Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo

Pony War: Luna VS. Derpy! Who is the better fan favorite?! (Poll Closed)

  •  
     
  •  
     
Total Votes: 23,439
212 Comments

  • lordelliott - 10 years ago

    I voted Derpy, but I'm kind of glad Luna is winning to perpetuate the "Luna wins all polls" thing. I usually vote Luna anyway. :)

  • ShadowGentleman - 10 years ago

    DinaK, how did I know someone would pick up on that? Tell me how I could have revised that sentence while still including everyone? Also, I think you may have missed the point... Also, while i'm still here... can someone please tell me why the opinions of other people offends you? I see so many people go to arms over this, a lot of people like Luna, why is that such a terrible thing?

  • Frith - 10 years ago

    Nicole, another example of just how integral Derpy is to Bronies: In March 2011 Lauren Faust was donating MLP:FIM concept art (the original sketches of the ponies that were part of her pitch to Hasbro for MLP:FIM) to be auctioned in support of Japan. Major natural disaster in Japan in spring 2011. Along with the concept art she made a concept-art-style sketch of Derpy Hooves. Now that's meta. Lauren Faust, creator of MLP:FIM, made a sketch of a mostly fan-created character based on a background pony in a show that started out as her sketches. That's a full circle. The sketch raised a lot of money. And made a _lot_ of fans very happy. This is why Derpy, an animator's error, is such a huge thing for fans of the MLP:FIM show. It's like writing a new verse to your favorite song and finding that not only has the band heard your verse, but they now sing your verse as well at live performances from time to time.

  • MM - 10 years ago

    What!!!, Coco Pommel beated Luna and Derpy, how did that happen, she only appeared in one episode.

  • TwilightSparkles - 10 years ago

    I'm irritated.
    Stop doing stuff like that!!
    I wish Luna never came back and Derpy never had the animation error!
    You both act like animals two of ponies who aren't special in any way..
    ......
    No more wars!
    No more "best pony!"
    No more Luna!
    NO MORE DERPY FOR CELESTIA'S SAKE!

  • TwilightSparkles - 10 years ago

    Oh look who it is! Two of the most overrated ponies ever! Why don't you go see who's winning and became the new overrated pony over at Horse News? Trust me, it will blow your minds!!
    http://www.horse-news.net/2014/01/poll-results-should-seth-go-to-bed.htm
    This poll shouldn't even exist! Everyone's entitled to their own opinions
    but I just don't get it at all. Your stupid worshipping made me hate both of these characters, even though one never even had a focus for more than 1 minute. You guys should quit it with your best pony crap...
    Sure, everyone has their favorite ponies but it's just isn't fair that Luna is winning everything...
    I hate this.

  • ohhYUSH!! - 10 years ago

    i like to say something c: i kinda agree with you -.- i mean she would be just a normal backround pony i mean i hate her cause she always steals the show with her crap eyes screw her i mean it was RAINBOWDASH EPISODE not that backround pony episode

  • -.- - 10 years ago

    im not much of a fan of derpy ya would treat her just as the other backround ponies if it wasn't for her eyes -.-

  • :D - 10 years ago

    nicole i agree with you there i mean derpy isan that inportant and i like the twicane btw also not all bronies are like that i mean the creepy pastas like rainbow factory and cupcakes is pretty disturbing for bronies to make but those are the weird bronies just ignore it and just go with the normal bronies not with those cloppers and weirdos

