I think Eli gets no respect just because he's Payton little brother. Everybody knows that football is about SUPER BOWL RINGS. Eli got 2, . Payton ,Brees,Rodgers,Farve & Flaco only have 1. And then you got Cam Newton, Michael Vick, Matthew Stafford, Matt Ryan, Rg3, Andrew Luck , Tony Romo & even Philip Rivers with no rings they always get pick before him. Only Big Ben who also got 2 rings may be as good as Eli, but I don't think so. And then you got Tom Brady with 3. But Eli beat him twice in The Super Bowl. So if we go by rings Eli got to be at least # 2 on the list. Please guys stop the hate against Eli.
Laurence Prairie - 11 years ago
Joe Morrison has to be the most underrated Giant. There wasn't any social media back then so he never got any publicity for his effort, grit, determination, perseverance, and results. In addition, he played on a mediocre team. I would also throw in Gary Reasons as he was always overshadowed by Harry Carson and Brad Van Pelt. They made a terrific LB corps.
John Calvin - 11 years ago
I have loved the Giants since 1956, still do, nothing like being a Giant fan, and as for who is
the most underrated, really, all of them? Eli gets the win only because of his work ethic, guiding the Giants
to 2 superbowl wins, and a great overall QB who is still active playing.
george ribaudo - 11 years ago
I remember all these players O.J. was great, so was meggit and morrison and chase was always one of my favorites ,but I look at all the receivers and tight ends eli has had over the years that left the giants and how anybody can say he doesn't make players better is beyond me.I cant think of any of this group that did better with out eli throwing them the ball . most are out of the game or you don't know their in it
I think Eli gets no respect just because he's Payton little brother. Everybody knows that football is about SUPER BOWL RINGS. Eli got 2, . Payton ,Brees,Rodgers,Farve & Flaco only have 1. And then you got Cam Newton, Michael Vick, Matthew Stafford, Matt Ryan, Rg3, Andrew Luck , Tony Romo & even Philip Rivers with no rings they always get pick before him. Only Big Ben who also got 2 rings may be as good as Eli, but I don't think so. And then you got Tom Brady with 3. But Eli beat him twice in The Super Bowl. So if we go by rings Eli got to be at least # 2 on the list. Please guys stop the hate against Eli.
Joe Morrison has to be the most underrated Giant. There wasn't any social media back then so he never got any publicity for his effort, grit, determination, perseverance, and results. In addition, he played on a mediocre team. I would also throw in Gary Reasons as he was always overshadowed by Harry Carson and Brad Van Pelt. They made a terrific LB corps.
I have loved the Giants since 1956, still do, nothing like being a Giant fan, and as for who is
the most underrated, really, all of them? Eli gets the win only because of his work ethic, guiding the Giants
to 2 superbowl wins, and a great overall QB who is still active playing.
I remember all these players O.J. was great, so was meggit and morrison and chase was always one of my favorites ,but I look at all the receivers and tight ends eli has had over the years that left the giants and how anybody can say he doesn't make players better is beyond me.I cant think of any of this group that did better with out eli throwing them the ball . most are out of the game or you don't know their in it
Rocky Thompson.........not.
bob hyland ....underrated