vancouver in Canada) it ended with Bella, but now I'm not sure...but I believe when I watched it online, it ended with Edward...I'm going on Saturday again at a different theatre but owned by the same chain, so I'll keep that in mind...
Sydney - 15 years ago
i saw new moon 2 times and they were both different now that i think about it.
Michelle - 15 years ago
I saw New Moon 5 times in 3 different theaters in NJ and they have all end with Bella being suprised by Edwards question. It is very quick so maybe some people just missed it.
Sarah - 15 years ago
I saw the movie 3 times. The first 2 times it ended with Edward and the 3rd time it ended with Bella.
Paige - 15 years ago
i saw it twice. the first time, it was the Edward ending. the second time, it was the Bella ending.
annie - 15 years ago
the first time i saw it, it ends with edward, and the 2nd and 3th it ends with bella shocked.. But i think that is the same ending.. just cut it by few seconds..
caitlin - 15 years ago
i saw it twice. and it both ended with bella shocked.
isis - 15 years ago
sorry i put minutes but i mean seconds
isis - 15 years ago
its trueeee
the first time i saw it it finish with edward saying mary me and the second finish with a surprised bella but the truth is not of of the other world they are just a few of minutes aniway i LOVE IT ¡¡¡
Carolina - 15 years ago
hey, now that you mention it I saw the two finals.
Really when I saw the second time, I did that was odd, but Cree I was crazy, but now that you mention it, yes, they are different endings. but I live in Mexico, so...
Marisa - 15 years ago
I have seen New Moon three times, and 2 of the times it ended with Bella looking very suprised. But the other time it ended with Edward! I still LOVE it though!
umm... i saw the movie twice && both times it ended with Edward.. but now i wanna see the one that ends with Bella.. : )
I only saw 2 times but im planning on going 100 more the first time i saw it it ended with edward and the second time with bella, it really bothers me that the girls who havent even read the book go to the cinema and scream every 2 seconds and then in the end shout at the movie for not showing bella's answer IF YOU WANT TO KNOW IT READ THE BOOK!
by the way i loooooved the movie it was great TEAM EDWARD!!!!
the first time i saw the film it ended with bella looking shocked but i'm going to see it again in two days, i will look and see if it ends different...
Does anyone wonder what ending will be on the DVD when it comes out? or will there still be alternate endings ??? (keeps you thinking doesnt it).
In response to the comment that "marry me" wasn't in the book New Moon, you need to revisit the book! Edward DOES ask her in New Moon and then he asks her fagain formally with a ring in Eclipse. He does it when they are discussing when and who will change her into a vampire. He puts it as a conditon to her getting him to do it rather than Alice or Carlise. I promise!
first time it was edward and the second time it was bella, it just took a little longer than the first time , liked it better with edward ending
belgium december 1
I saw it 4 times ... in 3 different theaters, and it always ended the same for me ... Bella surprised.
Ok people, do you even realize that that ending wasn't even pertaining to the book? The only reason that they put that in was so that the fans that just watch the movies and don't read the books will definitely want to come back and see Eclipse so it will get high ratings because of the cliff hanger. If you read the books you would've noticed that there was actually a very important scene in ECLIPSE where he says that, it is very frustrating to me. Especially when the little 1st grade girls sitting behind me and have seen the movie like 3 times before are telling their friend the entire movie as it happens, and they didn't even read the books. They don't even have a clue. One of their comments actually right at the end of the movie was that one time when they saw the movie, they started yelling at the screen when it ended like that. I think that if they honestly shouldn't be allowed to watch the moveis in the first place. especially when they can't even read the books for one and probably wouldn't if they could and if their parents have read the books they probably wouldn't let them read them at this point anyway. Lol it feels good to rant meaninglessly.
i have only seen it once but plan on going again but i saw bella looking surprised when he ask her then it went off but it does make u wonder why that happened and if it really has two different endings then when it comes out on dvd what will happen with the ending unless it gives u two endings to watch like they did with bourne identity u got two different endings to watch oh well it was still awesome i luv edward cullen go team edward!!!
well, maybe the theater cut it off at different times so, it looks like 2 different endings,,maybe?
I saw it twice as well, and the first tome, november 20th, it ened with bellas suprised face!
And the second time nov. 24th it just ened with dward!!
And they were in 2 diffrent theaters!!
Hmm...weird i never thought of that! :S
But i prolly didnt cause i cried like a baby threw the movie... both times!! ;)
I LOVE ALICE & JASPER & CARLISLE & ESME & BELLA & EDWARD & ROSEALIE & EMMET & JACOB & EMILLY & SAM & THE REST OF THE WOLF PACK & LIKE VERYONE ELSE!! (LL) ;)
HOPE THEY MAKE BREAKIGN DAWN!!! (yn) (yn) :) :)
**Since NEW MOON has been it its made almost hlaf a BILLION dolllars!! (LL):)
I think both times I saw it in the theatre (Greater Vancouver in Canada) it ended with Bella, but now I'm not sure...but I believe when I watched it online, it ended with Edward...I'm going on Saturday again at a different theatre but owned by the same chain, so I'll keep that in mind...
i saw new moon 2 times and they were both different now that i think about it.
I saw New Moon 5 times in 3 different theaters in NJ and they have all end with Bella being suprised by Edwards question. It is very quick so maybe some people just missed it.
I saw the movie 3 times. The first 2 times it ended with Edward and the 3rd time it ended with Bella.
i saw it twice. the first time, it was the Edward ending. the second time, it was the Bella ending.
the first time i saw it, it ends with edward, and the 2nd and 3th it ends with bella shocked.. But i think that is the same ending.. just cut it by few seconds..
i saw it twice. and it both ended with bella shocked.
sorry i put minutes but i mean seconds
its trueeee
the first time i saw it it finish with edward saying mary me and the second finish with a surprised bella but the truth is not of of the other world they are just a few of minutes aniway i LOVE IT ¡¡¡
hey, now that you mention it I saw the two finals.
Really when I saw the second time, I did that was odd, but Cree I was crazy, but now that you mention it, yes, they are different endings. but I live in Mexico, so...
I have seen New Moon three times, and 2 of the times it ended with Bella looking very suprised. But the other time it ended with Edward! I still LOVE it though!