  • Frith - 10 years ago

    Good morning Nicole. 8^) I've been a fan of MLP:FIM since early 2011, so much so that I created a MLP:FIM community on Dreamwidth and I've been nurturing it ever since. I think that the term Brony is a convenient term that means a fan of MLP:FIM, the animated series. The Brony fandom has a _long_ history of sharing opinions, theories and preferences without necessarily agreeing on them. As in 'opinion X is interesting and I'm glad it makes you happy but I don't necessarily think the same way'. Seeing what others take from MLP:FIM broadens my horizons! So, disagreeing with a lot of memes and what not does not make you less of a Brony. 8^) As for Derpy, sure she was an animation error, but she was an obscure animation error that the fans noticed and adopted. Derpy was like the secret Brony handshake -- you know who Derpy is then you have more than a casual knowledge of MLP:FIM. And when Derpy started getting included on purpose in the cartoon, that meant that the animators and show staff knew that we loved what they were doing. The fun had been doubled, we had touched the sky! It's the feedback through Derpy that makes her so popular, and we've built on that. Just like fans notice background characters that appeal to them and build them up. There are a lot of very creative Bronies, and since this fandom is very interactive, that creativity interacts as well to create elaborate stories for background ponies. As for jerks, there are jerks everywhere. Jerks rise up to annoy you because, well, they're jerks and they like to annoy. 8^D Don't let the jerks get you down.

  • Nicole - 10 years ago

    I'm confused whether I'm a "brony" or not... I LOVE MLP:FIM and is a huge fan, but I don't FEEL like a brony. I disagree with a lot of memes and fanon which just annoys me. Pinkamena meme/fanon for example: Bronies treat her like a different pony than Pinkie. I mean, come on! It's still Pinkie and it'll always be Pinkie, Pinkamena is just her full name while Pinkie is her nickname, she's ALWAYS the same pony whether her main is poofy or flat. I also fin the Twilight scepter annoying. Derpy is popular for no good reason. She never was an important character in the first place, just all fanservice from nothing more but a animation error. These people keeps getting more and more annoying, I've been wondering if I should stop my internet subscribtion and watch the show for what it is WITHOUT these so-called bronies ruining it for me. I know it's not all of you, but a lot of bronies I've seen are jerks. They even comment offensive things like it's not insulting people, but it does. Some might be close minded or immature and not know they offend, but I doubt it's that many because in real life I've never met anyone who's truly immature. Just childish, but that's nothing like immature. I never got the obsession with background ponies either. Sure some of them have really awesome designs and I love them, even reading stories about them and look at art. But I don't get the huge obsession people have over them and I dislike most of the popular fanons. So am I a brony or not, I'm pretty sure I'm not and is just "very huge fan" by now.

  • DinaK - 10 years ago

    I agree with you with everything else of course.

  • DinaK - 10 years ago

    ShadowGentleman, just wanted to say not all bronies wake up early to watch the episodes. When it's morning for you I (and many others) have been up for hours. When a new episode airs it's 16:30pm here when I stream, so definitely not moring. All bronies isn't American you know.

  • :D - 10 years ago

    YEA sure... you was joking we can vote for luna if we want noob

  • Arguologist - 10 years ago

    It seems I have at least 10,374 observant, worthy, kind, smart and admirable bros.
    And then there's a lot of slow witted loathesome morons who just take jokes too far.

    (joking)

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    ill wear a cup for no reason at all dude....also lunas kicking ass!

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    when the hell did you get here? you know what dont answer tell me at school. and ill wear my cleats cause were gonna play "kick ball(s)"

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    ya he sure is a real dick fart too get on his good side youll be let off with a kick in the dick

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    ty for the apology too
    ill give a truth....im 14 year old boy and shutterflys my sis juggernautsbrother is what else my brother and Matthew is my best friend who i rage at and pick on alot XD

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    ment to say it earlier but i was on keyboard arrest lol just felt like sharing

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    ok just needed to get that out sorry bout that lolz now no more bullshit ok :P

  • Juggernaut - 10 years ago

    ok hold on a second @bronies are a disgrace you do not talk to my friends like that you ugly piece of shit. if i were to meet you face to face id fucking rape you with a fucking cleaver and string your organs like christmas lights. if you hate the GET THE FUCK OUTTA HERE YOU DICKFUCK!

  • :+D YAY FOR LUNA - 10 years ago

    I vote for... LUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNA MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONA WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA LUNA!! LUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUNA! * cough* I like Luna.

  • Michi - 10 years ago

    Derpy is overrated, always has been.

