See this poll on: https://poll.fm/7210850/embed
Give others the chance to vote.
Share this poll, because the more votes the better.
Create your own.
Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.
closed
I vote for Starswirl!
Wait, is no one here going to mention how it should be Firefly, seeing as Lauren Faust thinks of her as Dash's MOM? Would be awesome if she showed up in that way.
Surprise would be great too, but may be a bit surreal to have two Pinkie Pies (oh...wait...). Pinkie pretty much is Surprise, so maybe she just needs to grow a pair of wings in an ep.
Minty for sure. I have been waiting to see her since season one~
No "Other" option?
Because the correct answer is Star Catcher.
The first three are automatically out. Firefly is Rainbow Dash, Surprise is Pinkie Pie and Posey is Fluttershy. They were simply renamed for FiM and updated a bit. As for Minty, as Rarity would say a green pony? How utterly atrocious. So out of these the obvious choice is Gusty. However I agree with another poster that Toola Roola would be a far better choice than any of these.
I bet Firefly would still win if Applejack was on this poll. She is a silly pony.
Uhm... where is the original Applejack..... or for that matter the original Twilight? Kimono perhaps as I've heard good things about her. Hm.. I can't really pick any of the given options because I think I only know two of them and the rest are from generations I've either never watched or never stood out to me.
I did end up voting for Gusty though. Why? Logic alone dictated my actions.
Wind Whistler! Wind Whistler! Wind Whistler!!! No other pony even comes close! Fizzy a distant second. North Star a weak third. Then for the hell of it Teddy from MLP Tales.
Minty should come first, cause her colors and style are the most different ones.
A fluttershy clone is uncalled for.
White skin is for rarity only (there can be only one marshmallow pony).
And firefly is RD combined with pinkie pie.
Only minty's left.
i feel so loved by the commenters(no really i rp as gusty on secondlife i like her that much)
In my collectiion of MLP art I have a copy of Artyl's G4 version of Gusty from early December of last year. It's a verra nice artwork. So I chose Gusty.
@Blayze Kohime: More like the Rainbow Dash of G1.
Firefly is best pony.
Of course Firefly is going to win; she's Lauren Faust's favorite G1 pony! She's the Luna of G1.
I have no idea who are those ..........
@Anon, no, you're thinking of G3. G1 was actually pretty good, for an 80s cartoon. It had tons of fantasy elements, lots and lots of monster villains, etc. etc....it was not all "teaparties and dressup" like G3 and G3.5 were.
How about NONE OF THESE.
Because anything before FiM was complete shit, with absolutely no conflict of meaning.
"Oh no, I can't attend the tea party today!"
"What should I get her for her birthday?"
As an artist, I'd kinda want Toola Roola from G3 to appear. :S
Firefly is best pony!
Surprise is already secretly in the show: http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/List_of_Wonderbolts#Surprise
An ep with surprise would be awesome! Can't help but think it would be hilarious too!
Firefly, so she can show Rainbow Dash how you can be a confident, skilled, awesome pegasus WITHOUT being a complete and total tool.
Firefly? Surprise? Posey? Nah. As Kazlene said, they're kinda already in the forms of RD, Pinkie, and Fluttershy in the show. Plus, wanting any of those three in the show (especially as the mothers of RD, Pinkie, and Fluttershy) is too manestream.
Minty? Nope. Also WAY too manestream, and I already have her as a pony in one of my headcanons for Apple Bloom's future.
So I guess I'll just be rolling with Gusty, then. I looked her up on My Little Wiki, and I think that it would be kinda cool to see her in the show.
i really wanna say surprise. but now that we know fireflys rainbows mom, i would much rather see what they do with that
This is a really difficult choice. I want all of them
What, no Wind Whistler? She was a genius.
Um, Fizzy.
No FIZZY???
Mimic.
No Mimic either. :(
Fine, Gusty.
Surprise, Firefly and Posey would be awesome but we already kind of have them in the forms of Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy. Now Gusty... Imagine a episode centered around her!
Yay...this was my question. But now I have to choose, DOH. I choose Minty.