Totally agree... Erika was absolutely a talented, gifted, singer, and more professional than so many others! What a shame the judges didn't save her!!! Heejun should of been GONE WEEKS ago! Is this show and the results rigged? My husband and i are beginning to wonder???
Katherine StJames - 12 years ago
Heejun is a joke. Erika is a great talent. I agree, to let her go home the show must be rigged. Where do the judges think their save could be better used? I can not think of anyone who deserved it more than Erika. Shame on Randy, Jen and Steven.
Thomas Stigar - 12 years ago
Hejun is a big JOKE he has no talent, cannot unerstand him when he talks at times. Erika was the best of all three, the judges are a joke at times. It would not hurt my feelings if Ameican Idol was canceled next year. The judges do have thier favorites.
CS Legarra - 12 years ago
Erika was the better singer . Heejun should have gone home. He is only having a good time and is not a qualified competitive singer . The big flaw of American Idol still remains. Allowing each caller to vote an unlimited number of times does not allow for American Idol to invest in the most qualified singer. They could be a comedian like Heejun. Hope they change the voting format before the show becomes more of a big joke.
Beverly - 12 years ago
I can't believe the judges didn't keep Erika. She was the best of the three. Heejun should have gone this week. Who would miss him!! Erika will make her way and be a star. She was shining last night!
richard barbee - 12 years ago
Heejun needed to go! His performance up to this one. Has never been one to take to the bank. Erika out classed him all the way.
Tootser - 12 years ago
I've said it before and I'll say it again. To allow people to vote as often as they wish on the phone and computer is ludicrous! So Heejun has his friends and community voting till the cows come home and he has NO TALENT! This is a joke to him! It should be ONE VOTE PER PHONE AND EMAIL! This is not a fair contest. Erika should have stayed. It's apparent Heejun has a lot of people, maybe all of Chinatown, voting for him. He stinks and shouldn't have made the top 10. America doesn't vote for the talent; they vote for their FRIENDS!!! Get real, judges. Even you were shaking your heads that Erika got the boot. Where is Simon Cowell in all this????
Tanya D. - 12 years ago
Erika definitely should not have gone home. I agree Heejun is not taking the contest seriously and it was very unfair to send someone home who does take it seriously and is a talented singer. Judging should not be based solely on the viewing audience voting as they are not professionals and sometimes just vote for "who they like the best" not who sings the best. I believe the Judges should have a percentage of the voting power since they are the professionals, recognize true talent and don't vote merely on who they think is the cutest. Time for some changes to the judging process at Idol or they will lose their audience. I know many who stopped watching after Pia Toscano was voted off too early last year; another contestant who was highly talented. Idol wake up and amend the voting process before you lose all your audience! Erika goes and Heejun stays--that just made American Idol look like a joke!!! My suggestion, let the audience pick the bottom 3 and then let the Judges decide who goes home out of the bottom 3--NOW THAT WOULD BE FAIR!!!
Betty - 12 years ago
Just can't understand Erika being sent home. HeJun should have been the one to go.
He was not good at all, and seems not to care about his presentations, and actions.
How did this happen? Erika was one of the best singers, and should have been saved!
Dana Hammond - 12 years ago
I cant believe she left. she was the better singer of the three. This show must be truely rigged. I like Heejuns voice, but come on, he wasnt that good and I think he deserved to leave not Erica.
Totally agree... Erika was absolutely a talented, gifted, singer, and more professional than so many others! What a shame the judges didn't save her!!! Heejun should of been GONE WEEKS ago! Is this show and the results rigged? My husband and i are beginning to wonder???
Heejun is a joke. Erika is a great talent. I agree, to let her go home the show must be rigged. Where do the judges think their save could be better used? I can not think of anyone who deserved it more than Erika. Shame on Randy, Jen and Steven.
Hejun is a big JOKE he has no talent, cannot unerstand him when he talks at times. Erika was the best of all three, the judges are a joke at times. It would not hurt my feelings if Ameican Idol was canceled next year. The judges do have thier favorites.
Erika was the better singer . Heejun should have gone home. He is only having a good time and is not a qualified competitive singer . The big flaw of American Idol still remains. Allowing each caller to vote an unlimited number of times does not allow for American Idol to invest in the most qualified singer. They could be a comedian like Heejun. Hope they change the voting format before the show becomes more of a big joke.
I can't believe the judges didn't keep Erika. She was the best of the three. Heejun should have gone this week. Who would miss him!! Erika will make her way and be a star. She was shining last night!
Heejun needed to go! His performance up to this one. Has never been one to take to the bank. Erika out classed him all the way.
I've said it before and I'll say it again. To allow people to vote as often as they wish on the phone and computer is ludicrous! So Heejun has his friends and community voting till the cows come home and he has NO TALENT! This is a joke to him! It should be ONE VOTE PER PHONE AND EMAIL! This is not a fair contest. Erika should have stayed. It's apparent Heejun has a lot of people, maybe all of Chinatown, voting for him. He stinks and shouldn't have made the top 10. America doesn't vote for the talent; they vote for their FRIENDS!!! Get real, judges. Even you were shaking your heads that Erika got the boot. Where is Simon Cowell in all this????
Erika definitely should not have gone home. I agree Heejun is not taking the contest seriously and it was very unfair to send someone home who does take it seriously and is a talented singer. Judging should not be based solely on the viewing audience voting as they are not professionals and sometimes just vote for "who they like the best" not who sings the best. I believe the Judges should have a percentage of the voting power since they are the professionals, recognize true talent and don't vote merely on who they think is the cutest. Time for some changes to the judging process at Idol or they will lose their audience. I know many who stopped watching after Pia Toscano was voted off too early last year; another contestant who was highly talented. Idol wake up and amend the voting process before you lose all your audience! Erika goes and Heejun stays--that just made American Idol look like a joke!!! My suggestion, let the audience pick the bottom 3 and then let the Judges decide who goes home out of the bottom 3--NOW THAT WOULD BE FAIR!!!
Just can't understand Erika being sent home. HeJun should have been the one to go.
He was not good at all, and seems not to care about his presentations, and actions.
How did this happen? Erika was one of the best singers, and should have been saved!
I cant believe she left. she was the better singer of the three. This show must be truely rigged. I like Heejuns voice, but come on, he wasnt that good and I think he deserved to leave not Erica.