  • a - 10 years ago

    Please, there's no need to fight. We can all stand united that Luna is best pony.

  • ShadowGentleman - 10 years ago

    @pinkaluna: You apologized, that's good enough for me. Hopefully here, that should be good enough for everybody as well. Thank you for being an honest, understanding human being.
    @:D Stranger things have happened...

  • :D - 10 years ago

    WELL sense everyone is telling the truth im gonna go ahead and tell the truth to im a girl and im 11 c:

  • pinkaluna - 10 years ago

    @ShadowGentleman I'm sorry man, I'm sorry for everything I said, my anger just got a hold of me because of all the trolls.

  • ShadowGentleman - 10 years ago

    Stop. Everyone, just...stop.
    @Bronies are a disgrace: Let me tell you about "Bronies". We get up in the morning, maybe eat breakfast, maybe skip it because we don't have time. Some of us go to high school, some of us go to college, some of us go to work, some of us do both, cause let's face it, the economy sucks right now. We have families; parents, children, siblings, significant others who love us and we love them back. As a collective, we make awesome music, write terrible to amazing story works, and give to charities. Sure, a few of us are crazy, and a few of us are hypocrites, but we're all human; for all of our eccentricities and outright craziness, we're all still very much human. You would disregard all of this-everything that we are- for our enjoyment of a TV show. I can't force you to leave, but seriously: what makes you think it is okay to decide to wake up and make fun of people for the way they live their lives? Hating someone for who they choose to be, when they've done nothing wrong to you, when you don't even know them, it's just... wrong. There is so much that is wrong here.

  • pinkaluna - 10 years ago

    If I was a real hater I would've been gone a long time ago.

  • pinkaluna - 10 years ago

    FINE I'm a brony, I just got sick of all the other bronies bullying me, so I decide to become a bully instead, I'm sorry but I just can't take these trolls anymore.

  • :D - 10 years ago

    also why cant you answer my question ''why are you cursing''? are you deep inside a brony but to afriad to show it come on friend you can do it (:

  • :D - 10 years ago

    keep talking

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    ya keep convincing yourself with that.

  • :D - 10 years ago

    and whats up with the cursing? i understand cause your dospit i want yourself to seem cool but your just making yourself look like a dumb weirdo camping on a pony website

  • \ - 10 years ago

    lol ge change the subject cause he know he mad cause he is getting pwned xD

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    Yes c'mon you little fuckers feed me with your anger, anyone else want a piece of me c'mon you scardy cats.

  • TWILIGHTISMAGIC - 10 years ago

    D bags? is this a kid or some fool being stupid

  • :D - 10 years ago

    lool you just described your self a spoiled **** who tries to troll on the computer cause he is to much of a wimp to fight

  • -.- - 10 years ago

    im dospit? coming from someone who doesn't know what gay means

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    I know what they mean stupid.

  • -.- - 10 years ago

    oh mind my bussiness? this is a full brony page are your the only anti brony please shut up if your gonna act dospit and not know what your talking about and if i was you i go get help and stop hatin

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    What you just said is one of the reasons why I quit the fandom, bronies pretend to love and tolerate, when in fact they're a bunch of spoiled little D bags.

  • \ - 10 years ago

    also you curse alot i wonder if your parents are ignorant and thats why you are c:

  • \ - 10 years ago

    Coming from someone who does not know what gay means or lebisan that sentence holds no wealth

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    you know what, why dont you just shove a dick up your mouth and mind your own fuckin business, you gay motherfucker.

  • -.- - 10 years ago

    im with :D on this i mean why come to a site to troll and make a fool of yourself? i mean this brony/anti brony war is getting old i mean we understand if you dont like the show but you dont have to come to pony related sites and be rude why cant you just Love And Tolroate (:

  • :D - 10 years ago

    clearly your just some ignorant noob coming on sites that you dont like if your gonna act ignorant go somewhere else and stop acting like a complte fool trying to troll but yet failing at it your even more worse then cloppers AND THATS SAYING SOMETHING!

