there ya go. that's exactly why the coaches should be making the decisions, and not the fans. given the chance, fans never fail to demonstrate that they are mostly idiots. i'll wager two thirds of the fans who voted for redman did so because of mendenhall's comments about bin laden and 9/11 and not because of any football savvy insight. as for a 2 back set, dream on. pass happy brucey boy will never do that, whether it's a good idea or not. to be fair, i should mention that the biggest idiots of all are the sports reporters and analysts. mr. redman, mr. mendenhall, if you should happen to read the drivel posted here by simpletons with WAY too much time on their hands, please try your best to ignore it. you are both outstanding players, and complement each other perfectly. go stillers!
acavemand - 13 years ago
@bdity200 exactly!! Why don't we just go to a 2 back backfield so we keep teams guessing as to who's gonna get the ball. Oh and I have been a Steelers fan all 14 years of my life and I just am never all that impressed by Mendenhall. Yes he's faster and can spin out of tackles, but he's been known to fumble balls and drop passes. The only major fumble Redman has had was that awful one last year that brought back memories of Bettis.
bdity200 - 13 years ago
I say lets use what we have and RUN them both!!!!
taco hedges - 13 years ago
Redman is better with ball security, yards per carry, blocking and catching.
Yeah go head and start Mendenbutt
thomas - 13 years ago
are you people kidding me, rashard is our back. we loved him last year when he rushed for over 1,000 yards. we cant just give up on him after a few mistakes. he's our back and were sticking with him.
dan - 13 years ago
no frank ur nuts im a long time fan and redman does not fumble, he doesnt make mistakes,
he moves the pile forward! he is the way steeler run offense should be!
Frank - 13 years ago
You people are NUTS...if you think Redman is better than Mendenhall. Typical uneducated Steelers bandwagon fans! Probably the one's that wanted Fleury benched last season for Johnson.
Jack - 13 years ago
Redman runs like Steeler running back of old His running style is more suitable for the steelers running game.A little bit like one of the best THE BUS
there ya go. that's exactly why the coaches should be making the decisions, and not the fans. given the chance, fans never fail to demonstrate that they are mostly idiots. i'll wager two thirds of the fans who voted for redman did so because of mendenhall's comments about bin laden and 9/11 and not because of any football savvy insight. as for a 2 back set, dream on. pass happy brucey boy will never do that, whether it's a good idea or not. to be fair, i should mention that the biggest idiots of all are the sports reporters and analysts. mr. redman, mr. mendenhall, if you should happen to read the drivel posted here by simpletons with WAY too much time on their hands, please try your best to ignore it. you are both outstanding players, and complement each other perfectly. go stillers!
@bdity200 exactly!! Why don't we just go to a 2 back backfield so we keep teams guessing as to who's gonna get the ball. Oh and I have been a Steelers fan all 14 years of my life and I just am never all that impressed by Mendenhall. Yes he's faster and can spin out of tackles, but he's been known to fumble balls and drop passes. The only major fumble Redman has had was that awful one last year that brought back memories of Bettis.
I say lets use what we have and RUN them both!!!!
Redman is better with ball security, yards per carry, blocking and catching.
Yeah go head and start Mendenbutt
are you people kidding me, rashard is our back. we loved him last year when he rushed for over 1,000 yards. we cant just give up on him after a few mistakes. he's our back and were sticking with him.
no frank ur nuts im a long time fan and redman does not fumble, he doesnt make mistakes,
he moves the pile forward! he is the way steeler run offense should be!
You people are NUTS...if you think Redman is better than Mendenhall. Typical uneducated Steelers bandwagon fans! Probably the one's that wanted Fleury benched last season for Johnson.
Redman runs like Steeler running back of old His running style is more suitable for the steelers running game.A little bit like one of the best THE BUS