Looking at the welterweight rankins I can't believe you list Robert Guerrero, Kell Brook, Paquiao and Marquez above Maidana, Porter and Thurman. Maidana just got through destroying the Broner myth and is a titleholder, Porter beat Alexander and is a titleholder, and Thurman is considered the most promising and talented young fighter who would, IMO, destroy Kell Brook in a New York minute. Not only that but you have Paulie malignaggi rated above both Maidana and Broner who soundly defeated Paulie in their match.
IMO, Amir Khan should replace Malignaggi and Guerrero should be in the 10th spot. Khan destroyed Paulie and is in the running for the Money Mayweather sweepstakes along with Maidana. That alone raises his rank for the simple fact Khan will have an opportunity to win the belt.
Malignaggis' defeat of the fading Zab Judah was surprising but clearly not a defining victory that places him in the running for another title shot.
Looking at the welterweight rankins I can't believe you list Robert Guerrero, Kell Brook, Paquiao and Marquez above Maidana, Porter and Thurman. Maidana just got through destroying the Broner myth and is a titleholder, Porter beat Alexander and is a titleholder, and Thurman is considered the most promising and talented young fighter who would, IMO, destroy Kell Brook in a New York minute. Not only that but you have Paulie malignaggi rated above both Maidana and Broner who soundly defeated Paulie in their match.
IMO, Amir Khan should replace Malignaggi and Guerrero should be in the 10th spot. Khan destroyed Paulie and is in the running for the Money Mayweather sweepstakes along with Maidana. That alone raises his rank for the simple fact Khan will have an opportunity to win the belt.
Malignaggis' defeat of the fading Zab Judah was surprising but clearly not a defining victory that places him in the running for another title shot.