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    Also @Patrick non of your fuckin business, what did you expect me to use a tiitle like sprinkles or rainbows just because this site is mlp related, well I'm not into this shit so fuck off.

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    NOW how I became an anti-brony, it's a really long story.

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    @ShadowGentleman Let me start by saying that I was a brony.

  • Patrick McCarthy - 10 years ago

    Remember dont feed the trolls. Also i would like to say that why would you post something on here with a title like bronies are a disgrace. This is a mlp related site why not take it to the message boards, yet you say it here because you are a troll plain and simple.

  • ShadowGentleman - 10 years ago

    @Bronies are a disgrace: I probably shouldn't, but i'm curious: What is your problem with the show? As in, the show itself, and not the people who watch it. Perhaps I could understand (not condone, understand) why you're anti-brony, if you could give me a solid answer as to why the show itself is so terrible . I, objectively, want to know: what is wrong with the show other than the fact that the assumed demographic is different than you expected? Is it the animation, the voice acting, the situations? I just want to know because I, personally, have not met an anti-brony who could give me a straight answer, the best I ever get is "it's not my thing", or some other piss poor excuse. If you have a reason to dislike it, fine, but coming here and saying stupid shit is old, you haven't said a single thing I haven't heard already.

  • Make - 10 years ago

    Luna or Derpy... If I just could vote twice :/

    (I voted for Derpy)

  • cake - 10 years ago

    Stop being such a dick, ok we get it you hate us, now leave us alone.

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    I know what I said dumbass, I called you lesbians because you watch a show for little girls which means that you are in fact little girls, thats why I didn't call you gay, cause your much worse , so If you want my advice why don't you just turn off your computer and go hump a barbie doll cause you like doing that.

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    But that basically means we are straight so if you said homosexuals than you'd be calling us gay....but you said LESBIANS instead of gay and that means you failed at your own troll???

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I say butterfly because she changed it to that. Also the hater bases ALL of us off of 3 or 4? What an idiot so fail.

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    Wow every one is coming together now! A butterfly would love this but that HATER would make her feel bad...though I refuse to rage at him any more so please if you hate us get off the site

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    WELL :D whoever you are, I was bored so I decided to see what you fags are up to and boy did I have fun reading your comments, you guys are such losers, I'd love to stay and chat some more, but I have much better things to do than taking to a bunch of lesbians.

  • Patrick McCarthy - 10 years ago

    Listen it is still close these 2 are some of the best characters in the fandom and I love Luna but I respect derpy because she has a disability and I do as well with asbergers. Whoever comes out on top one thing is for sure these are the two best ponies in the mlp universe by the fans. This is a tough call but I choose Luna because her design, backstory, character, and her apperance in the show and comics make her better than derpy who i will admit is adorable and quirky, but it takes more than adorableness to make me love a character it takes backstory, development, and designs to make me love a character. Still I love derpy and she is a great pony to represent the special ones, but Luna is better looking and I love her powers as being the one to control the night which is amazing. All I am saying is dont get your panties in a twist these are still 2 amazing ponies and deserve all the credit they receive.

  • tupek - 10 years ago

    I vote Derpi. I like Luna too.

    But Rainbow Dash is my favorite pony.

  • OmegaBrony - 10 years ago

    Luna best pony 4 ever

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    Band- as I said earlier my kindle auto corrects everything

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I apologize for my behavior earlier and I agree fully @Blacklight but we need to tear these favorite pony polls down if this continues we will be divided into 3 separate brony factions (lunar Republic, Muffin Armaggedon, and cloppers) so we need to back.d together and make sure no more best pony polls are made until season 9 :)

  • Blacklight - 10 years ago

    Man. You come to this comment section expecting a fun and funny conversation about two great characters in our fandom and I scroll through the comments expecting a great read and I get a whole thread of people cursing, swearing, at each other, trolling,, etc...
    What the heck happened to the Brony mantra of being nice to each other?
    There's no reason for this comment section to get all uncivilized and crap over two cartoon characters. Be grown ups people. We ARE capable of having civilized discussions about our favorite characters without devolving into swearing at each other and acting like two-year-olds.

