This was definitely the WORST pairing ever. I know it's not going to win, but I had to go with The Giver because that is one of my favorite books of all time. Harry Potter is in a whole separate world. They should have pitted The Giver against something more similar.
roseymary - 10 years ago
Ugh this was the worst pairing. I wanted to choose the Giver soo badly, but nothing beats Harry Potter. These two series were the most influential books I read during my middle school years and I had to pick between them. It was like picking between two children. (But I had to go with Harry Potter, sorry Jonas)
What.
Why. Did you just?
How can someone pick between The Giver series or the Harry Potter series?
Danielle - 10 years ago
Of all the book series in this bracket game to compare, why did it have to be these two? Almost impossible to pick!!!!
JRummy - 10 years ago
This was a bit misleading, as it only mentioned Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets vs The Giver, not the whole darn series! If they want to make it the whole series to vote on, say so in the description!
GAR - 10 years ago
This is completely an unfair match up. I love both books but Harry Potter is commercialized. It has become it's own brand to the point where kids go to the amusement park and buy toys and movies instead of reading the actual book series.
Sunshine - 10 years ago
The Giver might be my favorite book of all time. But the HP Series is better than the 4 books in the quartet. This match up hurt my heart a little bit.
booklover19 - 10 years ago
Almost unfair - The Giver and most books by LL are wonderful - but nothing is going to beat HP, at least not until the finals (maybe).
Leave a Comment
Give others the chance to vote.
Share this poll, because the more votes the better.
This was definitely the WORST pairing ever. I know it's not going to win, but I had to go with The Giver because that is one of my favorite books of all time. Harry Potter is in a whole separate world. They should have pitted The Giver against something more similar.
Ugh this was the worst pairing. I wanted to choose the Giver soo badly, but nothing beats Harry Potter. These two series were the most influential books I read during my middle school years and I had to pick between them. It was like picking between two children. (But I had to go with Harry Potter, sorry Jonas)
Why? Why? Why must I choose? I can't.
What.
Why. Did you just?
How can someone pick between The Giver series or the Harry Potter series?
Of all the book series in this bracket game to compare, why did it have to be these two? Almost impossible to pick!!!!
This was a bit misleading, as it only mentioned Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets vs The Giver, not the whole darn series! If they want to make it the whole series to vote on, say so in the description!
This is completely an unfair match up. I love both books but Harry Potter is commercialized. It has become it's own brand to the point where kids go to the amusement park and buy toys and movies instead of reading the actual book series.
The Giver might be my favorite book of all time. But the HP Series is better than the 4 books in the quartet. This match up hurt my heart a little bit.
Almost unfair - The Giver and most books by LL are wonderful - but nothing is going to beat HP, at least not until the finals (maybe).