There is pretty much no argument that Randall played for by far the worst offensive coaches than either McNabb or Jaws. The fact that he was able to put up an MVP season under Rich Kotite seals it for me. Randall in his prime under Dick Vermiel might have been good enough to win a Super Bowl. Not sure I can say that about McNabb. Always seemed to find a way to lose on the biggest stage.
Why isn't Doug Pederson on this list?
There is pretty much no argument that Randall played for by far the worst offensive coaches than either McNabb or Jaws. The fact that he was able to put up an MVP season under Rich Kotite seals it for me. Randall in his prime under Dick Vermiel might have been good enough to win a Super Bowl. Not sure I can say that about McNabb. Always seemed to find a way to lose on the biggest stage.