  • :D - 10 years ago

    if we bronies are soooo ''patetic'' why did you come to eqestria daily just to say you dumb loser

  • freedosedonuts - 10 years ago

    Luna is kicking ass! Though I still like Derpy more.

  • juggernautsbrother - 10 years ago

    Shuterfly- sorry my spelling is awful lolz also she's managed to love and tolerate since the beginning so she expects more from us.... look at us fighting over the best pony. One doesn't simply choose a best pony.

  • juggernautsbrother - 10 years ago

    Lol bet no one expected Matthew, a butterfly, me, and juggernaut to be family. GO LUNA!!!

  • dragon - 10 years ago

    @shutterfly OH trust me dude everybody says that, but nobody actually means it.

  • shutterfly - 10 years ago

    That would be nice.

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    Wanna swap to Skype?

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I'm sorry... I'm just pissed off with a lot of trolling fucks who keep on the hate (not the most recent one who's interrupting a family feud)

  • shutterfly - 10 years ago

    Juggernaut please when you first joined the brony fandom you said to me face to face you'd do nothing but love and tolerate all!

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I have restated multiple times that I love Derpy too you motherfucker!!

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    My personnel favorite is luna too but give derpy some credit you ass

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    YOU SON OF A BITCH! I'm gonna fuck your shit up Matthew!!!

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    Man you bronies are so pathetic.

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    Apparently all you need to do to avoid pissing juggernaut off is have a name similar to fluttershys lol juggernaut has a soft spot

  • shutterfly - 10 years ago

    Your previous comments make it look like you hate her...

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I just did

  • shutterfly - 10 years ago

    But derpy is cute and we adopted her. Can't you show little kindness towards her?

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    Derpy is cool but Luna has been my favorite since nightmare night

  • bronies are a disgrace - 10 years ago

    hey fags, getting butthurt over something stupid.

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I know right they just can't get off my dick not my fault I'm sexy!

  • cake - 10 years ago

    You guys are acting like a bunch of monkeys fighting over a banana.

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    Also I DO have a hobby. It's building Mobile Suit Gundam model kits and Warhammer 40k if you think it means I have no life DAT SHIT IS EXPENSIVE

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    You should realize I'm trolling dipshit you fucking dick fart where do u live motherfucker?!

  • jtg445 - 10 years ago

    WAW, someone needs a hobby.

  • :D - 10 years ago

    jugg anger problems much? and you gonna come get us yea sure im waiting for you to come ignorant fool

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    BITCH I'M ALWAYS HERE YOU THINK YOU'RE SAFE BEHIND DAT FUCKING SCREEN?? I WILL FIND YOU AND KICK YOUR ASS SO MANY TIME AN_ when did derpy get those numbers? WHO THE HELL ARE YOU PEOPLE???

  • Matthew - 10 years ago

    Wow u use a lot of profanity juggernaut and juggernauts brother.... name your self what u want tell your brother to fuck off to the inner wall and jerk off like the chicken shit he is!

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    I agree COME LUNA YOU BEAT ALL!!! FACE IT MOTHERFUCKERS!!!!!

  • donstudios - 10 years ago

    GOOOOOOOOOO LUNAAAAA

  • juggernaut - 10 years ago

    If so get the fuck off the comments section. If you want to avoid trolls and people who love to piss you off (which I'm terrible at avoiding trolling jerk offs) than don't comment.

  • TY - 10 years ago

    violets are blue roses are red, you guys are so dumb, you're hurting my head.

  • pon3 - 10 years ago

    HA HA HA HA

  • juggernautsbrother - 10 years ago

    Because I'm insignificant....

  • ShutterFly - 10 years ago

    Ok this is difficult...I guess ill choose Derpy cause I feel bad for her....

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.